Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

INDIA-DEVELOPMENT: Let Hill Women Lead, They Already do the Work

Sudhamahi Regunathan

ALMORA, India, Aug 1 1996 (IPS) - In hill villages in north India, women do not own the land, but they are the farmers and frequently heads of households.

As well as doing all the child caring and food processing, fetching firewood and water, washing and cleaning, the women do nearly all the farm work. Land preparation, planting, weeding, often even ploughing are a woman’s job.

Yet the government has always designed agricultural services for hill villages with the men in mind. Hill women were neglected, even though they are the backbone of agriculture in the mountains.

For decades, extension workers travelled from village to village in Kumaon and Garhwal, part of the Indian Himalayas, talking to the men, only to find that it did not make the slightest difference to food production.

“We used to go everyday and talk to farmers, but when it came to actual practice, we found the farmers did not heed our advice,” confides an agricultural extension officer attached to an agricultural research institute in the Kumaon region.

The truth was in fact staring them in the face, but the process of finding out seems to have taken years.

“This we found out only later,” the extension officer admits. “We were allowed to talk only to the men of the village. The actual workers were women who often never got to know of improvements or suggestions we gave.”

Hill societies are rigidly patriarchal, and extension workers adhered faithfully to social hierarchies. The benefits flowed to the men, but “they have never worked the land, (and) did not see the need to communicate with the women”, explains the extension officer.

Far from finding the kits of improved seeds and new ways of cultivation useful, hill men are usually dismissive of extension workers. “They say the same thing again and again, nothing new,” declared Manbar of Garud Village.

Extension workers are not dismayed, having learnt their lessons well. The men are not qualified to comment on agro- techniques, because they never work the land, they retort.

That women do double, and often treble, shifts each day, in the house and outside, in unwaged and waged work, is recognised as a worldwide phenomenon.

In hill villages here in the north Indian state of Uttar Pradesh it not uncommon to find the men have gone away, to the towns for work. With the spread of waged work for men, more and more of the family farm work is being done by the women.

The result is not only excessive burdens of work on the women, who still have all the household work to do as well, but it means inevitably the neglect of conservation measures and other investments in the land to maintain crop yields.

But because it is they who are the worst affected, there is widespread evidence that women are quick to respond to incentives and to innovate where opportunities of training, credit, extension services and other inputs are made available.

The experience of the Vivekananda Parvatiya Krishi Anusndhan Shala, an autonomous agricultural institute located in Almora, 400 kms north of the Indian capital in Kumaon, is a good example.

Considering male extension workers were making little headway, it employed women and quickly discovered that its programmes and ideas were accepted far quicker and more enthusiastically.

The most encouraging responses were from two villages, where the ‘satpathis’ or head of the village council were women.

Elaborating on the process of involving women farmers, an extension worker said the response to the project in the first year was “very poor”. But “in the second year we found women standing somewhere at the back and hearing us when we did a demonstration. The villagers had become familiar with us.

“In the third year, we found women coming forward to ask questions. Today we have women contacting us for every little problem on their land,” she added.

In many areas the traditional lower social status of women has proved a serious obstacle to rural development. For instance a survey by the G.B. Pant Institute of Himalayan Environment and Development has revealed this as the major reason for disparity in access to government loans between indigenous communities living on the fringes and dominant groups.

While the backward Harkhotiya Bhotiya utilised only 8 percent of government loans for rural development, the Joharias, also mountain people, had accessed 48 percent.

The Institute has also found a strong correlation between the existence of roads and the greater use of fertilisers, high yielding crops and watersheds. This, in the mountains, has meant the expansion of potato cultivation.

According to a study, “20 percent of households in Sama and Leeti villages have managed an increase in income by producing cash crops (potatoes). It is only after the development of roads that potato cultivation has begun in these villages and now it occupies 25-30 percent of cultivated land.”

Says a social scientist at the Lakshmi Ashram, which is at the forefront of a movement to set up women’s groups in the villages of Kumaon, “Women are keen to improve their methods of working … their problem is the lack of access to agricultural services.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags