Headlines

ENVIRONMENT: Suspicions Remain Over China’s Greeting of Kyoto Protocol

Antoaneta Bezlova

BEIJING, Feb 16 2005 (IPS) - China has greeted the start of the Kyoto Protocol on climate change with a dramatic display of new green policies, but observers fear the surprise move would remain a symbolic victory rather than a practical one for environmentalists in the most populous nation.

China has greeted the start of the Kyoto Protocol on climate change with a dramatic display of new green policies, but observers fear the surprise move would remain a symbolic victory rather than a practical one for environmentalists in the most populous nation.

China is the world’s second largest source of greenhouse gases – the main cause of global warming and the International Energy Agency in Paris predicts that the increase in greenhouse gas emissions from 2000 to 2030 in China alone will nearly equal the increase from the entire industrialised world.

But the Kyoto Protocol, which came into effect on Feb. 16, exempts China – as a developing country – from obligations to reduce emissions. Along with India – another major contributor to the world’s greenhouse gases, China is under no obligation to cut emissions during the protocol’s first phase to 2012.

U.S. President George W Bush has cited the exemption of developing countries from treaty obligations as one of the reasons for refusing to join the Kyoto Protocol, calling it ”fatally flawed”.

The Untied States walked away from the international treaty in 2001 saying the prospect of growing emissions of carbon dioxide from an economic powerhouse such as China rendered it useless.


But in a dramatic green U-turn in recent weeks, China has abruptly slowed and halted work on building 22 major energy projects to assess their environmental impact. The Chinese State Environment Protection Agency, the country’s top environmental regulator, long considered a toothless bureaucracy, has challenged the country’s powerful energy industry demanding that power projects should not proceed until their impact on the environment had been reviewed.

The suspended energy projects are worth more than 14 billion U.S. dollars and span some 13 provinces in the country. Topping the banned list is a power plant that is part of the Xiluo dam project, operated by the China Three Gorges Project Corp, developer of the highly controversial Three Gorges Dam – the world’s biggest hydroelectric power project.

In another step aimed at reducing pollution, the State Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) ordered 46 power plants last month to install de-sulphurisation units or face closure.

China’s unprecedented move has been met with ovations both at home and abroad. Last week British Prime Minister Tony Blair congratulated China on its readiness to ”take a real lead” in combating global warming.

Inside the country, environmentalists and state media have hailed the move as a sign of growing awareness among the leadership that polluting industries should not fund China’s economic progress.

SEPA’s bold move has been widely described as China’s ”environmental storm”.

”Only an environmental storm can bring about an industrial clean-up and give a jolt to the heavy polluters,” said the ‘China Economic Times’, which is published by the State Council’s Development Research Centre.

The clean-up order has reverberated because it is unusual for an agency like SEPA – with little political clout and a role in policy-making – to take on well-connected state-owned firms, like the China Three Gorges Project Corp, that operate massive public works and provide energy and employment.

But recent years have also seen the emergence of new public consciousness about the sober implications of China’s gallop towards a Western-style consumer society.

”There are some 70 environmental groups doing things at local level,” said Nick Yong of the Beijing-based China Development Brief that tracks the development of non-governmental groups in the country.

”They are pro-active and effective,” he said.

But it could just be a pyrrhic victory for the environmentalists. Investigative reports last week in the ’21st Century Business Herald’ newspaper claimed that many of the suspended projects have resumed construction and some have even gone into power production.

In an article dated Feb. 7, the paper quoted unnamed sources from Guodian Power Corporation, one of China’s main power developers, as saying that the reports about the halt have been ”false”. ”Many of the stations are ready to start power generation,” the official said.

Reporters alleged that at least three of the projects – Xutang power station, Xuanwei power station in Yunnan province and Shuzuishan power station in Ningxia province, were continuing construction. According to the paper, installed units of the Yunnan power station have already gone into production.

Under Chinese laws, power producers have to submit environmental impact assessment studies before work on large projects can even start. In the past, however, many chose to forego the regulations.

The China Three Gorges Project Corp. for example, argued that one of their targeted projects – the Xiluo dam power station, had received approval from the highest level – the National Development and Reform Commission, the country’s central planning authority.

SEPA can opt to fine the developer of any illegal project up to 24,000 U.S. dollars but analysts point out that this is just peppercorn money for mighty companies like the China Three Gorges Project Corp. Their biggest project – the Three Gorges Dam, when completed in 2009 is projected to cost 30 billion U.S. dollars.

”Millions of yuan have been invested in all of the targeted projects and if they are not built there would be not only even greater shortage of energy but also a great financial risk for the banks that have lent the money,” said the ’21st Century Business Herald’.

China’s dilemma arises from its current energy crunch and the big demands for more power for its voracious economy, which grew last year at a whopping 9.5 percent. Because China’s economy is relatively energy inefficient, each one percent decline in the GDP growth rate is expected to trim two percent from growth in power demand.

Power shortages in China since 2003 have led to the rapid proliferation of power plants and officials say they recorded the highest construction of them in 2004. Nevertheless, energy analysts say the country is on track to add 562 coal-fired plants – nearly half the world total of plants expected to come online in the years up to 2012, when the first phase of the Kyoto Protocol ends.

China continues to rely on coal for 70 percent of its energy, spewing out some 19 million tons of sulphur dioxide a year (the U.S. produces 11 million tons a year) and contributing mightily to acid rain.

If the economy keeps soaring along, within three decades China could overtake the U.S. as the world’s largest source of greenhouse gases.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Asia-Pacific, Climate Change, Economy & Trade, Environment, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT: Suspicions Remain Over China’s Greeting of Kyoto Protocol

Antoaneta Bezlova

BEIJING, Feb 16 2005 (IPS) - China has greeted the start of the Kyoto Protocol on climate change with a dramatic display of new green policies, but observers fear the surprise move would remain a symbolic victory rather than a practical one for environmentalists in the most populous nation.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags