Africa, Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Europe, Headlines, North America

DEVELOPMENT: Caught Between EU and U.S.

Stefania Bianchi

BRUSSELS, Feb 25 2005 (IPS) - African, Caribbean and Pacific countries fear that a renewed partnership agreement with the European Union could threaten their trade relationship with the United States.

After almost one year of negotiations, the European Union (EU) concluded ministerial negotiations on the revision of the Cotonou agreement with a group of African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) countries late Wednesday evening (Feb. 23)..

While the ACP group of countries welcomed the efforts and concessions made by the European Commission, the EU executive, and the Luxembourg presidency of the EU, they expressed regret that the outcome of the negotiations "did not meet all ACP expectations.."

The Cotonou agreement, which links the EU and 77 ACP countries was signed in June 2000 in Cotonou in the West African country Benin.

The deal is designed to fight poverty through political dialogue, development aid and closer economic and trade cooperation, and requires ACP countries enjoying special trading status with the EU to respect human rights and democratic principles.

The agreement has to be reviewed every five years.


Outstanding issues which had not been resolved during earlier talks included a reference to the non-proliferation of weapons of mass destruction (WMD), the International Criminal Court (ICC) and negotiations on a new financial protocol.

The EU had been pushing ACP countries to agree to ratify the ICC as part of the negotiations. But ACP countries remain concerned that any inclusion of the ICC in the new agreement will threaten their own trade relations with the United States.

The ICC, which came into being a year ago, is the first permanent global criminal court to try individuals for genocide, war crimes and massive human rights abuses.

But the court has been an irritant in trans-Atlantic relations since 2001 when President George W. Bush started his first term in office. While the EU champions the court, the United States has refused to sign up to it.

"There are some concerns that the mention of the ICC in the agreement will jeopardise our trade relations with the United States," ACP spokesman Hegel Goutier told IPS Friday (Feb. 25).

The EU also added a clause tying the non-proliferation of weapons of mass destruction (WMD) to eligibility for EU aid – an article which has been a sticking point during the negotiations.

"Although both parties recognise the proliferation of WMDs as an essential element of the Cotonou agreement, ACP countries don’t produce weapons of mass destruction. We are the victims of them and want to work against them so they should not have been an essential element of the negotiations," said Goutier.

The EU agreed to provide ACP states with additional resources to enable them to fight against the proliferation of these weapons, and also accepted ACP proposals to designate the international organisations qualified to judge violations of such agreements..

A new financial protocol was also negotiated for the next five years.

The EU agreed to make available to the ACP countries a sum at least equivalent to that of the 9th and current European Development Fund (EDF) "with a percentage increase based on the EU inflation rate, the EU’s growth rate, and contributions from the 10 new EU member states." The EDF delivers development aid to ACP countries.

Brussels also pledged to make additional budget lines available to the ACP states to offset potential adverse effects of the regional trade Economic Partnership Agreements (EPAs) and the bloc’s sugar regime which will come into effect in 2006.

While the ACP group welcomed the new financial provisions and support for the effects of the changing trade relationships, it says a fixed sum of funding would have been preferable.

"We are pleased that the financial protocol will not be lower than the current EDF, but the ACP group would have preferred to obtain a guarantee on a fixed sum for the next financial protocol which will show a net increase compared to the 9th EDF," Goutier said.

"The current financial protocol includes not only the 9th EDF, but also the balance from the preceding EDFs. Consequently, the ACP states have approximately 22 billion euros (29 billion dollars) at their disposal. However, even the lower range of the proposed amount for the next protocol will not match that sum," he added.

The European Commission says the aim of the negotiations has been to "improve the efficiency and to strengthen the quality of the partnership" while preserving the fundamentals of the Cotonou agreement.

"This agreement is an important step in strengthening the efficiency and quality our partnership with ACP countries. This is a balanced package. It has financing which aims to be sustainable over the long term, and stronger security and human rights provisions," José Manuel Barroso, president of the European Commission said Thursday (Feb. 24).

Jean-Louis Schiltz, Luxembourg minister for cooperation and humanitarian action, whose country currently holds the rotating presidency of the EU, said the agreement marked an important step for development.

"This meeting was the first important north-south encounter of 2005. With this agreement, we are beginning 2005, which has to be the year of development, on the right foot. The agreement we have reached also demonstrates the quality of the relation between the ACP countries and the European Union," he added

The revised version of the Cotonou Agreement is expected to be signed in Luxembourg in June 2005..

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags