Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

MIDDLE EAST: Albright’s Appointment Unwelcome Among Arab States

Commentary Dilip Hiro

LONDON, Dec 6 1996 (IPS) - The appointment of Madeleine Korbel Albright as United States secretary of state bodes ill for the future of the already tottering Middle East peace process.

While her elevation from the U.S. ambassador at the United Nations to the top diplomatic job in Washington has been welcomed in Israel, it has left the Arab capitals downcast.

During her four years at the United Nations in New York she left little doubt about her uncritical backing for Israel. At the same time she took an uncompromisingly hard line on Iraq and its president, Saddam Hussein.

Albright has been exceptionally influential in the administration of President Bill Clinton. As the U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, she enjoyed cabinet rank. But, unprecedently, Clinton also appointed her as a full member of the National Security Council.

She purportedly played a leading role in the shaping of the presidential decision to veto a United Nations Security Council resolution condemning Israel for its confiscation of Palestinian land in occupied Arab East Jerusalem in April 1995, which was backed by all the remaining 14 members. It was the first time that the U.S. used its veto in the post-Cold war era.

Later the Israeli government of Yitzhak Rabin backtracked on this issue when it found its thin parliamentary majority under threat in the house where a no-confidence motion was tabled.

The result was that the United States — and in particular, Albright — ended up looking more Israeli than Israelis. And the incident left a deep mark on the Arab world. .

Now what worries Arab diplomats and policy-makers is that, as it is, President Bill Clinton himself is so staunchly pro-Israel that during his last visit to the Jewish sate in March the country’s leading political commentator called him ‘the last Zionist’.

On top of that to have a secretary of state who is even more pro- Israeli than the president is to compound the bias of the U.S. stance towards Israel to an unacceptable degree.

Arab capitals now fear that this can only make Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu more intransigent in his negotiations with the Palestinians, and alienate the Arab world, thus hampering progress towards a comprehensive peace in the Middle East.

In her manner, Albright is a contrast to her predecessor, Warren Christopher. A diffident, self-effacing man in his early 70s, a lawyer by training, Christopher was ill at ease in front of television cameras.

If and when he had setbacks he masked them with a certain resignation, and kept both his temper and nerve — valuable qualities in a diplomat. Little wonder that his performance won him the nickname of ‘Saint Christopher’.

Albright thrives in the glare of television lights. A professor of international affairs at Georgetown University before her appointment to the United Nations, she is flamboyant and prone to lecturing. Subtlety and understatement are not the hallmarks of her performance.

And the overall image she conveys is that of a cold, hard woman, and self-righteous to boot. Given half a chance, she is likely to get into a confrontational mode than a compromising one. Even her friends and colleagues call her abrasive.

Her campaign against the re-election of Boutrous Boutros-Ghali as U.N. secretary-general is a case in point. It has been noisy and blatant. And it has provided her critics with enough evidence to justify their epithet of ‘The Queen of the Mean’ for her.

While Boutros-Ghali, a former deputy foreign minister of Egypt, a member of the Organisation of African Unity (OAU), represents Africa at the United Nations, he is also an Arab. He has had the unanimous backing of the 22-member Arab League for a second term as the U.N. secretary-general. Boutros-Ghali is also a Christian and that he has a Jewish wife, named Leah. But none of this cuts much ice with Albright.

Indeed what irreparably soured Boutros-Ghali’s relations with Albright waa the report he commissioned from a U.N.-appointed Dutch general on the massacre of 101 Lebanese refugees at the U.N. base near Qana in southern Lebanon last April during the massive bombardment of the area by Israel.

The U.N. report concluded that, contrary to the Israeli claim that its soldiers had fired shells at Hezbollah guerrillas operating near the Qana U.N. base, the Israeli troops had deliberately targeted the U.N. camp where some 800 Lebanese civilians were sheltering

Albright put immense pressure on Boutros-Ghali not to publish the report which was highly damaging to Israel. To his credit, Boutros- Ghali rebuffed the pressure, and released the U.N. report, thus reaffirming his independence. Apparently the U.S. in general, and Albright in particular never forgave Boutros-Ghali for that.

Albright’s hostile campaign against Boutros-Ghali has reinforced her already negative image in the Arab world, which includes Egypt and Jordan, the two Arab neighbours of Israel that have signed peace treaties with the Jewish states.

The mood in Syria and Lebanon is even more downbeat. They are at present not conducting peace talks with Israel since the latter refuses to endorse the principle of occupied Arab land for peace.

Netanyahu has said that Israel would not vacate the Syrian Golan Heights. With Albright at the helm at the State Department in Washington, there is little prospect of U.S. pressure on Israel to re-enter talks with Damascus.

So far the Arab League as a body has been reluctant to fully back the position of Syria that all Arab states must immediately freeze relations with Israel. Despite the continued boycott by Syria and Lebanon of the annual regional economic conference, in which Israel is a full participant, Egypt hosted such a gathering in Cairo last month.

While reiterating the earlier position that in order to secure peace Israel must vacate all occupied Arab territories, the statement issued by Arab League foreign ministers’ meeting in Cairo last weekend refrained from spelling out what measures the Arab states would take if Israeli intransigence continued.

The main reason for this restraint was that the Arabs wanted to wait for the new U.S. secretary of state to be announced.

Now that the announcement has been made, confirming the Arabs’ worst fears, the Arab League cannot postpone the task of countering a further tilt towards Israel.

— Dilip Hiro, a London-based IPS analyst on Middle East affairs, is the author of Dictionary Of The Middle East, published by Macmillan, London, and St Martin’s Press, New York.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags