Headlines

MSG075G/01E VENEZUELA: Desperation Leads to “Vigilante” Justice

Humberto Marquez

CARACAS, Mar 16 1995 (IPS) - People in the marginalised areas of Caracas have begun to take the law into their own hands in the face of a rising crime wave which Venezuelan authorities have failed to subdue.

On Mar. 5, Jose Figuera, a young gang member and would-be rapist, was beaten to death by an angry crowd and his body hanged over a sewage outlet.

Three other delinquents have been killed in this way so far this year, and the National Guard intervened in another case where four criminals had been rounded up by an angry crowd.

The authorities have condemned this self-styled justice, but many analysts fear that widespread desperation will cause such actions to increase – 20 to 40 murders are already committed each weekend in the capital city.

“Similar situations have occurred in other Latin American countries, so we knew what could happen when the state lost control,” said Justice Minister Ruben Creixems.

“One has the feeling that the State has driven off the paved road,” he added, “from here on in these crowded neighbourhoods – monsters of marginalisation and labarynthine streets – order is imposed by the local society.”

Creixems said it was “neither constitutional, legal nor morally permissable for people to take the law into their own hands,” though he did not suggest punishment for the community members.

Interior Minister Ramon Escovar agreed with Creixems, but argued that peoples’ reactions were “a legitmate defence on the part of a harrassed community.”

Henry Mendoza, a Jesuit priest and teacher in a poor area, condemned the lynchings saying, “what we need to control crime are better living conditions and an anti-drug campaign.”

“Society is crumbling and people get by, keeping ahead of the rest through violence,” he said, adding that the neighbourhoods need “schools, recreation areas and a police force that does intelligence work.”

According to human rights lawyer Ricardo Dorado, “insecurity is compounded by the state, which has violated human rights by failing in its efforts to guarantee public peace of mind.”

He said the lynchings stem from “the justice system’s incompetence, which is a result of a crisis in the sector that makes it incapable of punishing the guilty parties.”

Figuera pleaded for his life, but was offered no mercy. “If we had handed him over to the police, he would have been freed in a short while,” said crime victim Miguel Maiz.

He added, “I would kill another criminal if it was necessary – no one can put up with this insecurity. The only way to deal with these criminals is to kill them.”

Figuera and his gang stripped and wounded Maiz when he stepped in to help a woman they were trying to rape. When Maiz called for help, people nearby came to his rescue, killing Figuera.

Psychologist Leoncio Barrios said the hanging of the victim was “a symbolic illustration that people were ready to do the same to the gang members who got away.”

In a survey of 550 people between the ages of 18 and 45 in Caracas, 57 percent said they approved of the lynchings.

“This simply means that the people have had enough,” said Barrios. “They have decided to deal with it themselves rather than waiting for the authorities who should have dealt with the increasing crime over the past 10 years.”

Barrios explained that violence was also on the rise in middle-class areas, with many young people given guns by their parents “to defend themselves,” although Venzuela has not yet seen the organisation of “death squads” against street children and criminals that have developed in some Latin American nations.

Political analyst Antonio Cova envisioned a grave future for Venezuela, comparing it with the “wild West” with “spiralling violence leading to squads of former policemen turned private security men,” roaming the streets destroying criminals.

He said President Rafael Caldera was incapable of dealing with the situation, adding that any social, economic and educational reforms must be backed by judicial reform and harsher sentences.

Dorado explained that little was being done politically to deal with the lynching issue because of a “classist notion of justice, where no one cares if the poor kill each other.”

“A sort of authoritarian justification is produced – six constitutional rights have been suspended (since June 1994), and people believe these cases and police excesses don’t much matter, as long as – in exchange – they feel secure,” he said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags