Active Citizens, Civil Society, Headlines

RUSSIA-CIS: Region Rejects Moscow’s Bid for Regional Integration

Sergei Strokan

MOSCOW, Oct 17 1995 (IPS) - Russia’s spirited bid to promote closer integration among states of the former Soviet Union has been all but nixed by continuing disputes within the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) over key political and military issues.

Moscow, incensed by attempts within the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation’s (NATO) to co-opt eastern Europe into its sphere of influence, issued a strong plea here last week at the meeting of CIS foreign ministers for a full-fledged alliance of the former Soviet republics.

But few of the wary CIS members appeared to be biting.

The 12 delegates failed to finalise draft documents outlining Moscow’s proposal, which was titled “Russia’s Strategic Line Toward the CIS”. Conceived by the Russian Foreign Ministry, it is seen by experts here both as Moscow’s answer to NATO’s proposed expansion and an attempt to regain influence as a global player.

But disagreement over the document’s fine points was so intense that the CIS summit slated for October is now expected to be postponed, Russian diplomatic sources told IPS.

Russian president Boris Yeltsin’s fist-banging diatribe at the NATO press conference on Sep. 9 against western policy in the former Yugoslavia was the first sign that Russia might seek to counterbalance the NATO bloc with a CIS alliance.

The policy document that emerged out of Moscow’s ire offers practical guidelines for the Kremlin’s new policy toward its CIS neighbors. The basis of the new doctrine is the 1995 “conception of collective state security”, which has yet to be recognised by all CIS states.

To make the concept a reality, Moscow has put forward the idea of forming two working organs — the Council and the Secretariat of Collective State Security — to coordinate joint peacekeeping operations by CIS allied forces. The initiative, which aims to counteract threats to the external borders of the CIS, is based on NATO principles.

According to the decree, aggression against one member state is regarded as aggression against them all, and defence would be collective. Moscow also proposed a plan for sharing the financial burden of CIS peacekeeping operations. Lastly, the plan envisages creation of a united system of air defence directed from a single control center, which would be led by the commander of Russia’s air defence.

If these ideas were implemented it would transform the amorphous CIS into a viable military alliance capable of providing security in the troubled areas of the former Soviet Union, with Russia clearly playing the leading role.

“Moscow wanted a new military policy because it has come to the conclusion that it no longer has leverage with the West,” says Alexander Golz, a political commentator for ‘Krasnaya Zvezda’ army daily.

“International disarmament agreements and inadequate financing have seriously harmed the Russian army. The nuclear arsenal is useless at imposing pressure in regional conflicts. If NATO expands, Moscow’s influence will diminish even further,” he adds.

According to Alexey Pushkov, an analyst on ORT Russian TV, the idea of integration may also be intended to help Yeltsin in the upcoming December parliamentary and 1996 presidential elections, boosting his image as staunch defender of Russian interests.

“For a lot of Russians (the move toward integration) may be a balm, healing wounded national pride,” he told IPS.

From a purely economic point of view, the ex-Soviet republics would be better off training forces and producing armaments jointly. But, experts note, the collective security idea as it stands is quite vague and has no definite time frame.

More importantly, today’s threats to the security of most CIS states come not so much from without as from within.

“Many of the former republics are either at odds with each other or coping with internal conflicts, and a lot of people there are wary of the intentions of the ‘Russian bear’,” Golz says.

The most vocal supporter of the new Russian plan is Belorussia, whose president Alexander Lukashenko made a flying tour of Moldova and Ukraine trying to sell them Moscow’s idea even before the foreign ministers meeting.

“Lukashenko’s zeal is explained by his personal ambitions. He has been striving for the tightest possible Russian-Belorussian alliance all along and there are rumours of him being offered the vice-presidential post in the new alliance, should it happen,” Vladimir Yemelyanenko, CIS affairs analyst with ‘Moscow News’ weekly told IPS.

The only other country to tentatively support Moscow is civil war- torn Tajikistan, where Russian troops are guarding the border with Afghanistan against mujahedeen (Afghan rebel) penetration.

Ukraine, on the contrary, is sharply against the proposed alliance. “We are not going to enter any bloc,” President Leonid Kuchma firmly declared.

Strong objections were also voiced by Moldava’s delegation, which, along with Ukraine and Azerbaijan, is currently pursuing partnership plans with NATO.

Another set of questions discussed at the CIS foreign ministers meeting concerned the coordination of CIS member states’ foreign policy. Russia believes the CIS needs working organs supervising the latter’s relations with international alliances and organisations.

This idea was also tabled at the meeting, with the majority of participants insisting it needs more in-depth analysis.

The wary attitude of CIS states can be explained by the fact that Moscow’s initiative was really no news to them. Russia has for a long time been trying to reassert its leadership within CIS by establishing military bases in Armenia and Georgia and by reiterating its desire to strengthen defences on its borders with the northern Caucasus and the Baltics.

“CIS states see Kremlin moves as just a part of a bargaining session with NATO over the redistribution of spheres of influence, as a result of which NATO wants to get carte-blanche in eastern Europe and Russia,” says Yemelyanenko.

“The ‘new course’ is to legitimise the Russian military presence across what it sees as its new influence perimetre, and we won’t see other CIS states agreeing to it readily in the near future.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Active Citizens, Civil Society, Headlines

RUSSIA-CIS: Region Rejects Moscow’s Bid for Regional Integration

Sergei Strokan

MOSCOW, Oct 17 1995 (IPS) - Russia’s spirited bid to promote closer integration among states of the former Soviet Union has been all but nixed by continuing disputes within the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS) over key political and military issues.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags