Friday, November 20, 2026
Muddassir Rizvi
- An alleged Indian spy condemned to death here appealed for clemency this month, creating a political quandary for Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf.
Sarabjit Singh, who continues to claim his innocence, was sentenced to death in 1991 by a Pakistani lower court after convicting him for four bomb attacks in 1990 that left 14 people dead and 89 injured. His subsequent appeals in higher courts were turned down and Pakistan’s Supreme Court upheld his death sentence in August 2005. He has now appealed to the Pakistani president for clemency.
But more is at stake than one man’s life. On the one hand, Musharraf must consider the possible damage in relations between India and Pakistan should the Indian national be executed. On the other, clemency will go against the president’s avowed objective of showing no mercy to convicted terrorists, giving opposition parties another talking point.
The question of clemency to Singh, 40, comes at a time when the country is bracing for general election next year. Musharraf, who has indicated his intentions to run for a third term, will certainly not be ready to risk irking conservative Islam by pardoning Singh after having seen their street power during recent protest over the Prophet Mohammad’s caricatures controversy.
“Showing mercy to a convicted terrorist will seriously compromise Musharraf’s anti-terrorism campaign and his no-compromise-on-terrorism image that gives him international legitimacy,” said an official in the Foreign Office who requested anonymity.
Moreover, a pardon will create precedent for at least 50 Pakistanis who are facing death penalty in Pakistan for various terrorism-related acts. A total of 5,447 people are waiting death in more than 50 jails in Pakistan. Some 15 people were hanged to death in the country in 2004, said information acquired from the home ministry that has yet to compile the similar data for 2005.
Equally important are the implications of this case on Indo-Pak relations. “It is a tough call for President Musharraf. Pardoning Sarabjit will certainly yield dividends for him [Musharraf] to create amicable relations with India as well enhance goodwill with Indian leadership,” said Zafar Nawaz Jaspal, an assistant professor at Quaid-i-Azam University in an interview with IPS in Islamabad earlier this month.
“Clemency will itself be a major confidence-building measure that will only cement the ongoing talks between the two countries,” he added. Pakistan and India have been encouraging people-to-people contact by softening visa conditions and opening new transportation routes as part of an ongoing effort to push forward the peace process initiated in April 2003.
“But clemency to Sarabjit will not go down well at home where opposition parties, particularly right-wing Islamic parties, are running a concerted campaign against Musharraf for his tilt towards the West,” said Jaspal, who is considered an authority on South Asian affairs.
Islamic parties have already accused Musharraf of softening Pakistan’s position on the Kashmir issue, which has pushed the two South Asian countries to three full-fledged wars. Both countries stake claim over the disputed territory.
Indian government officials have confirmed to Pakistan that Singh is an Indian national from Bhikiwindi in the Punjab and have repeatedly called for his release. They have not, however, commented on the spy charges.
Despite the fact that the case will have repercussions for peace between India and Pakistan, peace groups in Pakistan are silent. “There is as such no planned campaign on this issue, other than a few random demands by peace groups for commutation of his sentence or even his release as he has been in prisoner for over 14 years,” Dr. A. H. Nayyar, a prominent peace activist, told IPS this month.
Singh has maintained that he had strayed into Pakistani territory by mistake and was later arrested by Pakistani security agencies, who he claims coerced a confession for the bomb blasts. He says the crimes were carried out by someone with a similar name – Manjeet Singh.
Sarabjit Singh could not provide sufficient evidence to substantiate his defence in Pakistan courts, which convicted him of the bomb attacks. The Supreme Court already has rejected one review appeal, but still is considering three new petitions.
Anticipating a defeat in the legal battle for his life, Singh has decided to go for a political gamble, knowing his high-profile case has repercussions for the ongoing peace process between India and Pakistan.
“If Sarabjit Singh is not pardoned it could have adverse impact on the relations between the two countries,” Singh’s lawyer Rana Abdul Hameed, told IPS by telephone from central Punjab town of Lahore.
“My client has pleaded in his mercy appeal that he was innocent and wrongly implicated. He has prayed for clemency under the constitutional powers bestowed upon the president of Pakistan,” he said.
Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, no relation to the convicted man, made a personal appeal for the condemned man’s life to President Musharraf during their meeting in New York in September 2005. The Pakistani president reportedly assured the Indian premier that he would consider the issue in a “humanitarian spirit,” because of his firm belief in sympathy and forgiveness.
“Manmohan Singh is more concerned since Sarabjit belongs to the same ethnic community as the Indian premier,” said Asifa Hasan, a researcher with Islamabad Policy Research Institute, in an interview with IPS this month.
The Indian premier would feel let down by Musharraf in addition to letting down the Sikh community if he couldn’t use his good offices to save Singh’s life, she added. “This is one chance for Musharraf to develop a personal rapport of trust with India prime minister,” she said ahead of Indian premier’s likely visit to Pakistan in June.
Pakistan’s constitution gives the president power to grant clemency by overturning the highest court when the necessity of forgiveness is compelling enough for the greater interest of the state and society.
To many people and analysts, the desire for peace with India is a compelling necessity.
However, conservatives view the situation differently. They say that President Musharraf lost moral authority to grant clemency to Singh after showing no mercy to one of the convicts in the failed assassination attempts against him. That convict, Islam Siddiqui, a low-ranking soldier, was hanged to death in August 2005 for his involvement in the plot to kill Musharraf a year earlier. Five others are also facing death in the same case.
Conservatives say that Islam only allows the victims’ families the right to grant clemency. “If Musharraf cannot pardon a man for attacking him, he has no right to pardon the killers of 14 people. Only the families of those killed have the right to pardon him,” Badar Islam, a supporter of Jamaat-i-Islami in Islamabad, told IPS.
Indeed, many of the victim’s relatives demand his public hanging. Mohammad Salim, who lost his father in one the Lahore blast, told IPS by telephone from Lahore that no one can understand the misery he and his family have had to endure. He said that the killer of his father must be hanged publicly unless India decides to release all Pakistani convicted in Indian courts for terrorism.