Armed Conflicts, Headlines, Human Rights

TRADE-THIRD WORLD: ACP Producers Call on EU to Defend Banana Regime

Angeline Oyog

PARIS, Feb 22 1995 (IPS) - European banana producers and their African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) counterparts called on the European Union (EU) Wednesday to defend the EU banana export regime against attacks by the United States government and growers.

According to Manuel Hermoso, President of the autonomous government of the Canaries, the European Union must not allow the United States to upset or to re-arrange the banana regime established in 1993 with European and ACP countries.

The regime, which harmonised diverse import systems within the European Union following the opening of the Single Market and gives preference to the EU banana growers and traditional suppliers within the ACP, is already producing results that satisfy parties involved, Hermoso added.

The regime also took into account the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) rules and the future World Trade Organisation (WTO) with regard to third party countries or the so- called ‘dollar bananas’.

“The complaints of U.S. companies are nothing more than willful pride and an attempt to question and to destroy the very principle of the European Union,” said Hermoso during an international meeting in Paris organised by the Association of European Banana Producers (APEB).

The APEB is a European economic interest group bringing together banana producers within the European Union: Canaries (Spain), Madeira (Portugal), Guadaloupe and Martinique (France).

In a manifesto adopted at the end of the conference, the ACP and EU banana producers urged the U.S. authorities, “misled by the inexact information given them” to renounce dismantling the European Union banana regime.

A dismantling of the banana regime by the United States, they said, would have drastic consequences on the regions and countries already characterised by high unemployment levels and having no other alternative to the cultivation of bananas.

The European banana regime has come under attack after U.S. Trade Representative Michael Kantor picked up the complaints of U.S. multinational company Chiquita and threatened unilateral actions to retaliate against an agreement that it said is adversely affecting U.S. economic interests.

In making his threats, Kantor is using the vast discretionary powers vested on him by Section 301 of the U.S. 1974 Trade Act — a move that many have judged to be contrary to the agreement signed in Marrakech in April 1994 creating the WTO.

Since the WTO was established, all signatories, which include the United States, must go through the organisation’s dispute settlement system, stressed Laurent Chabot from the French Economy and Finance Ministry.

“It is dangerous to note that some feel it possible to take unilateral action. I hope that good sense will prevail. It is essential to respect the agreement if we are to preserve an environment of trust in world trade relations,” said Victor Martins, Portuguese State Secretary for European Affairs.

“From out of the blue, we get 301. Washington should be told our side and be made to understand. Obviously, they see it only from one point of view,” said Eugenia Charles, prime minister of the former British colonial island of Dominica in the Caribbean.

Believing that the U.S. government is seeking a way out of the situation and still save face, Charles also suggested that ACP and EU producers help Washington find the solution.

“They won’t give up 301 overnight, but I believe they are looking for a way out and we must help them find it.”

Figures show that U.S. complaints of huge losses resulting from the EU banana regime are not justified, said Caribbean Banana Exporters Association technical expert Clare Wenner.

“Are the difficulties of Chiquita a result of the regime or of the company’s bad business decisions?” said Wenner, calling for an examination of the motives of the U.S. multinational company.

What Chiquita wants, said Wenner, is not an abolition of the regime, but an amendment to have a bigger market share at higher prices. “It wants to get rid of competition. And what it wants should not happen, because Chiquita’s arguments are based on totally false premises.”

Edwin Laurent, ambassador of East Caribbean states and president of the ACP working group on bananas, stressed that the ACP countries will not be able to bear the consequences of Chiquita’s attempts “to drive us out of the market”.

The ACP share of the EU market has already been squeezed from 26 percent in the mid-1980s to 19 percent by 1994, Laurent said.

“The ACP has already been forced to give up far too much. We can’t afford to give more concessions. For Chiquita, it is a matter of market share. For us, we stand to lose everything.”

According to Wenner, production of Latin American bananas, controlled by U.S. multinational companies, has been increasing since 1988, from some 6.9 million tonnes to 8.12 million tonnes in 1992.

Wenner said that the increased production was forced in anticipation of liberalised trade with the EU and much bigger demand for Latin American bananas, leading to a chronic over- supply in the market and the collapse of prices starting 1991.

“Chiquita claims that the EU regime caused them great financial losses,” said Wenner. “We believe that corrections in 1993 will mean profits of 70 million dollars for Chiquita in 1994, because of the regime.”

The collapse in prices in 1991 led to record losses for Chiquita in 1992 of some 284 million dollars, acknowledged Wenner. “But 1992 was a bad year for everyone, and Chiquita’s losses are not due to the regime.”

The EU sources of bananas include the French departments of Guadaloupe and Martinique, the Canary islands of Spain, the Madeira region of Portugal and Crete in Greece. ACP producer states include the Windward islands, Jamaica, Belize, Cameroon and the Cote d’Ivoire.

According to the APEB, ceding to U.S. demands would result in serious socio-economic problems in EU regions and in most ACP banana producing countries where no alternative to the crop can be found in the middle term.

APEB figures say that the banana industry involves a total of over 350,000 jobs and provides livelihood for 50,000 small family plantations. Changes in the balance will have impacts on other related services.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags