Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

PERU-CHILDREN: Should Paedophiles be Castrated?

Abraham Lama

LIMA, Sep 13 1996 (IPS) - The case of Nicolas Gutierrez, who confessed to the rape and murder of 11 girls aged between six and nine years old, has sparked debate on the human rights of sex criminals.

On Sep. 2, Gutierrez, 25, a drug addict who confessed he had never had a girlfriend of his own age, was caught in the act of raping an eight year-old child in Parcona, a rural suburb of Ica, 200 km south of Lima.

Gutierrez later admitted murdering four girls whose bodies were found with their torn school uniforms by their side, and another seven children in two marginal neighbourhoods in southern Lima.

According to his confessions, which he repeated twice in front of the television cameras, he has an irresistible attraction to small girls and follows them around for several days before taking them to secluded spots.

“I feel a sort of internal current which I cannot control with my will,” he said.

“I killed them because when they cried they made me feel so terribly desperate,” he added. He said that in all the cases he had also raped the children repeatedly.

The case has had particular resonance in the local media because the issue of sexual violence against children was the subject of a recent international conference in Stockholm. That conference took place in the shadow of gruesome discoveries in Belgium about the victims of a multiple child abuser and murderer.

There are three rapes per hour in Peru. The Demus Studies Centre estimates that 25,000 rapes are committed annually, including a large number against children.

Gutierrez admitted to the cases committed in recent months in which his victims were strangled. Authoriteis believe he may have raped other girls at other times without killing them.

Surveys carried out since the incident indicate that 80 percent of the population want the death penalty for paedophiles. Seventeen percent support the new “chemical castration” (the inhibition of the sexual impulse by hormone injections) and the remainder would like life imprisonment imposed on victims.

In political circles, opinion is mixed. Some parliamentary initiatives have been suggested to allow for the death penalty, chemical castration and life imprisonment for those who rape children less than seven years old.

But in principle, Catholic groups and civil organisations working in defence of human rights are all opposed to the death penalty and chemical castration.

The Peruvian constitution allows for the imposition of the death penalty for treason, and then only in times of war. Punishment cannot be extended to other crimes because the South American nation is signatory to the Treaty of San Jose against the death penalty.

Child rape is punished according to the age of the victims: 20 to 25 years in prison for the under sevens, 15 to 20 years for seven to ten year-olds and 10 to 15 years for 10 to 14 year-olds.

In practice, the abusers generally serve only a third of the nominal sentence, as the “judicial” years are only nine months long, and up to half the term can be lifted for good behaviour in prison.

Consequently, even in the most serious case, committed against a child aged less than seven years-old, the criminal can be free after only seven years. Experts say this partly explains why there are so many repeat offenders.

Psychiatric medicine does not consider paedophilia to stem from neurochemical causes and it cannot be treated with psychoanalysis nor educational programmes.

“This is the core of the problem. If it is an illness, it could be seen as technically unpunishable, and a more or less able defence attorney could avoid prison for their client, getting them detained in a mental hospital where they could either stay forever, or be released shortly afterwards,” said the lawyer Abel Linares.

Unlike his colleague Mary Vargas, from the Demus centre, Linares accepts the idea of life imprisonment for paedophiles, but like her, he opposes the death penalty or chemical castration.

Vargas said “the increasingly drastic punishments do not reduce the incidence of the crime, and on the contrary, they increase the chances of the victim being killed so they cannot identify the attacker.”

Carmen Pimentel, social worker and author of the book “The Family and its Problems in the Poor Urban Sectors,” rejects castration, even in its chemical form, as an inhuman act. She also objects to the death penalty.

“Maybe life imprisonment (would be acceptable), but in decent conditions, to rehabilitate the criminal.”

Pimentel works in the Villa El Salvador neighbourhood. She believes paedophilia and rape “are caused by poverty, frustration and the social violence of Peru, and they must be fought with ethical education and the promotion of a culture of human solidarity and love.”

The sociologist Imelda Vega, author of a book on youth sexuality “Love and sex in the AIDS era,” also rejects the death penalty and said the hormone treatment impractical as it is “too costly” for Peru, adding that life imprisonment “in the extreme cases” could be an option.

Meanwhile, member of parliament, Beatriz Merino, director of the Women’s Commission in Congress, supported the death penalty, “or at least with the hormonal treatment which is called chemical castration, because we need to eliminate these abhorrent crimes.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags