Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour

INDIA-LABOUR: Garbage Workers Ride to “Hell” and Back Daily

Meena Menon

BOMBAY, Aug 2 1996 (IPS) - For the last 12 years, Vishwanath’s life has been spent loading and unloading garbage, wearing the thinnest of plastic slippers and armed with a shovel in his bare hands.

A migrant from the backward Latur district in the state of Maharashtra, western India, he is a contract worker, earning 30 rupees (a dollar is roughly 35 rupees) for every truckload of garbage that is collected and unloaded.

The dumping ground in the suburbs of this huge megalopolis is vast, over 100 hectares and there is only garbage as far as the eye can see. Open garbage trucks snake in and out, and clinging to the back of each are three contract workers like Vishwanath.

Bombay, renamed Mumbai last year, generates about 4,000 tonnes of refuse every day, and 2,500 tonnes of debris. And it dumps the nearly 2,000 truckloads of garbage daily at four notified landfill sites that are far from the city centre, in the marshy, far-flung suburbs of Deonar, Malad, Gorai and Mulund.

Keeping the city clean is the business of the city corporation, which has some 5,000 men on its rolls employed as loaders. But because of the sheer volume of waste generated by the city of 12 million, the majority of the workers are like Vishwanath, daily wagers employed by contractors, who have been assigned the job of carting away the rubbish by the corporation.

The contractors do not provide the workers with any kind of benefits: no shoes, gloves or masks, and there is no question of medical aid or compensation in case of accident. Often they have to buy the water with which they wash up at the end of the day.

A non-governmental organisation involved with labour issues has been trying to organise the temporary garbage disposal workers at Deonar to form a registered union. Says Milind Ranade of Shramik (labourer), “The municipal corporation has the basic responsibility of solid waste management … the corporation disclaims all responsibility for casual workers.”

In May, a worker fell off a truck and died, and the contractor promised to pay his wife 200 rupees every month. He did so for two months and then stopped. The man was a daily wager, and there is nothing that the wife can do.

Take Ganga Malushre, in his 40s and one of the oldest loaders in Deonar. His knees are covered with sores, and he is bent with the physical exertion of shovelling garbage day in and out ever since he can remember. He says he cannot afford to stop working, there are no retirement benefits for a temporary worker.

The plight of the workers on the corporation payrolls seems no better. In 1991, the Forum for Environmental Concern, linked to Nirmala Niketan, a well-known college of social worker in Bombay, conducted a study of working conditions and occupational hazards at city dumping sites for the municipal workers union, MMU.

The study was tellingly titled ‘A Living Hell’, and was a chilling documentation of what it said were “inhuman and deplorable working conditions.”

“Due to the nature of the garbage and its consequent decomposition, various foul smelling gases are emitted. During summer, due to the intense heat the gases are ignited … the dumping grounds are hazy with various pungent smelling gases, odours, raging fires and smoke. The employees are forced to work in terrible conditions. On the whole, dumping grounds are places of death, decay and desolation,” the report stated.

Equally horrifying was the report’s observation of a very high mortality rate among workers. The average lif-span was 40 to 45 years. An alarming majority suffered from respiratory ailments and skin infections, apart from othopaedic ailments, eye problems and a high incidence of gastro-intestinal problems.

The authoritative study recommended proper restroom facilities, protective equipment, washrooms and toilets, medical care and training of workers in occupational health problems. It also suggested examining alternative methods of garbage disposal.

Six years later, except for a canteen for the workers at Deonar, nothing has changed. A follow-up study carried out recently by a research unit of Nirmala Niketan has confirmed the total neglect of the workers who are helping keep the city clean.

The study by Dr Gracy Fernandes and Dr Anuradha Bakshi has found that workers reported the same health hazards as in the earlier study — acute respiratory tract infection, bronchitis and cough are common; so are gastro-entiritis and parasitism, as well as scabies and dermatitis.

Though the corporation claims it has provided a paltry 70 rupees (approximately two dollars) medical allowance, the

facility of periodic medical check-ups, first aid facilities at the dumping sites and speedy transport in case of accidents, the workers said most of the services were on paper only.

For instance, some workers said they have never received the medical allowance or the benefit of an annual medical examination. The first aid box, they said, was mostly empty and there was no provision for rushing a patient to the hospital in case of a medical emergency.

City corporation officials say there is no money, for waste disposal is at the bottom in the government’s priority list. Tired of petitioning the authorities, activists filed a writ petition in the Bombay High Court demanding redressal for the army of daily wagers working in the open landfills of Bombay.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags