Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights

PAKISTAN: Clemency for Indian Spy on Death Row Gets Complicated

Muddassir Rizvi

ISLAMABAD, Aug 29 2005 (IPS) - -As passions mount on both sides of the Indo- Pakistan border over the death sentence awarded to Sarabjit Singh for espionage, the issue of presidential clemency for the Indian national is getting ever more complicated.

Legislators, the media and civil society groups here are urging the government to make good use of what they see as an opportunity to secure, in exchange for Singh’s life, the freedom of hundreds of Pakistani citizens believed to be languishing in Indian jails.

But success in meeting popular demands on both sides would depend on any understanding that may be reached between leadership of the rivaling neighbours that are engaged in a serious peace dialogue.

The question of clemency for Sarabjit Singh, alias Manjit Singh, is already creating uneasiness in the relationship between the nuclear- armed neighbours, because both governments are under intense public pressure at home.

Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has promised that he would personally get in touch with Pakistan President Gen. Pervez Musharraf to see about clemency for Singh. This, after Singh’s family in India’s Punjab state threatened to commit suicide en masse if the sentence is carried out.

The Singh issue has put the Pakistani government in an awkward position.

”The involvement of Indian leadership on the issue has linked Singh’s sentence to the sustainability of the ongoing peace process between the two countries as they are currently only focusing on confidence building measures,” said Zafar Nawaz Jaspal, a professor of international relations at the Quaid-e-Azam University in the national capital.

” Islamabad must move cautiously (on the Sarabjit issue) ,” Jaspal warned.

Singh was convicted by a Pakistani court on charges of involvement in the killing of 14 people in bomb attacks in Lahore, Sialkot and Kasur in 1990, besides espionage.

Having exhausted all appeals, even at the country’s apex court, his life now depends on a presidential pardon that is still available under clemency clauses in the constitution.

The situation presents a real test for Musharraf who may use the situation to maintain the goodwill he enjoys with the Indian leadership. On the other hand, if he does exercise the presidential prerogative, he is bound to annoy the right wing political parties and sections of the public.

Religious groups, are already on the war path against the government for a crackdown ordered on religious schools and groups, in the aftermath of the London suicide bombings last month, and are looking for soft spots to attack the general.

Moreover, pardoning Sarabjit will also compromise Islamabad’s stated position that it will mete out exemplary punishment to all convicted terrorists.

Besides Musharraf must consider that he did not pardon Islam Siddiqui, a low-ranking soldier, who was hanged to death earlier this month for his involvement in a plot assassinate the president, last year.

Five others have also been handed down the death penalty for involvement in the same plot.

”He shouldn’t pardon the killer of 14 people if he could not forgive somebody for attempting his assassinationàonly the heirs of Sarabjit’s victims are entitled to grant clemency. This is what Islam teaches,” commented Fida Mohammad, a supporter of the fundamentalist, Jamaat-i- Islami party.

Amid such sentiments, it will be difficult for Musharraf to justify clemency for Singh to the local audience.

At the same time there have been calls by some Islamic groups that Islamabad demand clemency for Mohammad Afzal, an alleged Pakistani who was recently convicted by the Indian Supreme Court for orchestrating an attack on the Indian parliament in December 2001.

”Afzal is innocent and the government of Pakistan must ask India to spare his life,” said a press statement issued this weekend by the United Jihad Council, an alliance of Muslim groups that support armed resistance in Indian-controlled Kashmir.

The peace lobby in the country is also not too sure about what line of action the government should take on the Singh issue, perhaps in view of its stated commitment to efforts against terrorism.

”Islamabad should allow the Indians to look at the evidence that led to Sarabjit Singh’s conviction and sentencing,” comments peace activist Francisco D’sa, who is also coordinator of the Islamabad-based Citizens Peace Committee.

But he believes that both Pakistan and India should keep in mind the larger objectives of peace. ”Singh’s execution may have serious repercussions for Indo-Pak relations as well as for Pakistanis visiting India.”

D’sa said that no matter what is done, prompt measures should be initiated for the reciprocal freedom of the prisoners in each other’s countries.

According to a spokesperson for the Foreign Office, as many as 611 Pakistanis are currently confined in Indian jails. The number includes 52 fishermen, who entered Indian waters by mistake.

Most of the detainees are being held for straying into the Indian territory, overstaying their visas and visiting cities not permitted on their travel documents. ”None of these crimes merit more than a few months of punishment,” commented Nadir Altaf, a senior advocate.

”We have been able to confirm the identities of 173 prisoners, while the identification of 178 is in process,” said the spokesperson.

Earlier, the foreign office said that it has been pressing India to grant consular access to 208 jailed Pakistanis, but had yet to get a response. Pakistan, on the other hand, holds 576 Indian prisoners in its jails.

Anees Jilani, a senior advocate and a child rights activist, considers the attitude of officials of both countries ”uncivilised, apathetic and corrupt”. To him, it is just like punishing citizens just because they belong to the other side.

Prof Jaspal believes that, handled with prudence, the issue of clemency for Singh could lead to headway on the prisoners issue.

”Sarabjit Singh’s execution may affect the fate of the prisoners. The president can commute Sarabjit Singh’s sentence to life imprisonment. Having spent almost 15 years in jail, he might be able to walk out quicklyàsuch an effort could be face-saving for both governments and maintain the level of goodwill that is (already) established,” he suggested.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags