Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

ENVIRONMENT-BELIZE: Indigenous People Question Highway Project

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Nov 7 1996 (IPS) - The Maya people of southern Belize face dispossession and impoverishment at the hands of a highway project on the road to funding approval by the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB), indigenous peoples’ and environmental advocates say.

Fearing that the Belizean government will seek out investors immune to public scrutiny and pressure if the IDB rejects its loan application, however, the groups want the Washington-based bank to go ahead. But they want it to make sure the government meets international environmental and human-rights standards in paving the road and granting concessions to loggers on adjacent lands.

“Our clients are not against paving the road,” Steven Tullberg, director of the Indian Law Resource Centre, told IPS. “They’re not against change, but they’re very serious about not being pushed aside or run over.”

The Centre’s pro-bono lawyers have been retained by the Toledo Maya Cultural Council, a non-governmental organisation (NGO) based in Toledo district, southern Belize.

If approved, the 60-million-dollar loan would be the IDB’s first one to the tiny Central American country. It would enable the government to pave and upgrade an existing roadway, making it a route for heavy-goods traffic through traditional communal lands that have provided the Mayas with food, medicine and their culture, and to which they are seeking legal title.

Additionally, environmental organisations want the IDB to conduct environmental impact assessments that take into account the direct and indirect impact of the highway and lumber industry on the area’s forests, watersheds, rivers, and coasts, as well as potential side-effects in the coral reefs off northern Belize.

The higway “would basically amount to a logging road which could accelerate unsustainable harvesting of timber and result in significant environmental degradation,” Tullberg said in an Oct. 18 letter to IDB executive vice president Nancy Birdsall.

Since 1995, the government has granted at least 17 long-term logging concessions in Toledo district to foreign-owned companies. Already, one company has built a sawmill directly off the roadway.

Described in press reports as one of the country’s biggest sawmills, the new structure has fueled speculation that the loggers’ promise of selective logging soon will give way to large- scale clear-cutting.

The concessions cover some 224,600 hectares and cut deep into traditional Mayan lands, according to maps produced by the Maya Mapping Project under the auspices of the University of California, Berkeley. The Maya say they were not consulted before the concessions were granted.

“The development of a massive industrial export-oriented logging industry in Toledo is an environmental nightmare,” Julian Cho of the Toledo Maya Cultural Council told journalists recently. “This runaway logging is a national crisis. The Mayas are aware that these powerful forces are aligning themselves to quickly and permanently change their lives and challenge the viability of the basic elements of their culture.”

Government officials say the logging will remain small-scale and selective, and will be governed by a 1994 forest management plan which, they say, was written with help from the British government to widespread acclaim. But many of the national forest inspectors charged with supervising the logging themselves have been felled by the budget axe, say environmentalists and journalists who visited the area in September.

What’s more, the plan is being violated under the government’s nose, according to environmental groups’ action alerts on the Internet and press reports. Prohibited species and untagged trees in prohibited areas have been cut down; roads have been bulldozed through prohibited areas; and logging has continued through the rainy season, thus accelerating environmental damage.

This in a country where “ecological and anthropological tourism figure prominently,” accounting for some 30 percent of export earnings, according to the World Bank. Toledo district alone is home to a number of Mayan sites and beaches that make it a priceless resource, environmentalists add.

“If they’re interested in going into debt, why not do it for something like ecotourism that is a proven engine of their economy but needs more investment to develop sustainably,” Arturo Garcia- Costas, legal advisor to the Washington-based Natural Resources Defence Council (NRDC), said of the government’s loan application.

Well-placed sources say the Belize loan has pitted operations staff against senior management. Staffers responsible for environmental and indigenous affairs reportedly are sympathetic to the NGOs, but their bosses are understood to want to sign up a new client, whatever the cost.

Nevertheless, senior management has stalled the loan approval process to allow Birdsall to meet with the NGOs upon her return from travel later this month. The Mayas’ lawyers have been joined by representatives of the NRDC, the Centre for International Environmental Law, and Conservation International.

Deforestation claims some 7.5 million hectares a year in Latin America and the Caribbean and the forests remaining in Central America and Mexico are being destroyed at “the highest rate of any subregion in the world,” according to the IDB’s latest annual report on the environment and natural resources. The major reasons for this include “weak timber concession allocation resources.”

The report, which an IDB spokesman described as a de facto policy statement, adds that “indigenous peoples and other forest dwellers should be able to express and negotiate their interests in forest protection and policies. Actions should be promoted that help resolve land use conflicts and facilitate the decision-making process for these groups.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags