Environment, Headlines, North America

US-ENVIRONMENT: Coal Mine Expansion in Tennessee Draws Fire

Glenn A Himebaugh

LAKE CITY, Tennessee, Aug 19 1996 (IPS) - The rugged Cumberland Plateau in eastern Tennessee, home the highest waterfall in the United States east of the Rocky Mountains, has become the centre of coal- mining controversy.

At the centre of the controversy is the 52-year-old Fall Creeks State Resort Park and Natural Area, a crown jewel in Tennessee’s state park system, which attracted 934,654 visitors in 1994.

Local environmentalists charge that this tourist attraction is about to be devastated by a plan to strip mine for coal in the park’s unprotected watershed by Skyline Coal of Dunlap, Tennessee, a wholly owned subsidiary of Cyprus Amax Minerals.

Cyprus, one of the biggest copper mining companies in this country, has recently started to expand its operations to Third World countries, including Peru, where it recently bought a major copper mining concession in the southern part of the country.

Environmental activists say that acidic mine runoff wil6 pollute Fall Creek Falls, five other waterfalls and the streams in the park, threatening fragile lands and habitat for trout, cave- dwelling creatures and rare flowers.

Mining operations, activists add, will also affect views from overlooks in the park and part of the proposed Trail of Tears Historical Trail, that marks the forced removal of Native Americans from their ancestral lands and relocation to government reservations.

Project proponents discount these environmental concerns, and they argue that the jobs the expanded mining operation will produce are more important

“We did a study in 1990 and 1991 and found that 83 percent of the mines that were mined in this coal seam and in this Whitewell shale, are today causing acid mine drainage. We would like to see an end to this,” says David Hardeman, a board member of Save Our Cumberland Mountains (SOCM), a 2-00-member group based in this city.

Runoff results when iron pyrite in the shale that has been removed to reach the coal is exposed to air and rain, forming sulphuric acid. Typically, the acid ends up in nearby streams, turning them an ugly reddish orange color and killing aquatic life.

The environmentalists, led by SOCM and Tennesse Citizens for Wilderness Planning, filed an 80-page petition last year with the federal Office of Surface Mining (OSM) to demand that the 34,000 hectares comprising the park’s watershed be declared unsuitable for surface mining, a designation granted to only two other sites in Tennessee.

The company, which filed an 86-page counter petition with the OSM in January, says that modern technology and regulations assure it will be able to control acid mine runoff in a technologically and economically feasible manner.

Skyline currently produces some 500,000 tons of coal a year by strip mining the Sewannee seam of coal about 10 kilometres from the park. The company touts the financial benefits of its operation by noting that it employs 60 people with an annual payroll of 1.9 million dollars, spends 11 million dollars a year to purchase supplies in the region and pays 600,000 dollars in taxes.

In its petition, Skyline says it leases 12,000 hectares — a quarter of its reserve holdings in the area — within the proposed buffer zone. According to Skyline, the Sewanee seam contains another 128 million to 164 million tons of coal in the proposed buffer zone, and three seams there contain unknown quantities of coal reserves.

A lengthy environmental impact study is under way, and an OSM ruling is anticipated sometime in 1997. Skyline already has threatened a long court battle if the OSM rules against, claiming such a ruling would violate the U.S. constitutional guarantee that private lands cannot be seized for public use without “just” compensation.

Meanwhile, the controversy has divided residents and even neighbouring local governments. The Sequatchie County Commission, for example, passed a resolution opposing the SOCM petition, while the Cumberland County Commission issued one in support.

At a recent public hearing in the park, Skyline spokesman Thomas said the company operates under strict federal guidelines. And mining in the proposed buffer zone, he argued, would not damage the environment.

“The first part of this (SOCM) petition that really bothers me is the massive infringement on personal property rights,” Jones said, who was backed by other landowners in the area.

Robert Haston who, with his brother, owns 400 hectares in the area, said, “I have some mixed feelings … but I don’t like people to tell me what I can do with what’s mine.”

Another bone of contention between SOCM supporters and Skyline backers relates to jobs. Environmentalists argue that the park needs to be protected to assure long-range tourism dollars will continue to flow into the region. They say Skyline cannot be counted on to hang around after the coal is gone.

But others point to the area’s 100-year tradition of mining and argue that Skyline’s immediate jobs are the most important consideration. This position was stated in no uncertain terms on a sign posted at an auto service station near the park entrance. It contained the intials SOCM, but station attendants clarified that they stand for Save Our Coal Mines.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags