Sunday, November 22, 2026
Analysis - By Thalif Deen
- The United States, which is pushing for a fresh U.N. resolution authorising military force against Iraq, will have to overcome a powerful Franco-German alliance in the U.N. Security Council if it is to reach its goal in the coming weeks.
France, a veto-wielding permanent member of the Council, and Germany, a non-permanent member holding a two-year rotating seat as of January, both want to give U.N. arms inspectors more time to search for weapons of mass destruction (WMD) in Iraq.
So far, French President Jacques Chirac has refused to compromise on his demand for a diplomatic solution to the problem. A resolution favouring war, he says, should be the last resort. But Chirac has refused to put a marker on when such a resolution will receive his blessings.
U.S. officials, who are infuriated by the stumbling blocks erected by the European allies, have been openly critical of France and Germany.
U.S. Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld angered both nations last month by dismissing them as members of the "old Europe" in the 15-nation European Union (EU) whose total strength will rise to 25 by January 2004.
Rumsfeld was hinting at the support the United States has been assured from the emerging ”new Europe”, including Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic, which will be part of the EU next year.
Asked by a member of the U.S. House of Representatives armed services committee what kind of cooperation Washington could expect to receive from allies in the event of a war, Rumsfeld said caustically, ”And then there are three of four countries that have said they won’t do anything. I believe Libya, Cuba and Germany are the ones that I have indicated won’t help in any respect.”
A senior U.S. official has also dismissed France as ”no longer our ally”, accusing Chirac of making life difficult for the United States by publicly expressing his reservations about an attack on Iraq.
The United States is conscious of the fact that if it succeeds in convincing France to join an international ”coalition of the willing”, Germany will follow suit. And so will the others.
A French crossover to the U.S. side would also help nudge the other two veto-wielding permanent members of the Security Council, China and Russia, to support a new resolution favouring war. Or, alternatively, generate abstentions by all three, which would be good enough for the United States.
On Thursday, U.S. President George W. Bush declared that ”the game is over” for Iraqi President Saddam Hussein. As a final concession, Bush said, he would give the Security Council one last chance to formulate a new resolution authorising the use of force against Iraq.
But such a resolution would have to be approved by a minimum nine Council members, and vetoed by none. The veto-wielding members of the body are the United States, Britain, France, China and Russia.
While Britain is the most steadfast U.S. supporter, China and Russia remain ambivalent and may even abstain on a vote. France is the only member that has threatened to exercise its veto.
The remaining 10 votes are held by Bulgaria, Cameroon, Guinea, Mexico, Syria, Angola, Chile, Germany, Pakistan and Spain.
Since the monthly presidency of the Security Council is held in alphabetical rotation, the two countries chairing crucial meetings to date have been France, in January, and now Germany. As president, both countries have had ample room for political manoeuvring – much to the dismay of Washington.
The speculation is that Bush will push for a resolution in March when Guinea, a country that could relent under U.S. pressure, takes over the presidency of the Council.
A western diplomat told IPS on Friday that a new resolution will be ”a hard sell”. But he admitted that the world’s only superpower could use its political and military muscle to browbeat the Council, particularly the 10 non-permanent members.
”The United States is as adept at threatening countries as it is at influencing votes with cheque book diplomacy,” he added.
Chirac’s decision will also depend on how France views the emerging political picture.
If the United States decides to go to war without U.N. authorisation, the international body would be reduced to a political non-entity, with France having contributed to that outcome.
And when the spoils of war are divided in post-war Iraq, an anti-war France might be left out of the reckoning.
Long before the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait in 1990, France was one of the major arms suppliers to Iraq. That country still owes more than eight billion U.S. dollars in military debts to France: a debt that will have to be written off if the European nation is marginalized in a post-war Iraq.
Last month, representatives from Britain, Spain, Italy, Portugal, Hungary, Poland, Denmark and the Czech Republic, signed an open letter published in the European edition of the ‘Wall Street Journal’ calling on the international community to take a united stand against Iraq.
The letter was symbolic of the sharp divisions in Europe over Iraq, and more importantly, over the United States.
Washington and Europe have remained divided on several politically sensitive issues, including the Kyoto Protocol on climate change, the creation of the International Criminal Court, the convention against landmines and the Palestinian uprising in the Israeli-occupied territories.
Additionally, the French stand on Iraq is being influenced by public opinion polls in Europe, which are heavily against war.
The French attitude was best summed up by Dominique Moisi of the French Institute for International Relations, who described the government position: ”Partly it was instinct, partly frustration with the United States, and partly public opinion.” .