Development & Aid, Environment, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Population

INDIGENOUS PEOPLES: Caution On Effectiveness Of New Arctic Council

Angeline Oyog and Asbjoern Thomassen

PARIS/OSLO, Sep 18 1996 (IPS) - An eight-country ‘Arctic Council’ is to be launched in Ottawa Thursday, to coordinate the environmental, economic, social and cultural policies governing the nine million people who live north of the 60th parallel.

But observers warn that as long as it denies the Arctic peoples the right to a full vote and sidesteps military issues, the Council will be ineffective.

“This region is vital for the world which has been polluted for economic, political and military reasons,” said Christian Meriot, professor at the University of Bordeaux in France and a specialist on indigenous groups in the Arctic region.

“The indigenous peoples have managed their territories for millennia without destroying their environment. But we have now polluted everything. And that represents a danger for us and our children, because the state of the climate and the resources of the Arctic region will affect the rest of the world.”

Three indigenous peoples’ groups — the Inuit Circumpolar Conference, the Saami Council (Norway, Sweden and Finland) and the Association of Indigenous Minorities of the North, Siberia and the Far East of the Russian Federation — have permanent membership, though they will not have voting rights.

“They are minorities, they have no voice and no decision- making powers,” said Meriot. “They are not represented in democratic institutions.”

“They will be full participants,’ Canadian Foreign Minister Lloyd Axworthy told the Ottawa Citizen newspaper when the conference was announced. “The only difference is that when it comes down to the final decision-making, the governments, by nature of international organisations, have to be the ones that express their ‘yes’ and ‘no’s’.”

The Council, which will meet at the ministerial level once every two years, is to operate by consensus, without the need for votes where possible — but where votes are forced, each state has a veto.

Foreign ministers and ministers responsible for Arctic and aboriginal affairs from Canada, Denmark (for Greenland), Finland, Iceland, Norway, Russia, Sweden and the United States will sign the agreement to establish the Council on Thursday. Canada is to be the first holder of the Council’s two-year rotating chairmanship.

The Council’s coordination tasks cover everything from pollution threats from abandoned Soviet nuclear submarines to ice-breaking technology and possible Arctic trade deals.

It is to incorporate existing programmes of the Arctic Environmental Protection Strategy (AEPS), in which the eight will agree to cooperate in controlling pollution, and to work out economic development programmes that will help sustainable development.

The AEPS was signed in 1991 to deal with ecological problems such as the build-up of toxic organic compounds and the management of endangered species. The council is to extend the AEPS’ reach to include issues such as sustainable development and the impact of climate change on the region’s indigenous peoples.

“There has been a spectacular retreat of the glaciers,” said Thierry Brossard, a specialist at the Paris-based National Scientific Research Centre (CNRS) who heads a research group working on the Arctic region.

“Since the beginning of the century, glaciers have depressed by one kilometre or in terms of volume, there has been a 30 percent loss of glaciers.”

Brossard said the worst ecological problems are due to the industrial nations — the eight Council members chief among them — by building pipelines, dams and running oil exploration activities, but said careless economic development by indigenous communities had brought some problems as well.

“It’s a fatal spiral. The people need more and more income to buy more and more snowmobiles. So they raise more money by raising more reindeer. The over-grazing hurts the pastures.”

He said that everything would depend on the commitment of the Council member states. But their historical interest has always been inconsistent. A recent Canadian government policy paper noted that the history of Canadian Arctic policy reflects “long periods of official disinterest, even neglect, punctuated by episodes of frantic attention”.

— In Oslo the Nordic Council has announced that is to award its Nature and Environmental Prize for 1996 to the Greenland based Inuit Circumpolar Conference (ICC) one of the three NGOs associated with the new Council.

The prize is worth 350,000 Danish kroner (about 54,600 dollars) and will be handed over to the organisation at the Nordic Council’s next meeting in Copenhagen, on Nov. 12.

The ICC was founded in 1989 to strengthen the cooperation between the various Inuit organisations in Alaska, Canada, Greenland and Russia.

“Since the ICC was founded in 1989 it has done a unique work to take care of the conditions and mode of living for indigenous peoples, and especially the Inuit. This has as a purpose among others to keep a sustainable environmental development,” the jury said in a press release.

“ICC has been very active in the work of the Arctic Environment Protection Strategy (AEPS) where the organisation has cooperated closely with the home government of Greenland to the benefit of peoples in the Arctic”.

“The Inuit organisation has also worked actively for humans rights, cultural cooperation and for a political strategy for the Arctic”. The Nordic Council is a cooperation body for the governments and parliaments of Denmark, Finland, Island, Norway and Sweden.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags