Saturday, November 21, 2026
Vivienne Siva
- The newspaper caption was wrong, but for several days it sparked intense discussion and some amount of controversy.
The caption which accompanied the wedding photograph of popular University of the West Indies lecturer and newspaper columnist Carolyn Cooper to the British university lecturer, Cecil Gutzmore in error identified the husband as Cecil Cooper, indicating that he had taken her name.
Although the caption was quickly corrected, and Cooper herself wrote in her column that he did not take her name as he is “not dat (that) liberated,” the idea that a Jamaican man could have taken his wife’s name shocked many Jamaican men.
Men and women from all socio-economic backgrounds and educational levels were divided on the issue.
There is no stipulation in Jamaican law that says a woman has to take her husband’s surname in marriage. In fact, according to Attorney-at-law Margaret MaCaulay, the partners to a marriage can take any name they choose.
She says as far as her investigations have shown there are only two countries in the world — France and Poland — where the law states that a woman must take her husband’s name.
“It’s really just tradition that has been handed down,” she says. But despite this legal freedom, many men did not hide their disappointment when the possibility of such a situation arising was brought to their attention.
Some even began to question the sexual orientation of any man who would ‘give up his name’.
Women, on the other hand were more receptive to the idea and some even felt that it would be a true test of a man’s love and commitment.
This attitude cuts across classes and age groups.
Clive Campbell, an engineer with a university degree has been married for 10 years. He admits that a man taking his wife’s name is totally inconceivable.
“When I read the caption, I just felt that the husband was soft and that she would definitely be the one in charge.
Some fear that the power relations between the sexes would be threatened if this should become a trend in Jamaica where men are perceived as head of the household where there is such a family unit.
There are some 46 percent female-headed households in Jamaica.
Campbell admits that while he knows that there really is nothing wrong with a husband taking his wife’s name the concept seems to emasculate men.
Recently here, there has also been a trend of more women retaining their names and merely adding that of their husbands after the marriage.
Vivian Blane, a minister of religion says Campbell’s reaction is typical of how Jamaican men feel. “We are not very liberated. You would be surprised that many men still insist that the wedding vows include their wives to love, honour and obey them,” says Blane.
He says Jamaican men are still very chauvinistic and are suffering from the ‘residue of 400 years of slavery and colonisation’ which had many black men feeling that they could only assert themselves in the home with their wives and children.
The home, for many men, was the only place where they could be the ruler. Even the most ‘so-called liberated man would balk at the idea of taking his wife’s name, he says.
“When I saw the caption, I have to admit that my initial reaction was why.” Blane says men in Jamaica are still preoccupied with anything that will “emasculate them.” How they dress, speak, how they interact with their children, whether or not they are faithful to their wives or girlfriends is very important to them and any kind of threat to this will be resisted.
However, Blane says more men are leaving the island to travel particularly to North America to study and work and this exposure has brought about changes in their attitudes.
In addition, many Jamaican women are no longer “being long suffering” or are putting up with chauvinism.
MaCaulay who is also co-ordinator of the Association of Women’s Organisations in Jamaica (AWOJA) agrees with Blane. She says the attitude of some Jamaican men is slowly changing and recent amendments to legislation dealing with citizenship and nationality have brought women on an equal level with men.
Prior to the 1993 amendment to the Citizenship and Nationality Law, a Jamaican woman could pass on her nationality to her children if the child’s father was not a Jamaican. A non-Jamaican male could not automatically gain Jamaican citizenship if he married a Jamaican woman, but this was automatic to foreign women marrying Jamaican men.