Saturday, November 21, 2026
Humberto Márquez
- Venezuela is discussing changes to its legal code that would reduce trial time and generally make the system more open and accountable.
The existing system involving a single judge listening to evidence and reaching a verdict based on a strict interpretation of written laws would be changed to a three-member panel: a judge and two lay persons.
Documents would be used only to supplement oral presentations to this tribunal. And more media coverage will be allowed to reduce the number of cases which take place behind closed doors.
Reform of the legal system has been on the cards for 15 years. Concrete proposals in this regard did not reach parliament until late 1996, after a campaign by Carlos Tablante, a socialist governor. He demanded that Parliament declare a “judicial emergency” in much the same way as the unprecedented banking crisis in 1994 was dealt with as a “financial emergency”.
Most cases in Venezuela are decided by a single judge who sticks rigorously to written law. And evidence is handled within a rigid framework supported by a special Judicial Police controlled by the Ministry of Justice.
This form of justice has always been slow and unwieldy. Surveys carried out among citizens, criminologists, investors and human rights non-governmental organisations (NGOs) include the legal system among the biggest cause of complaints.
A court case in Venezuela takes an average of three and a half years. The South American nation has 25,000 prisoners languishing in jail, two thirds of them still awaiting sentence.
Statistics from 1994 and 1995 show that one prisoner dies in captivity every day. This deficient justice system affects poor and rich alike: former president Carlos Andres Perez (1989-1993) and several of his ministers constantly complained of delays and problems while they were facing trial.
People from poor neighbourhoods of Caracas and other cities have taken the law into their own hands, lynching more than 20 suspected criminals. At first the majority of the judges rejected Tablante’s ideas, but the reform now being discussed in Parliament has gained their support.
“We need to show the country and those who come from abroad that we have an ideal judicial power,” said Pedro Reyes, former president of the Judicial Council.
“The new penal system will unleash a radical transformation of the Venezuelan Judicial Power,” Attorney General Ivan Badell told the Caracas daily ‘El Universal’. “There will be no more cards hidden up sleeves and nothing will be done behind the back of the public,” he declared.
Courts will follow “the principles of the pure trial systems: oral presentations, publicity, speed and concentration,” said Social Christian Luis Oberto, leader of the parliamentary legislative commission.
Fewer cases will be heard behind closed doors, though television cameras will not be allowed in because they “give a partial vision and create impressions which do not agree with the truth”.
Acceleration of the trial process will enable cases to be heard in a smaller number of hearings and there will be more business in each session.
Alberto Perez, president of the council which administers nearly 1,400 courts, said oral hearings with lay judges “will eliminate the practice of torture as a means to extract confessions, as only statements made before the court will be valid.”
During trials now a certified judge will be supported by two “common citizens” chosen at random from adults with no criminal background and a certain, as yet undecided, level of education.
This point is a great bone of contention. Some believe involving lay people in court proceedings “could be very dangerous”. Others believe Venezuela should introduce trials by jury.
“There must be a preeminence of lawyers when justice is administered,” said lawyer Liliana Hernandez, from the non- governmental group Cofavic which opposes impunity in cases where civilians are killed in demonstrations and within the prisons.
However, she said “it is important to link the community to the passing of justice, for society to become legally conscious and because the more eyes there are on the processes, the smaller are chances for impunity.”
Closed summary sessions will become a thing of the past. Only details of police action prior to the opening of the case will continue in secrecy, said Badell.
The Public Prosecutor’s office will be reinforced and granted control over the Judicial Police, a body of detectives who theoretically support the judges but who, in practice, end up patrolling and carrying out commando operations and anti- subversive missions.
According to Oberto, the new system for administrating justice will not be more expensive than the present form, except for initial expenditure on physical conditioning and technical and professional training programmes which would be paid for by a loan from the World Bank.
Hernandez said training is one of the most crucial aspects, “in order for the reform of the penal procedure not to become a false front, a facelift which leaves the attitudes of public prosecutors and the judges unchanged.”
“A non-cosmetic reform of the penal legislation must incorporate conventions and documents of international legislation defending human rights into Venezuelan law, for these were officially accepted but not translated into the laws or behaviour of the State,” said Hernandez. (FIN/IPS/hm/ag/ip/fn/96)
= 10021220 DAP0039