Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Poverty & SDGs

CARIBBEAN: Regional Bank Lagging in Poverty Reduction

Peter Richards

MONTEGO BAY, May 18 2006 (IPS) - Every year, Caribbean governments lavish praise on the Barbados-based Caribbean Development Bank (CDB) for its efforts to improve socio-economic conditions in the region.

But that does not prevent these same governments from being critical of the 35-year-old financial institution, even though their leaders and finance ministers are members of the bank’s board of governors and hold shares in the institution.

This year was no exception, as the board gathered in Montego Bay, Jamaica’s scenic northwestern tourist area, May 17-18 for their 36th annual meeting.

In most cases, the criticisms are tied to perceived late disbursements of much-needed funds for projects that regional governments consider vital to improving the social wellbeing of their citizens.

The mission of the bank calls for it to be the leading catalyst for development resources in the Caribbean, and together with its borrowers and other partners, work towards “the systematic reduction of poverty” in the region through social and economic development.

Newly appointed Jamaican Prime Minister Portia Simpson Miller said that while there is no doubt that the CDB will continue to play a meaningful role in regional integration, there was now a need for the financial institution to switch gears, especially in a changing global environment that is taking its toll on Caribbean economies.


“This role must consist of a menu which includes financial resources, technical assistance, policy advice, rooted in reducing and ultimately eliminating poverty in the region,” said Simpson-Miller.

She said current lending by the bank – 153 million dollars last year, representing a 24 percent increase over 2004 – was still “too small to have the kind of impact required against the background of regional needs”.

“The bank therefore must assist its borrowing members where the constraint is the lack of absorptive capacity (the ability to make effective use of new aid flows) or issues to proper project identification and implementation, or lack of counterpart funding,” Simpson-Miller added.

Her finance minister, Omar Davies, who is also chairman of the CDB board of governors, went even further, noting that of the 15 loans disbursed to regional states last year, just one of them – a highway project in Jamaica – “accounted for 35 percent of total approvals”.

“While we recognise the fiscal pressures and debt constraints of some borrowing members, the bank has to find creative ways to assist the borrowing countries to improve their absorptive capacity,” he added.

Guyana, one of the beneficiaries of the Paris Club debt reduction policy, said that while it appreciated the assistance given by the bank, especially following last year’s floods that destroyed crops and infrastructure, it felt the bank “should get more involved, at the analytical, policy and operational levels, in respect of global economic developments impacting on the region”.

Officials referred in particular to the loss of preferential trade deals, high oil prices, increased food imports and the threats posed by agricultural liberalisation.

“Most of the major international organisations.are now tackling these issues and coming up with various remedial recommendations, generally under the theme of ‘aid for trade’,” said Saisnarine Kowlessar, the alternate governor for Guyana.

“We feel it would be timely in collaboration with the member states and the Regional Negotiating Machinery for the CDB to get more involved in a Caribbean approach to these problems,” he added.

Established in 1997, the Caribbean’s Regional Negotiating Machinery gives technical advice and coordinates unified strategies in the context of global trade talks, where the world’s wealthiest nations generally seek to dominate the agenda.

Grenada, recovering from the effects of two hurricanes in recent years, also wants the bank “to make more resources available, particularly to the private sector, the primary engine of growth of our economies”.

Finance Minister Anthony Boatswain, while thankful for the assistance provided by the institution, particularly since Hurricane Ivan struck in 2004, noted that “poverty continues to persist among a significant percentage of the populations of the borrowing member countries”.

“There is therefore a need for a redoubling of efforts as well as a review and evaluation of past and present policies, strategies and approaches to addressing this issue,” he added.

Like Guyana, Grenada also wants mechanisms in place to monitor programmes and projects, warning that while all the Caribbean states support the United Nations Millennium Development Goals, which include halving extreme poverty by the year 2015, “what is most lacking is our ability to monitor progress because of the absence of effective evaluation mechanisms”.

CDB president Compton Bourne has defended the institution, describing 2005 as a “successful year” in which the institution undertook its work “consistent with its charter obligations and practice”.

He said it provided loans for dealing with natural disasters, low-income housing, economic reconstruction, and also embarked on several training initiatives. The bank was also successful in replenishing its Special Development Fund (SDF), totaling 156 million dollars.

“Because the SDF is the bank’s principal means of providing highly concessionary financial resources in pursuit of the goal of poverty reduction, contributors are to be specially commended for making the extra effort in somewhat difficult fiscal circumstances,” said Bourne.

In March, the CDB approved its five-year strategic plan, and Bourne says it “retains the bank’s overarching strategic focus on poverty reduction through broad-based economic growth”.

“In pursuing this objective, the bank intends to make interventions to strengthen and modernise public utilities and the physical infrastructure essential for economic development, improvement of the competitiveness of business enterprises and which support agriculture and rural development.”

Bourne, an economist, also believes that despite the economic obstacles facing the region, such as structural changes in its trade relationship with Europe, increased oil prices and global tariff liberalisation, there are still favourable conditions for economic growth in the region.

He cited alternative approaches to tourism, recognition of the market potential of the wider Caribbean and Latin America for investment and a regional energy policy to take full advantage of the region’s mining and energy sectors.

“The Caribbean has the human capacity. There is a sound foundation of education and training on which the curricular innovations requisite for the new economic structures, sectors and industries can be based,” he said, adding that the region “should be able to secure the financial capital” needed to bring those initiatives to the centre stage of development policy.

Bourne said domestic financial capital, while not sufficient for the major investment required, is available to a greater degree than generally believed.

“The challenge is to devise risk-sharing arrangements to induce greater investment lending by the banking industry,” he said.

It is a situation which the CDB itself must move quickly to address, because as the Jamaican prime minister pointed out, financial institutions “both within and outside the region are very aggressive and now constitute serious competitive offering alternatives to financing from the bank”.

“In addition, the turn-around time for these creditors is much shorter than the bank,” Simpson-Miller warned.

 
Republish | | Print |