Saturday, November 21, 2026
Stephen Dale
- A major confrontation between aboriginal peoples and a newly independent province of Quebec can be expected if Quebecers vote to separate from Canada in the province’s independence referendum on October 30.
At a high-profile news conference held in Montreal October 12, Grand Chief Matthew Coon Come forcefully told the federal and provincial governments that the 12,000 Crees of northern Quebec will not allow their territory to be absorbed by the new nation.
“There is nothing you will do without our consent, the chief said. “I repeat: there is nothing you will do without our consent.”
The Crees are one of several aboriginal nations in the province of Quebec who have expressed unwillingness to be governed by Quebec nationalists.
The Crees and the Inuit both have claims on their traditional lands in the northern part of the province, comprising roughly two-thirds of Quebec’s landmass. They say the territory should remain under Canadian jurisdiction in the event of separation by Quebec.
In addition, there are smaller Mohawk, Huron and Montagnais communities in the southern part of the province which also view themselves as independent nations with as much right to sovereignty as the predominantly French-speaking Quebec nationalists in the province.
At their Montreal news conference, the Crees attempted to address that very question of whether aboriginal nations have as much right under international law to political self-determination as do other residents of the province. They released a 500-page book entitled “Sovereign Injustice” which presents legal arguments in support of their cause.
“We have international law on our side,” said Bill Namagoose, executive director of the Grand Council of the Crees of Quebec.
“Quebec claims to have territorial integrity. But international law only recognises the territorial integrity of countries. There is no such thing as the territorial integrity of provinces; Quebec’s borders are simply an administrative arrangement within Canada,” Namagoose told IPS in a telephone interview.
All of Canada’s aboriginal peoples insist that they never ceded sovereignty to any foreign power, and therefore remain independent nations with the right to control the territory they have always occupied.
The Crees and Inuit say this principle gives them the right to decide whether they want to join an independent Quebec or remain part of Canada. The Crees will hold their own referendum on that matter October 24, six days before the province-wide vote.
An earlier study, prepared for Canada’s Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples by U.S. international law expert Richard Falk of Princeton University, concluded found no precedents on how aboriginal sovereignty is affected by the break-up of a country. “Part of the study’s conclusion is that the legal situation is not altogether clear,” Falk said when the study was released late in August.
But he indicated that if Canada used “a degree of discretion” and recognised the aboriginal right to self-determination in the face of Quebec’s claim to sovereignty, it could help establish an important precedent in international law.
The Crees, however, not only believe they have a stronger claim to the territory in northern Quebec than do the Quebec separatists, but also that specific treaty obligations compel the Canadian government to continue protecting the interests of the Crees and the Inuit.
In 1975, Canada, Quebec, the Crees and the Inuit signed an agreement on political and financial arrangements that paved the way for Hydro Quebec’s massive James Bay hydro-electric project, a development which resulted in the flooding of large areas of Cree and Inuit land.
Although Quebec’s aboriginal affairs minister David Cliche said recently that an independent Quebec would assume Canada’s treaty obligations after separation, the Crees reject that option.
“The James Bay agreement was signed by four parties, and one party cannot exit without the consent of the others, just as we cannot unilaterally start acting on behalf of the Inuit. You cannot transfer legal obligations like a piece of baggage from one party to another,” Namagoose told IPS.
Namagoose said that the Crees would take legal action in Canadian courts to compel the Canadian government to act on their behalf if Quebec separated. He also promised legal and political action at the international level. The Crees have repeatedly stated they will not resort to violence in their struggle against being absorbed by a separate Quebec.
Past experience indicates that the Crees would mount a formidable challenge to the government of an independent Quebec. Last year, the Crees forced Quebec to abandon construction of a new phase of the James Bay Hydro-electric project after it lobbied major consumers of Quebec electricity in the U.S.
The Crees’ international profile also increased in September, when a remote Quebec Cree village was chosen by the United Nations as one of 50 model communities around the world.
The Ouje Bougoumou community, designed by renowned aboriginal architect Douglas Cardinal, includes such innovations as an environmentally friendly heating system. Formerly poverty- stricken, the village has launched a number of thriving businesses.
Political scientist Francois Pierre Gingras of the University of Ottawa, believes the Crees would use their political expertise to negotiate a good deal with the government of a sovereign Quebec.
He believes the Crees’ current stand against sovereignty is just a strong opening position for negotiations that might follow. Gingras told IPS an independent Quebec will have so many problems to deal with, that it may be more willing to extend aboriginal people greater powers of self-government than would the Canadian government.
“I trust an agreement could be reached,” Gingras told IPS. “I believe that, in order to buy peace, the Quebec government could find it possible to give special jurisdiction to the Crees and the Inuit.”
Others are sceptical. David Newhouse, head of the Native Studies program at Trent University in Peterborough, Ontario, says there’s a history of tension between Quebec and aboriginal peoples. “We’re talking about land and territory, and I think Quebec will want to start asserting its jurisdiction, rather than give it up,” he said.
Namagoose also indicates that the Crees have deep philosophical differences with Quebec separatists. Quebec’s Declaration of Independence makes no reference to the First Nations’ inherent right to self-determination, which has been recognised by Canada. “If you start a new country with a denial of our rights, then why would we want to join that country?” he asked.
The latest opinion polls show separatist forces now nine per cent behind those Quebecers who want to stay in Canada. However, with 13 percent undecided, analysts say the final result is anything but certain.