Saturday, November 21, 2026
George John
- When Trinidad and Tobago immigration officers last week barred four Barbadian musicians from entry into the country forcing cancellation of their soca band engagements, watchers on the regional scene viewed a bureaucratic circumstance of tragi-comedy proportions.
In the aftermath, government ministers defended their immigration officers saying the action was in keeping with the country’s laws.
The relevant legislation states that “a person entering Trinidad and Tobago to engage in gainful occupation for a period not exceeding 30 days in every 12 consecutive months does not need a work permit.”
The quartet had played with their band in Trinidad on Sep. 25 therefore, they needed work permits for which they had not applied. The other members of the band returned home with their banned colleagues without playing a note of music and setting off a furore in Barbados which reached Cabinet.
The Barbados Attorney General, David Simmonds, and Culture Minister Mia Motley both launched an investigation into why the musicians were barred. But the real fear was that the action in Port of Spain could lead to retaliation in Barbados as well as other territories in the Caribbean Community (Caricom) where Trinidad calypsonians and musicians are welcomed all year round.
Indeed Barbadian musicians threatened a boycott of Trinidadian musicians, an action that could affect the Port of Spain Carnival celebrations next February and also could prevent Trinidad musicians joining in the Bridgetown “Crop Over” festival in August.
The Port of Spain decision flew in the face of near futile attempts to unite the Anglophone Caribbean in the areas of politics, economics, and social concerns. The successes have been few, one of these being in the field of West Indies cricket.
One such team of cricketers from Jamaica, Barbados, Trinidad and Tobago and the Windward and Leeward Islands is now playing an important series of games in Australia under the banner of the West Indies, as they have been doing for 96 years.
The cricketers have overcome persistent complaints of insularity in team selection to rise to the top against England, Australia, New Zealand, India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, and South Africa. The present team is led by a Jamaican, whose predecessor is from Antigua. The vice-captain is from Trinidad and Tobago.
Another success was seen this month when approximately 3,000 students participated in graduation ceremonies at the three campuses of the University of the West Indies in Jamaica, Barbados and Trinidad and Tobago. Students cross over for study from one campus territory to another with national allegiances muted to the point where one is familiar with the different accents, it is impossible to know who is from where.
And last month West Indian public servants and representatives of non-governmental organizations (NGOs) sat around conference tables in Port of Spain discussing in one the presentation of a common front of trade and environment issues at the World Trade Organisation ministerial meeting in Singapore next month and in the other case assessing problems related to the development of common regional understanding of potential climate change and how to respond nationally and regionally.
On the immigration front all the territories have work permit legislation which inhibits the free movement of labour from one territory to another. It is one of the main sticking points which has impeded progress to real regional integration from the period of the short-lived West Indies Federation, 1958-62, to Caricom which has been discussing and debating the matter for two decades.
The West Indian Commission appointed by the heads of government with the mission of formulating proposals to advance the regional integration process grasped the nettle bravely.
The Commission, headed by the Guyana-born Sir Shridath Ramphal, retired Commonwealth Secretary-General, recommended in its voluminous 1992 report, “Time For Action”,”that there be the earliest implementation throughout Caricom of recommendations already adopted for ensuring “hassle-free travel for West Indian graduates of the University of the West Indies and the University of Guyana and other designated universities and media personnel should have the right to live and work anywhere in the region as a start of the process towards mobility of people within the Caricom Single Market.”
The commission saw that the logic of freedom of movement for all categories of West Indian professionals, skilled personnel and workers generally and entrepreneurs, including hucksters, would have to be permitted to work its way through the system.
Trinidad and Tobago’s Foreign Minister, Ralph Maraj, said this week the government intended to amend the law in keeping with a Caricom heads of government resolution which called for free movement within the region of media workers, entertainers and artistes.
So far, the law in Trinidad and Tobago allows free movement only to Caricom nationals who are graduates in accounting, dentistry, engineering, law and medicine of the University of the West Indies and the University of Guyana.
Barbados, just 25 minutes by air from Trinidad, boasts that it removed restrictions on Caribbean artistes two years ago and they were all free to enter.
Meanwhile, amid all the furore, tourists from the United States, Canada, Britain, Germany and elsewhere in Europe are free to walk past immigration officers in most Caribbean islands by merely showing an identification card or a driver’s licence.