Saturday, November 21, 2026
Meena Janardhan
- Following the successful ‘emiratisation’ of the public relations sector, authorities in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) have decided that henceforth only nationals would be appointed as human resources (HR) managers and secretaries.
But this is being resisted by private companies that are more comfortable employing better skilled expatriates who also tend to be more disciplined and have fewer demands.
If the plans were implemented as originally decided, around 22,000 expatriates currently employed in these two professions would have lost their jobs.
Khalid Al Khazraji, undersecretary at the ministry of labour, insists that in many cases UAE nationals are discriminated against. ”The private sector is discriminating against UAE nationals, not because they are not willing to work but because those companies are greedy and are scared of UAE nationals who stand up for their rights and demand appropriate working conditions,” he said in a statement.
‘‘It will be really difficult to implement,” Ali Mohammed, manager of a Dubai-based information technology company, told IPS. ”Nationals are not willing to work the hours that expatriates can, nor will they be happy with the salaries that they get. Also a lot of time has to be spent identifying the right candidate and training them – why should we do that when trained expatriate professionals are available?”
But private companies have to follow two ministerial decrees, presented by Ali bin Abdullah Al Kaabi, minister for labour, in June, that banned new work permits and renewal of labour cards for expatriate secretaries and offered private companies a grace period of 18 months to replace expatriate HR managers with Emiratis.
Companies will also have to follow government stipulations for fixing minimum salaries for UAE nationals. Those violating the rules would be penalised and could get blacklisted.
‘‘I think this is a very good move,” said Mona Ibrahim, a UAE national and communications manager at a Dubai hotel. ‘‘We need such measures to push up the unemployed nationals who have taken the initiative and acquired an education.”
‘‘But what about us,” asked Sherene Varghese, an Indian secretary who has been working in the country for the past 10 years. ‘‘This is my livelihood – will we be given other jobs or are we going to be out in the cold?”
However, soon after the announcement, ground realities intervened and clarifications had to be issued about what the plan really means and devising new ways of making it effective.
One of the ministry’s new proposals recommends that companies which do not wish to replace expatriate secretaries with UAE nationals can opt to pay a 60,000 dirhams (around 16,500 US dollars) yearly fee to the National Human Resources and Employment Authority (Tanmia) to train UAE nationals on their behalf.
It was also clarified that in the secretarial category, the rule applies to companies that have more than 50 employees and companies can be exempted from this rule depending on the nature of the business, their working environment and their location. ‘‘The ministry of labour is undertaking the emiratisation of professions as previous policies of quota in sectors have not achieved their targets,” Al Kaabi told the media recently.
‘‘The emiratisation of HR manager and secretarial positions have short and long-term objectivesàthe reason behind emiratising the secretary profession is solely to create work opportunities for UAE nationals, which is short-termàthe decision to emiratise HR jobs is long-term to create a more solid base for opening up the job market for UAE nationalsàFor example, studies reveal that if a HR manager is from Kerala in India, the majority of the employees are also from Kerala. We hope the emiratisation of the profession will have the same effect,” he added.
Humaid bin Deemas, assistant under-secretary at the labour ministry, said: “The HR manager’s profession is a very sensitive one. It is a qualitative job and by emiratising this profession we will give a qualitative push to the emiratisation process, since the Emirati HR managers will aid in accelerating the employment of UAE nationals in the private sector.”
This is a new approach in the ministry’s emiratisation mechanism. ‘‘The process of emiratisation has to come both vertically, which is developing the skills of the UAE nationals, and horizontally, which is through providing work opportunities for nationals,” Al Kaabi said.
Around 800,000 jobs are created every year in the UAE – 200,000 in the public sector and 600,000 jobs in private firms. Of these, 450,000 are blue collar. As for national jobseekers, statistics show that there are 33,000 unemployed UAE nationals – 14,000 of these are secondary school certificate holders.
Marcus Gomez, an Indian supervisor of a supermarket chain, thought the government plan was sound. ‘‘Though I am an expatriate, I can understand that the government wants to ensure employment for its nationals. It is only right that Emiratis get preference – where else will you find so many unemployed nationals while the country is overflowing with employed expatriates?”
”What is needed is a change in the mindset of the employers,” Ayesh Al Barghouthi, a director at Tanmia. ”UAE nationals are committed and willing to work but lack some skills that could be developed and improved.”
Bargouthi, however, admitted that expatriate management in many cases felt ”intimidated by UAE nationals because they have tough control over their expatriate employees, something that is not tolerated by the nationals.”
Sheikha Lubna Al Qasimi, minister of economy, said: ‘‘The mission of any nationalisation drive, whether in the Gulf states or elsewhere, is to maximise the career opportunities for citizens of that country to create a sustainable workforce. Currently, the UAE population comprises 85 percent expatriates and only 15 percent nationals, which is the highest ratio of foreign workers in the wider Gulf region.”
Qasimi made it clear that the government expected the private sector to act. ”Even the least trained economist would reach the conclusion that the private sector holds the key to emiratisation – it’s where the jobs are.”