Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Poverty & SDGs

ENVIRONMENT-LATIN AMERICA: Laws Don’t Work If They’re Only on Paper

Raúl Pierri

MONTEVIDEO, Aug 9 2005 (IPS) - The governments of Latin America and the Caribbean will not be able to curb the growing environmental destruction in the region unless they enforce the laws and international conventions they have adopted, fight poverty, and put a stop to the interference of big corporations in their public polices.

This was the consensus reached by 35 experts from 10 countries in the region who have gathered for seven days in Montevideo to draw up the agenda for issues to be addressed in the next Global Environment Outlook (GEO), a periodic, comprehensive environmental report organised by the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP).

The GEO reports are produced through a participatory and consultative approach with input from the international, regional and national levels. Three have been published so far, in 1997, 1999, and 2002, and the next is scheduled for completion in 2007.

In an interview with IPS, Ricardo Sánchez, the director of the UNEP Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean, commented that the region’s governments “demonstrate a certain political will for protecting the environment. They have laws, they have ministries and parliamentary commissions, but there hasn’t been enough progress in making environmental policies a crosscutting issue.”

The result, he said, is that “countries undertake a great many projects aimed at development that focus solely on economic growth, without taking environmental impact into account. There needs to be a greater will on the part of governments to include the environmental aspect in all sectors, in order to genuinely pursue a strategy of sustainable development,” he stressed.

“It should be made clear that the most important thing is not growth at any cost, but rather growth in terms of quality, growth in those aspects that have a greater impact on people’s quality of life, in balance with the ecosystems,” he added.

The GEO reports are drawn up in coordination with governments, civil society and academia. They do not simply provide a diagnosis of the state of the environment, but also put forward proposals for action through public policies, Eduardo Gudynas, director of the Latin American Centre for Social Ecology (CLAES), told IPS.

CLAES, based in Uruguay, is one of the GEO collaborative centres that participate in coordinating the input for the report from the Latin American and Caribbean region.

At the Forum of Environment Ministers of Latin America and the Caribbean, held in Panama in 2003, the participants resolved to follow the recommendations put forward in the GEO reports.

The experts who are meeting in Montevideo until Wednesday have compiled a list of “grave” environmental problems facing the region: deforestation, soil degradation, water and air pollution, inadequate disposal of urban solid waste, and the situation of thousands of peoples living without access to basic public services like drinking water and sanitation.

However, one of the greatest concerns expressed at the meeting was the failure of governments to comply with their own environmental regulations, reported Edgar Gutiérrez Ezpeleta, director of the University of Costa Rica Development Observatory.

“The countries make commitments on a global level through conventions, but at the national level, they neither fulfil them nor ensure that they are fulfilled. I would say that Latin America has sufficient regulations for making proper use of natural resources in an efficient manner, but they are not applied,” Gutiérrez Ezpeleta remarked to IPS.

He also stressed the danger posed by the growing interference of multinational corporations in the public policies of Latin America and the Caribbean.

“Companies negotiate with a small number of people in Latin American countries, almost always with the economy minister and the president. There is a process whereby national democracies are being transformed into what have been called ‘delegatory democracies’, in the sense that only one or two people in the government take part in negotiations and adopt major decisions,” he said.

“The corporations like this, because they only have to deal with one or two people. They don’t have to talk with the congress or with eight different ministers,” he added.

Gutiérrez Ezpeleta maintained that when governments “put financial needs before the well-being of the population, the country starts heading downhill.”

“Getting caught up in the wild race to achieve economic growth or attract investment and boost exports is turning our countries into what they were during the colonial era – mere exporters of natural resources. This is neither sustainable nor just,” he said.

The experts agreed that the next GEO report on Latin America and the Caribbean should highlight the importance of including the environmental component in trade and regional integration initiatives.

“There is a major challenge facing Latin America. This is a region with natural wealth unlike any other area in the world. However, it is not used in accordance with local needs, but rather the needs created by consumption in the countries of the North. This poses an enormous challenge, because while it is true that this demand brings in financial resources, it also represents a formidable potential for environmental degradation,” said Gutiérrez Ezpeleta.

“This shows us that we should be seeking a new kind of integration. Not just trade-related integration, but rather integration that includes aspects like cooperation, mutual understanding and ethics, that can promote our relations with other parts of the world on the basis of trade that is more just, more equitable and mutually beneficial,” he added.

The experts gathered in Montevideo also emphasised the need for governments to address environmental issues from an integrated perspective, while stepping up efforts to combat poverty.

“Environmental matters are not only environmental, because they are also linked to social, economic and institutional issues, just as economic matters are no longer simply economic, because they are connected to social and environmental questions. Everything is interconnected,” stressed Gutiérrez Ezpeleta.

“And if this interconnection isn’t grasped, we are going to continue fostering partial visions and short-term strategies that lead to what we have observed in Latin America: an accelerated process of environmental degradation,” he concluded.

 
Republish | | Print |