Civil Society, Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

RIGHTS-EGYPT: NGOs Stifled By Heavy Gov’t Hand, HRW Says

William Fisher

NEW YORK, Jul 6 2005 (IPS) - Non-governmental organisations in Egypt are being strangled by a law severely restricting their activities and by the "extra-legal role" of the country’s Security Services, a new report from Human Rights Watch (HRW) charges.

"Civil society groups in Egypt face severe restrictions under the law governing non-governmental organisations (NGOs). In addition, the country’s security services scrutinise and harass civil society activists even though the law does not accord them any such powers," an HRW spokesman said.

The 45-page report, "Margins of Repression: State Limits on Nongovernmental Organisation Activism," concludes that "the most serious barrier to meaningful freedom of association in Egypt is the extra-legal role of the security services".

The report documents numerous cases where the security services rejected NGO registrations, decided who could serve on NGO boards of directors, harassed NGO activists, and interfered with donations reaching the groups.

It says that while the current law, which went into effect in 2003, is an improvement over the previous law, "its provisions – and the broad and arbitrary way it is applied – violate Egypt’s international legal obligations to uphold freedom of association."

"The law prohibits political and union-related activity, and allows the authorities to dissolve organisations by administrative order. It continues a host of intrusive administrative practices that stunt organising by civil society groups, and provide ample means for state interference in their affairs."


"There is a difference between ensuring that civil society groups are accountable to the public and enhancing the state’s power to police and stifle the work of these groups," said Joe Stork, deputy Middle East director at Human Rights Watch. "Egypt’s laws and practices fall squarely in the latter category."

HRW called on the government to amend the law to make NGO registration voluntary and abolish penalties for participating in unregistered NGOs. The authorities should also remove all restrictions on peaceful activities that amount to the exercise of freedom of expression, freedom of association and freedom to participate in public life.

Dr. Mohammed Zaki Gomaa, one of Egypt’s leading authorities on NGOs, told IPS, "The HRW report is right in documenting such negative public interventions in the associations’ activities and the need for change. There have been frequent changes to amend this law – almost one change every two years, but without real change."

"There is a need for a new project from USAID (the U.S. Agency for International Development) to advise on real legislative change and make sure it conforms to international standards," he added.

USAID recently announced grants totaling 1 million dollars to six NGOs involved in electoral issues, the first of their kind of the 25-year history of U.S. assistance to Egypt.

One of the grants went to the Ibn Kaldoun Centre for Development Studies, whose founder, Dr. Saad Eddin Ibrahim, was jailed for seven months in 2000 on charges connected to their work, before being acquitted in a high-profile retrial of his case in 2003.

The HRW report said the government should:

Amend the law to abolish penalties for participation in unregistered NGOs; and remove restrictions on their ability to affiliate with other NGOs.

Remove all restrictions on peaceful activities that amount to the exercise of internationally-recognised human rights to freedom of expression, freedom of association, and freedom to participate in public life.

Ensure that any involuntary dissolution of an NGO takes place only by judicial order and only as a result of the most egregious violations.

Permit receipt of donations or transfers from foreign donors.

Abolish the requirement that NGOs seek permission from the Ministry of Insurance and Social Affairs (MISA) to work in more than one field of activity or governorate (roughly similar to states in the U.S.).

"Government regulations should help citizens to form groups, raise money and carry out needed work," Stork said. "If people cannot form civil society organisations and run them without heavy state interference, the chances of developing a functioning democracy will shrink."

The Egyptian government has no legitimate interest in choosing who can sit on a board of directors, approving invitations to conferences, or reviewing minutes of meetings and deciding how often executive committees can meet, Human Rights Watch said.

In an earlier report, HRW charged that the Egyptian government is using national security to stifle dissent.

It says the Egyptian government has detained hundreds of Muslim Brotherhood members solely for exercising their rights to freedom of speech, association and assembly.

"The Egyptian government should not use public security as a pretext to punish people for peacefully trying to exercise their basic rights," Stork said. The Muslim Brotherhood, a banned but tolerated group, staged large demonstrations in Egyptian cities in early May calling for political reform. At least 800 members were arrested, and more than 300 are still in custody, most without charge. In a letter sent to President Hosni Mubarak, Human Rights Watch called on the government to release the detainees without delay.

The new report comes as Mubarak has taken limited steps to open the political process by amending the constitution to allow multi-party elections for president for the first time. However, many critics say the new election law is a sham that makes it virtually impossible for political parties to win approval for their candidates.

But California State University professor of international relations Beau Grosscup told IPS, "The government’s tight control of NGOs in Egypt is one more piece of evidence that the Bush administration’s praise for Egypt’s ‘move to democracy’ is strictly a public relations campaign."

"Freedom of association and citizens’ unfettered participation in civic and social affairs are true hallmarks and requirements of democracy in form and substance," he said.

The 76-year old Mubarak has ruled Egypt for 24 years, being "reelected" three times in one-person referenda. He has not publicly declared his candidacy for another term, but is widely expected to run.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags