Friday, November 20, 2026
Tarjei Kidd Olsen
- Germany and Canada are among a group of nations that have opposed a move to ban cluster bombs.
Austria on the other hand announced a moratorium at the start of an international conference in Oslo Thursday.
Almost 50 countries are participating in a two-day conference on a ban on the production, use and stockpiling of cluster bombs, that mostly kill and maim civilians.
Major producers or users such as the United States, Russia and China are not attending the conference, but most participants that IPS spoke to did not think that a final obstacle.
“I believe that eventually they’ll join us too because they’re dealing with issues such as disarmament and non-proliferation, and cluster bombs are a deadly killer of civilians that also end up in the hand of non-state actors,” Norwegian foreign minister Jonas Gahr Støre told IPS Thursday.
Several NGOs pointed out to IPS that the same three countries have not used landmines following the 1997 Mine Ban Treaty, despite not signing up.
“With any treaty we want to have as many countries as possible involved, and certainly those that use the weapons,” Steve R. Goose from Human Rights Watch told IPS. “But can we have success without them? Yes, certainly. The U.S. hasn’t used landmines since 1991, and hasn’t produced them since 1997. I think we’ll see the same norm develop with cluster bombs.”
Of larger concern was the tendency of some participating countries to advocate a return to the Convention on Conventional Weapons (CCW) negotiations at the United Nations in Geneva. Unlike the Oslo conference, CCW negotiations allow states to veto suggestions to discuss cluster bombs.
Italy, France, Switzerland, Canada and Germany, all producers and stockpilers of cluster bombs, were among the countries offering support for the CCW. Canada said that cluster bombs are a military necessity, contradicting research by NGOs and statements by some countries and militaries.
In an official statement Germany said it supported the Norwegian initiative and pointed out that it is pushing for restrictions on the use of cluster bombs, and a ban on certain types considered to pose “serious humanitarian hazards”, but advocated a return to CCW negotiations.
“The Oslo conference does not include some very major actors that are reluctant to move, so the CCW deserves another chance, even if not in an unlimited timeframe,” Heinrich Haupt, head of the division for conventional arms control at the German foreign office told IPS.
Haupt is worried about the monetary cost involved in banning cluster bombs. “Once they have been developed, bought and stockpiled, huge costs are involved,” he said.
But he expects a mandate allowing discussions on cluster bombs to begin to be adopted at CCW negotiations in November, despite the veto threat. “It is true that there is the veto issue, but in order to maintain credibility reluctant states will learn from the Oslo initiative,” he said.
Chief executive officer Dr. Jean Baptiste Richardier of the NGO Handicap International France is more sceptical.
“I think the worst scenario would be for the Oslo initiative to be held hostage to the so-called CCW momentum. The CCW is a talking shop, in five years it has achieved nothing on anti-vehicle mines,” he told IPS.
“Suggestions to return to the CCW are either made in bad faith or are a double-edged strategy. These people are not paid to take account of humanitarian consequences. I’m not saying they are evil, they have a job and come with preconceived ideas, but now things have to be moved forward,” Richardier said.
“Those that use cluster weapons can pretend that they have made technical modifications that make the bombs safer, but they cannot escape the reality of their loss of control and the terrible consequences – proof that they have shirked their responsibilities,” he said.
Austria, the only country announcing a moratorium on the use of its cluster bombs on Thursday, said it is willing to host a follow-up meeting in Vienna towards the end of the year.
In June 2006 Belgium became the first country to ban cluster bombs. Norway has declared a moratorium.
According to Handicap International, 98 percent of cluster bomb casualties in the last three decades have been civilian.