Africa, Development & Aid, Europe, Headlines, Population

FRANCE: Migrants Make Good Development Partners, Not ‘Threats’

Gigi Oyog

PARIS, Dec 26 1996 (IPS) - The image of immigrants has been getting a battering in France recently, with some legislators painting them as a menace to public law and order and proposing new, even more restrictive legislation to curb their inflow.

But while both legislators and the government prepare to follow up last week’s bill readings with new acts to still further clamp down on immigrants, Hartmut Schneider of the Paris-based Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) is calling on France and Europe to look at immigrants not just as threats to security.

“Migrants who are already here should not be looked upon as merely problems of law and order, but as people who can play positive roles to improve the relations between France and the immigrants’ countries of origin,” said Schneider.

Together with Marie-Helene Libercier, Schneider wrote the report “Migrants: Partners in Development Cooperation” for the OECD’s Development Centre which studied mainly the contributions of African migrants in five OECD countries, including the Malians in France.

Both concluded that “immigrants come up against a lack of political goodwill and the obstructions that result: the home- and the host-country governments under-estimate migrants’ potential for cooperation”.

According to a case study prepared by the Panos Institute in Paris, the Malians in France, who migrated mostly from the Kayes region, have provided up to 80 percent of the consumption needs of their villages.

Dependence on migrants’ remittances became particularly pronounced in the 1970s when an economic crisis and drought were strangling Mali, one of the poorest countries in Africa. Highly structured and maintaining close ties with their home country, the Malians in France are among the foremost agents of development in the Kayes region.

But they are also one of the most maligned African communities in France, their frequent accounts of mass deportations carried out on charter flights organised by the government.

France’s National Assembly passed on first reading last week new laws making it more difficult for non-European foreigners to enter and reside in France, hardening even further already repressive proposals of Interior Minister Jean-Louis Debre.

With the Senate expected to hold their own debate on the government proposals in January before a mixed group from both chambers of Congress meets to harmonise their versions, it is unclear what the final laws will be.

But migrant rights organisations have denounced the legislation just passed by the National Assembly, stressing that it will not provide long-term solutions.

Gone is the possibility that illegal migrants living in France for the past 15 years could be given their residence papers. Foreign spouses of French nationals would also have to wait two years before being given a temporary (one-year) permit, instead of one year as obtains at present.

Fingerprints would also be taken of foreigners asking to enter France. But one of the major amendments carried by the most conservative wing of the ruling majority, would be the possibility to deny the renewal of 10-year residence permits if the immigrant represented “a threat to public order”.

The government proposals and the subsequent Parliamentary debates arose as a consequence to the movement earlier this year by some 300 Africans who sought refuge in Catholic churches in Paris and to remedy the anomalies of stricter laws passed in 1993 when “zero immigration” Charles Pasqua was still Interior Minister.

Before it was forcefully interrupted by police authorities, 10 Africans had gone on a hunger strike for some 40 days to draw attention to the plight of certain categories of immigrants who could not be given residence permits but could not be deported either.

In drafting immigration policy, Schneider said that “one should also look at longer-term concerns and one should not be guided by short-term events like election campaigns. One should look at immigration policy from a distance and with serenity, and within a broader view.”

“There are some activities by certain official bodies who do not consider migrants as problems of law and order. But in general, there is indeed an imbalance, to the disadvantage of everyone,” said Schneider.

Nothing suggests a future decline in the flows of migrants from developing countries, concluded the report. “At a time when migratory pressure is growing world-wide, the objective of zero immigration is unrealistic.”

The weight of migration and the stakes are such that, for both home and host countries, the advantages to be reaped from looking at migration from the broader view of development should be re- examined.

A predominant view in host countries linking immigration and development is too restrictive, argued the authors. According to this view, to have less immigration, more development in the home country is needed.

In contrast, Limercier and Schneider proposed recognising immigrants and their associations, taking them in as actors and mediators in the formulation of immigration and development cooperation policies.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags