Development & Aid, Headlines, Health, Human Rights, North America

POLITICS: Female Circumcision Jeopardises Somali Refugees’ Plans

Gabriel Packard

NEW YORK, Nov 7 2002 (IPS) - Refugee advocacy groups say that U.S. officials should try to educate Somali asylum-seekers about the negative health effects of female circumcision rather than threaten to block their migration to the United States.

Last month, the U.S. embassy in Kenya said that it would likely prevent refugees who had performed the procedure, known in the West as female genital mutilation (FGM), from migrating to the United States.

Aid workers in refugee camps have recently reported that Somali Bantu refugees bound for the United States had performed a large number of the procedures after learning that it is illegal in their future home.

Although they oppose the practice, groups that work with refugees say that a different approach that emphasises education can reduce the frequency of FGM.

"It’s good that the U.S. government is taking a stand against female genital mutilation, but I don’t think they’re going about it the right way," said Evan Simpson of the Program for Appropriate Technology in Health (PATH).

PATH has helped develop alternative rights of passage ceremonies to provide an alternative to FGM. They educate girls about reproductive health, peer pressure and other related issues.

"These have resulted in a significant decrease in FGM in Kenya, where we are most active," said Simpson, who suggested that the U.S. government could have focused on educating women about health issues. "It takes more than a firm policy against it to bring an end to this practice."

"I would raise questions about U.S. doctors examining girls,” he added. ”This could lead to further traumatising."

Some of the Somali Bantus have spent a decade in Kenyan refugee camps and experienced lifelong persecution only to find that at the last minute they might be denied access to the United States.

"The Somali Bantus apparently understood that circumcision would be illegal in the United States," said U.S. Embassy spokesman in Kenya, Tom Hart, in October. "And the result of this is them circumcising their girls before leaving."

Doctors will be asked to identify families with recently circumcised girls, Hart said. "When identified, those cases will be suspended and very likely they will denied resettlement in the United States."

There will also be a publicity campaign to warn Bantus of the health risks of the practice and that it may jeopardise their chances of resettlement in the United States, he added.

Since that statement, neither the Embassy nor the State Department will confirm that the families will be denied immigration. "We are aware of the press reports," said one State Department official. "And we are seriously considering the next step."

Earlier, Hart had condemned the traditional circumcision ceremony as a crime, regardless of cultural sensitivity.

In a brief statement the Embassy said, "the United States government finds the practice of female genital mutilation to be abhorrent and strongly condemns this practice”.

The type of circumcision practiced by the Bantu consists of removing the clitoris and labia, and sewing up the vagina; a small opening is left for urine and menstrual blood. This process, known as infibulation, is supposed to ensure that a woman remains faithful to her future husband, and to deny her sexual pleasure.

FGM is performed on girls as young as three and is usually carried out with no anaesthetic. Scissors, razor blades and pieces of glass are used, and often on more than one girl. This increases the risk of infection.

Almost all heath reports and human rights groups condemn FGM. The United Nations and World Health Organization, for example, both recognise it as a human rights violation.

And this year a study published in the International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics said that circumcised women are more likely to suffer sexual health problems and stillbirths.

The Women’s Commission for Refugee Women and Children, which also condemns FGM, said that if the United States bans the Bantu families, it would "only further harm these young girls and condemn them to life in a refugee camp".

"Refugee girls and women are particularly vulnerable to gender-based violence and exploitation," it added.

But the United States would be acting within national and international law if it were to ban the families, says Tony Brown of the Minnesota Advocates of Human Rights. Brown says FGM is specified as a form of persecution in the U.S. Immigration and Nationality Act.

Persecutors, says Brown, are denied refugee status by the same act, as well as by the international Refugee Convention.

But other groups waiting to emigrate have in the past performed FGM on their daughters, says Emmanuel Nyabera, a spokesperson in Nairobi for the United Nations High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR). Apparently this did not bar them from emigrating, he adds..

Persecuted in Somalia because of their more Negroid appearance and history as slave-descendents, the Bantus have been refugees for some years, but their plight became more critical in 1997 when a civil war broke out in Somalia.

More than 10,000 Bantus fled on foot to Kenya to escape the militias that attacked their settlements.

When efforts to resettle in Mozambique proved unsuccessful, the United States designated the Bantus a priority group for resettlement in 1997. The resettlement programme was shut down after the Sep. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks on the United States, then reopened with tighter security measures.

All of the 11,860 Bantus, some of whom are expected to settle in the United States by April next year, have now been transported from refugee camps in Dadaab, northeast Kenya, to a transit camp at Kakuma in the northwest.

In the Kakuma camps they undergo medical tests and learn about life in the United States. This is the last stop before resettlement.

While the Bantus wait in Kenyan camps, another problem has recently surfaced in a small city in western Massachusetts.

Holyoke has been designated a "preferred community" for up to 300 of the Bantus to settle in over the next three years. But even though it has been granted nearly one million dollars in federal funds, city councillors say they cannot afford to accommodate the refugees.

”The city does not have the resources to care for, educate, train, house or protect” the refugees, said a council resolution, adding that it did ”not support the decision to place the refugees in our city”. The resolution passed by a vote of 12-2.

Federal officials say the vote is merely symbolic because the city council does not control federal funds and cannot legally prevent people from moving to Holyoke.

Still, it is not just the council that objects. Some of the residents do not want the Bantus either.

Since the beginning of the debate, Mayor Michael Sullivan has received threats and abusive phone calls. Sullivan says, ”I tell people, ‘don’t blame the victims’. The victims are the city,” he says, adding, ”and the Bantus”.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Development & Aid, Headlines, Health, Human Rights, North America

POLITICS: Female Circumcision Jeopardises Somali Refugees’ Plans

Gabriel Packard

NEW YORK, Nov 7 2002 (IPS) - Refugee advocacy groups say that U.S. officials should try to educate Somali asylum-seekers about the negative health effects of female circumcision rather than threaten to block their migration to the United States.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags