Sunday, November 22, 2026
Jaya Dayal
- An appeal by the PhiliPpines for a global conference on international migration may be falling on deaf ears, according to some skeptical U.N. officials and migration experts.
In a speech to the 185-member General Assembly Monday, Domingo Siazon, Philippines’ secretary of foreign affairs, Monday renewed his country’s offer to host a U.N.-sponsored meeting on the thorny subject.
The presence of migrant workers in foreign lands “has placed them in positions of vulnerability that require international cooperation for the protection of their rights and dignity as human beings,” he said.
As an exporter of more than four million labourers overseas, Manila is especially sensitive to the situation and treatment of foreign workers.
It is currently embroiled in a debate with the government of the United Arab Emirates over a death sentence issued to Sarah Balabagan, a young Filipina maid who allegedly killed her employer after he raped her. Earlier this year, the hanging of another Filipina, Flor Contemplacion, in Singapore for the alleged murder of a co-worker, fostered huge demonstrations in the Philippines.
These cases, which have drawn the attention of international human rights groups, highlight the kind of abuse and lack of legal safeguards available to migrants, and migrant women in particular.
The Philippine proposal — first floated after the 1994 International Conference on Population and Development in Cairo — has garnered the support of the 132-developing nation bloc and China.
Last week, foreign ministers from the “Group of 77” Third World countries reiterated the importance of convening a global conference on migration and development and called for international cooperation to deal with “the plight and predicament of migrant workers and their families.”
But despite the growing concern over the rights of migrants, many U.N. officials and migration experts have raised doubts about whether all 185 governments will agree to the proposed international meeting.
“What’s holding it back is that it’s such a hot potato,” said one U.N. official speaking on condition of anonymity.
International migration is a touchy topic on most domestic agendas, and few countries seem willing to discuss it in public. Two years ago, the U.N. Population Fund (UNFPA) warned that international migration could become “the human crisis of our age.”
In 1992, the World Bank estimated international migrants of all kinds at 100 million. Human rights abuses of migrant workers, disputes over the right to family reunification, xenophobia and shrinking quotas for migrant labour have roiled recent debate on migration.
Efforts by developing countries at U.N. conferences, and most recently at the Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing last month, to move the issue beyond immigration nightmares to the context of socio-economic development have failed.
In recent months, the United States, the 15-member European Union and Japan have made it clear that they oppose an international conference.
They argue that the United Nations’ severe financial straits, and a series of back-to-back international conferences since 1990, have dimmed their enthusiasm for yet another global meeting.
But a more likely reason for their resistance to the initiative, according to one U.N. official, is that “no one wants to be publicly lambasted for tightening up their immigration policies and closing their borders.”
Peter Schatzer, director for external relations at the Geneva- based International Organisation for Migration (IOM), said while it was “definitely necessary to have international discussion” on the subject, a global meeting might not be the best way to address the issue.
He noted that the IOM, a leading inter-governmental body dealing with migration issues, “is not pushing for any type of conference or meeting.”
Schatzer said if the proposal for the international conference fails to muster support, countries may still agree to address the issue at the regional level, or at smaller fora.
“There are many ways to skin this cat,” Schatzer said. “Things may not get resolved at an international conference, but at more specialised meetings.” The IOM is currently preparing for a regional meeting on migration for the countries of the former Soviet Union.
Countries at the United Nations could take a decision on the Philippine proposal when the Committee on Social and Economic affairs discusses the subject at the end of October. If they fail to agree, they may simply call for more discussion on the subject.
International migration is set to be the main focus of the inter-governmental think-tank, the Commission on Population and Development, when it meets in 1997.
Schatzer noted meanwhile that while the Philippine proposal has been endorsed by the bloc of developing countries and China, not all members of the group are as keen as others to see the conference take place.
For example, countries like Bangladesh, Pakistan, Philippines, Sri Lanka, and Northern African countries, are more supportive of the initiative than some migrant-receiving countries like the Gulf states, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates.
Many Asian countries — which have recently become magnets for migrants — may also be shying away from the idea of the conference.
“Many of these countries do not have all the human rights safeguards in place. Migrants in some of these countries have no rights at all,” said the U.N. official.