Environment, Headlines, North America

CANADA-ENVIRONMENT: New seal hunt spurred by Asian demand

Stephen Dale

OTTAWA, Jul 4 1995 (IPS) - The Canadian government has announced that it will expand the Newfoundland seal hunt which 20 years ago provoked international outrage and eventually led to a European ban on the importation of seal pelts.

In the mid-1970s, television viewers worldwide were shocked by the images of newborn harp seal pups — known as “whitecoats” — being clubbed to death and skinned in front of their mothers off of Canada’s east coast. The bloody carcasses were left on the ice — leaving huge fields of ice stained red — while the furs were taken to market.

Now, however, critics of the hunt say the new market for seal products will not centre on fur boots and coats sold in luxury shops in Europe, but rather on seal penises that are made into sexual potions and aphrodisiacs in Asia.

“There’s only one product that seems to be in demand, and that’s seal penises,” said Dr. David Lavigne, a zoologist and authority on seals at the University of Guelph in Ontario.

“The government of the Northwest Territories (in the Canadian north) did a study that showed an excellent market potential for seal penises. There is a market for seal penises in China. They looked at the market in seal pelts but found that it’s not good,” Lavigne told IPS.

Oceans and Fisheries Minister Brian Tobin (who recently spearheaded the Canadian campaign to drive the Spanish fleet out of Canada’s waters) said last week that whitecoat pups will not be targetted when the number of seals killed in Eastern Canada increases beyond the present 60,000 per year. The total allowable catch was raised in February to 186,000 seals.

Lavigne said this new emphasis on adult seals — which replaced seal pups as the primary target of the hunt in 1993 — indicates that the trade in seals now centres on penises. Adult seals have more developed sex organs than the pups.

A government spokesperson confirmed that seal penises are being marketed by Canada. “Our approach has been that we want to promote and encourage the total use of the animal,” Jean Hache, senior advisor on fisheries management, told IPS. “Part of that is the sexual organs – the penis – of the seals. As that’s part of the whole animal, then by all means, let’s market all we can.”

Hache also said that a seal-derived oil known as ‘Omega Three,’ which is said to lower cholesterol levels, is also finding a market in Asia.

Lavigne says that Canada’s claim that it uses the whole animal is an attempt to avoid public outrage over killing seals primarily for their sex organs. He said the need for the government to subsidise seal meat by about 30 US cents per kilogramme shows there is no general market for seal products.

Already, environmentalists are reacting with anger over the revival of the large-scale seal hunt. In Britain, the International Fund for Animal Welfare issued a statement calling for its members to boycot Canadian salmon.

Fisheries minister Tobin suggested the expanded seal hunt is necessary because the seal population has increased dramatically and are eating too much cod. Fish stocks off Canada’s east coast have declined to the point where Canadian fishermen have been ordered to stay home until the stocks recover.

In a four-page document released to the press, Tobin’s ministry reported that the harp seal population has doubled to 4.8 million in the past 20 years. It also stated that “although Atlantic cod is a relatively small component (about three per cent) of their diet, the large number of seals present consumed approximately 88,000 tonnes” of the cod, which is a mainstay of the fishery.

But Lavigne said the report’s findings are unsubstantiated and sometimes at odds with earlier government research. He pointed to a section of the report that says the seal population may be much lower than 4.8 million if a higher mortality rate among pups is factored in.

Since it is accepted that young seals do die at a higher rate than adult seals, then “to even run a model with a constant mortality across age groups is misleading and leads to inflated figures,” he said.

The scientist also complained that there is no evidence to suggest that killing more seals will lead the cod to recover. More complex studies are needed to determine if that is true, said Lavigne. In fact, it is equally possible the cod would be worse off without the seals who eat their other predators.

“If the seals were culled dramatically,” said Lavigne, “there could be more mid-sized fish eating smaller fish and that would impede the recovery of the northern cod stock.”

Lavigne accused the government of trying to blame the seals for a crisis That is human-made. “The cod originally collapsed as a result of one factor and one factor only: that is, overfishing, and most of it by Canadians,” he said.

Government scientist Dr. Garry Stenson, speaking to IPS from St. John’s Newfoundland, agreed that the estimates of the harp seal po|ulation “will vary according to what assumptions go into the model” which is used to generate the estimate. He also confirmed that the seals were not responsible for decreasing the cod population, and that it is not known whether they are now eating enough young cod to impede recovery of the fish stocks.

“The question of [the seals’] impact on the fish stocks has not been addressed by any of the work we’ve done to date,” Stenson said. “We don’t know of any other cause of mortality, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist.”

The decision to increase sealing in Canada will likely revive the bitter memories that linger from the earlier struggle over seals. One of the most controversial outgrowths of the European seal import ban in 1983, was that Inuit communities in the far north lost a major source of income, even though they did not blugeon baby seals as the Atlantic sealers did.

Tache told IPS that “the harvest of seals will have a positive impact” on those Inuit communities that were hurt by the earlier ban.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags