Sunday, November 22, 2026
Stefania Bianchi
- The European Commission has warned that a European Union-wide ban on Nazi symbols to be extended to Communist Party symbols as well would be ”unwise”.
European Commissioner for Justice, Freedom and Security Franco Frattini, said Monday much debate is still needed on how the bloc should tackle emotive symbols from its darkest past.
But Frattini’s spokesperson Friso Roscam Abbing went further in arguing that such bans are best left to individual European Union member states rather than the Union as a whole.
”It would be hard to explain and unwise if we were to try to harmonise it at EU level,” he told journalists on Tuesday, describing the issue as a ”perfect example” of where the EU should stay out of its members’ internal affairs.
Abbing recommended that the EU drafts a framework law to outlaw material ”which could lead to racism or xenophobia”, while leaving the details to its member states.
”I think it would be hard to explain and unwise if we tried to harmonise it at European level,” he said. ”It would be up to member states to decide when and which symbols would lead to such criminal offences.”
The EU is considering banning the swastika and other Nazi symbols after British Prince Harry, the 20-year-old grandson of Queen Elizabeth II, was photographed wearing a swastika armband to a New Year’s Eve fancy dress party.
German Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) in particular have demanded action over the Nazi symbols at EU level, although more cautious British officials say important freedom- of-speech questions were at stake along with the rights of EU member states.
The proposal, which could include a ban on all Nazi symbols, aims to set EU-wide standards on fighting racism, anti-Semitism and other forms of discrimination.
The swastika, adopted as the symbol of Nazism is derived from the Sanskrit ‘svastika’, which means ‘conducive to well-being’.
The European Parliament passed a unanimous resolution late last month urging a Europe- wide ban on incitement to racial and religious hatred but the proposals need agreement of all 25 EU governments.
MEPs from central and Eastern Europe also joined the furore last week to demand that the insignia of the former Soviet Union such as the hammer-and-sickle be outlawed, noting that the late Soviet ruler Joseph Stalin was if anything even more murderous than Germany’s Adolf Hitler.
Lithuanian MEP Vytautas Landsbergis and Hungarian MEP Jozsef Szajer called last month on Frattini to press for the former Soviet symbol ban.
The two MEPs said that if Nazi symbols are to be banned at EU level, then former Soviet symbols ought to be as well.
”We would like to have an equal treatment of the other evil totalitarian regime of the Communist system,” said Szajer.
However, Frattini rebuffed these calls in a letter Monday to the two MEPs who had made the request, calling instead for a ”wide-ranging European debate” on the issue.
Frattini’s letter to Szajer and Landsbergis said the ”Europe of today was united and free precisely because it had freed itself of the two great authoritarian regimes of the 20th century – Nazism and Communism”.
Frattini also pointed out that there had often been disagreement between historians about whether Soviet and Nazi era crimes could be compared.
”They differed in their origin and fate, but were similar in having slaughtered perfectly innocent people regarded as objective enemies,” he added.
Frattini’s latest comments represent a stepping back for the European Commission, the EU executive. Last month he had spoken generally in favour of such a ban.
”EU action is urgent and has to forbid very clearly the Nazi symbols in the European Union,” the European commissioner said last month.
Many European Union officials say that a EU-wide ban on either Nazi or former Soviet symbols would be extremely difficult to put into place, as it would be difficult to legislate the ban. The question is whether satirical articles or cartoons containing the symbols would also fall foul of the law.
Justice and interior ministers from the 25 EU nations will discuss the banning of Nazi symbols at a meeting on Feb. 24.