Asia-Pacific, Crime & Justice, Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

KYRGYZSTAN: Spared but Near Starving

Kuban Abdymen

BISHKEK, Jan 29 2007 (IPS) - The central Asian republic of Kyrgyzstan has adopted a new constitution specifically banning all taking of life and lawyers are now drafting revisions to its legal code replacing the maximum criminal sentence of death by firing squad with long prison terms.

Many independent lawyers and human rights activists here have welcomed this as an unequivocal ban on all state executions, saying the reforms were more progressive on this than anything in the constitutions of their immediate neighbours – Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and China.

The new Kyrgyz constitution came into full force when President Kurmanbek Bakiev signed it on January 16, 2007. Parliament had given its approved at its last sitting at the end of 2006. It was the second constitution within two months with these changes, but the first was dropped in a presidential tussle with the opposition for the return some of the powers earlier wrestled from him.

“Every person in the Kyrgyz Republic has an inalienable right to life. No one can be deprived of life,” article 14 declares. Conspicuously removed is an article specifying the death penalty for murder and some serious crimes, such as rape of minors. This had been in all Kyrgyz constitutions since independence from the Soviet Union in 1991.

“The death penalty has been abolished,” a spokesperson on the parliamentary judicial reforms committee announced at a press conference immediately after the deputies approved the new constitution on December 30.

Confirmation of this was also later provided to IPS by Marat Zhamankulov, head of the justice ministry’s department on prison reform: “There’s not a word in the constitution about the death penalty. This means it no longer exists in Kyrgyzstan, either in law or practice,” he said.

A parliamentary judicial reforms committee spokesperson added that some existing laws now needed altering to bring them into line with what was a clear constitutional ban on state executions. Draft proposals were currently being prepared.

The head of a specially created commission on police and law enforcement reform, Kubat Baybolov, confirmed that this was the next step.

“All that’s needed now is to bring the legal code in line with the constitutional changes,” he said.

“There haven’t been executions in Kyrgyzstan for some time and there’ll never be any again in the future.”

Sources were unable to confirm when the necessary legal changes would be presented to parliament for approval. But the head of Bishkek’s department of justice, Nurbolot Kurmanov told IPS that parliament was currently preoccupied with other more pressing issues.

Iskhak Masaliev, head of the parliament’s constitutional committee, told IPS that the necessary changes in the criminal code would be made “as soon as our society is more ready”.

Until the latest constitutional reforms, all executions had been halted by a death penalty moratorium. This had been in place since 1998 and was renewed annually by presidential decree.

The last renewal was on January 1, 2006 and was to be until the death penalty had been abolished in law in Kyrgyzstan.

All sides in Kyrgyzstan now understand that with the latest constitutional reforms another prolongation is no longer necessary.

No official would say when the last execution was carried out or the name of the person. But the state prosecutor’s office told IPS that the last two sentenced to death were Makhmujan Ruzimetov and Sabyrkul Batyrov. They were found guilty of the murder of the parliamentarian Bayaman Erkinbayev.

There are currently between 160 and 165 people in Kyrgyz jails sentenced to death, the non-governmental organization Civil Society against Corruption told IPS.

The final settling of the death penalty issue in Kyrgyzstan by an altering of the constitution, appears to be a deft compromise between those who had different approaches to how a death penalty ban should be introduced in Kyrgyzstan.

Ombudsman Tursunbay Bakir-uulu had been calling on parliament to pass a specific law abolishing state executions.

“We tried to achieve this – but failed,” he said.

“This was the idea I put forward together with the heads of the constitutional court and justice ministry. But the deputies rejected both the idea and our draft law.

“Their response was to suggest the holding of a national referendum on the death penalty issue. But we couldn’t accept this. We felt this was an issue that should be decided solely by parliament.”

Bakir-uulu apparently believed that in a referendum the public would have rejected a death penalty ban, according to members of his staff.

Nurbolot Kurmanov, the head of the department of justice in Bishkek, also said he believed a referendum would have resulted in the re-instatement the death penalty in country. Public anxiety over the economy, crime and corruption ran high and the death penalty was still widely perceived as a deterrent.

Opposition to a referendum – and there have been several since independence – was also expressed because of the cost. Kyrgyzstan’s 5 million people are among the poorest in the world, according to the World Bank.

With the apparent settling of the death penalty issue, attention is now being focused on the country’s dire prison conditions.

The Civil Society against Corruption earlier reported that death-row prisoners in basement jails of Bishkek and Osh were crammed ten to a cell designed for two.

Life expectancy behind bars was half that national average because of absence of medical attention and food shortages, one source reported

The tuberculosis was rife and often a reason for early release.

Prisoners barely survived on rations of 8 Kyrgyz Soms (17 US cents) a day, less than a quarter officially specified. This was just enough to buy a kilogram of potatoes, the sources said.

The prison system was entirely unprepared to cope with more life-term prison sentences, Kurmanbek Osmonov, the chairman of the Kyrgyz Supreme Court said.

The task now was to build new prisons and spend money on improvements and the conditions, said the parliamentary deputy Baybolov.

Justice Minister Kajypov has promised the prisons any budget surpluses.

“That means nothing will change in penitentiary system of Kyrgyzstan until situation in economy improves,” one source commented.

“The exception has been the abolishment of the death penalty”.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags