Saturday, November 21, 2026
Peter Richards
- When the European Union requested World Trade Organisation (WTO) arbitration of its proposed single tariff on banana imports, Caribbean banana-producing countries responded with “grave regret”.
St. Vincent and the Grenadines Prime Minister Ralph Gonsalves, who has special responsibility for bananas within the Caribbean Community (CARICOM), said the region would have preferred to negotiate directly with the EU to seek an amicable and fair solution to the situation.
“However, the route of litigation rather than negotiation was pursued despite repeated pleas from various suppliers in the African, Caribbean and Pacific states, including the Windward Islands, Latin America and among trade unions and the NGO community,” Gonsalves said in a statement Monday.
The dispute has pitted the so-called Most Favoured Nations (MFN) – many in Latin America – against the 25-nation African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) group, former European colonies whose banana sectors have for years received duty-free access.
In a bid to put an end to the long-standing banana dispute, the EU had agreed with Ecuador and the United States in 2001 to move from a complex import system based on a combination of tariffs and quotas for bananas from MFN countries to a regime based on a single tariff by Jan. 1, 2006.
The MFN nations include Brazil, Colombia, Costa Rica, Ecuador, Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua, Panama and Venezuela.
“There is a feeling of outrage in the region,” said Richard Bernal, the director general of the Caribbean Regional Negotiating Machinery (RNM), which coordinates the region’s position at various trade fora.
Marshall Hall, chairman of the Caribbean Banana Exporters Association, characterised the ruling as a “monumental disaster for the African, Caribbean and Pacific banana-supplying countries”.
In September, the EU presented a revised proposal in light of the arbitrator’s ruling, for an import duty of 226 dollars per tonne for MFN suppliers and a tariff quota of 775,000 tonnes at zero duty for bananas originating in ACP countries starting next Jan. 1.
MFN suppliers are subject to a tariff of 91.50 dollars per metric tonne, whereas all banana imports from preferential suppliers enter the European Community at zero duty. In 2004, the EC-25 imported a total of 3.87 million metric tonnes of bananas.
“It is regrettable that the arbitrators did not use this opportunity to provide more clarity as to how this long-standing dispute could be resolved,” the EC said in a statement.
Mariann Fischer Boel, the EU Commissioner for Agriculture and Rural Development, said her organisation was “surprised and disappointed that the arbitrators did not back our proposal”.
“We believed that the system we proposed would have maintained access to our markets in a fair manner. We calculated the proposed tariff in a neutral and transparent manner, based on a comprehensive legal and economic analysis. We will now carefully study the decision before deciding how to proceed,” she said.
Caribbean states argue that the best approach now is to postpone the single tariff, pending a compromise that would permit all suppliers to continue to trade.
“Unless a solution is found within the coming weeks, the consequences for the Windward Islands (Dominica, Grenada, St. Lucia and St. Vincent) would be particularly serious since they rely on preferences for successful exportation and sale of their bananas,” Gonsalves said.
The Windward Islands Farmers Association (WINFA) agrees, urging regional governments to move quickly on the issue.
“We note that there are still divergent views as to how the impasse could be resolved and are of the view that the most prudent course would be for all parties to agree to an extension of the current system for an agreed period during which negotiations for an acceptable import regime should concluded,” said WINFA’s coordinator, Renwick Rose.
He said every effort must be made to prevent a collapse in prices, which would hurt both Caribbean and Latin American producers.
“In the meantime we urge all farmers not to lose faith, to pursue our production and quality targets and to press their respective governments to do all in their power to defend the interests and livelihoods,” Renwick added.
The Windward Islands Banana Development and Exporting Company also called for the extension of the present system “for a sufficient period, to enable the parties to agree to a suitable timeframe and tariff level for the introduction of a tariff-only import regime”.
“This is the only viable option to maintain market stability and access for the ACP and MFN suppliers at current levels,” the company said.
St. Lucia’s Foreign Affairs Minister Petrus Compton has used the pending visit to the Caribbean later this week of John Tsang, chair of the Sixth World Trade Organisation (WTO) Ministerial Conference to be held in Hong Kong from Dec. 13-18, to outline the region’s concerns on the banana issue.
He said some of the smallest and most vulnerable countries in the Caribbean must now come to terms with the WTO ruling “that threatens to undermine the livelihoods of tens of thousands of people”.
“In effect, the ruling exposes Caribbean banana trade to new uncertainties, at a time when preferences are being scaled-back. A solution must be found, and fast,” he said urging Europe to negotiate with MFN and ACP suppliers “to arrive at a mutually satisfactory solution that ultimately is fair to both”.
“That solution must provide for market stability. The Caribbean expects that the EU will honour its commitments as regards ACP banana market access to the European market, in keeping with the Cotonou Partnership Agreement,” he added.
“Preferences are vitally important to the ability of small and vulnerable countries like St. Lucia to export bananas, yet this issue has received a hostile reception in the WTO. These preferences harm no one. The Caribbean has no desire or ability to damage the trading interests of Latin American or indeed any other exporters,” Compton said.
“It is immediately clear that the arbitrators’ ruling goes beyond bananas, affecting the capacity of the Caribbean’s small, vulnerable banana-producing states to effectively trade a vitally important commodity.”
“If WTO rules are undermining our ability to trade, what then is the value of the WTO system to the most vulnerable? The WTO system is marginalising small economies. Indeed, the WTO negotiating agenda is failing to address the obligations of a Development Round to developing countries, especially to its smallest and most vulnerable members,” Compton asked.
His Dominican counterpart, Charles Savarin, was also critical of the WTO ruling.
“It seems we have no place in the multilateral trading system, which is confining and consigning small, vulnerable developing countries to the dustbin, forcing them to be dependent on alms and handouts, rather than embracing them and enabling them to forge their own path to development,” he said.
Caribbean banana producers were planning an emergency meeting that Compton said would “discuss the way forward on bananas and a strategy in this regard ahead of the Sixth WTO Ministerial Meeting in Hong Kong this December”.