Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

INDONESIA-DEVELOPMENT: Poverty Down, But Rich-Poor Gaps Remain

Johanna Son

JAKARTA, Jul 26 1996 (IPS) - Indonesia has chalked up an impressive record for slashing poverty in the past three decades, but now authorities face the equally tough challenge of uplifting the remaining poor in the world’s fourth most populous country.

The success of Indonesia, with a population of 192 million in more than 13,600 islands, in reducing poverty incidence stands out in the developing world and South-east Asia.

Seventy per cent of Indonesians lived below the poverty line 25 years ago. Official figures say this fell to 29 per cent in 1980, 17 per cent in 1990 and down to 14 per cent today.

The archipelago’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) has at the same time been growing by more than seven per cent since 1990.

Still gaps between the ‘haves’ and ‘have nots’ remain sizable.

“As poverty incidence decreases, we anticipate that the remaining poverty may be increasingly difficult to address,” said Rahardi Ramelan, vice chairman of Indonesia’s National Development Planning Agency.

From 1981 to 1991 Indonesia’s unequal level of income was such that the ratio of the highest 20 per cent of income to the lowest 20 per cent was 4.9 to one.

Even more worrisome is the fact that the poor are lacking not only in income, but even moreso in basic ‘human capabilities’ like health and nutrition, says the 1996 Human Development Report issued by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP).

Indonesia, like several other South-east Asian countries, has relatively equitable growth policies but it “could do better in reducing deprivation”, said the report released earlier in July.

Already, analysts say, growing rich-poor gaps are contributing to social pressure in a country that has seen rapid growth and urbanisation in recent decades. “Some people are five BMWs, while the very poor have very little,” a Jakarta resident said.

At this week’s Asia-Pacific workshop addressing the human development report, Ramelan conceded that the government needs to do more to target the very poor and improve their human development.

“Indonesia, while successful at reducing income poverty, still has much more to do in developing people’s basic capabilities,” the report said. “This disparity is reflected in the human development index: Thailand is ranked 52, Indonesia 102” out of 174 countries.

Health pulled down Indonesia on the capability poverty measure (CPM), a new yardstick that the report devised based on basic health, reproduction and literacy. While 17 per cent of Indonesians are income poor, 42 per cent of “capability poor”, the human development report said.

Addressing Indonesia’s poor performance, Ramelan said: “These seem to reflect some of the health areas where we have been aware that our performance was not as strong as we would like.”

In terms of maternal mortality, Indonesia has the highest rate in the seven-member Association of South-east Asian Nations (ASEAN) with 650 per 100,000 live births — compared to the Philippines’ 280 per 100,000.

To address these gaps, Ramelan said the Indonesian government has been stepping up programmes to counter poverty, some of them quite ambitious. The Indonesian government aims to cut poverty incidence further to six per cent at the end of 1998 and virtually eliminate it at the current standard by the year 2003.

Asked if these targets are attainable, Ramelan told IPS: “I’m a planner, so I have calculated everything.”

But sceptics often take issue with the government’s definition of poverty, which officially for city dwellers is just 930 rupiah (approximately 2,300 rupiah equals one dollar) per capita per day and 608 rupiah for those in the countryside.

Some economists say 82 per cent of the population live on a per capita income of 60,000 rupiah (26 dollars) a month or less.

To improve quality of life and not just income, Ramelan said: “There are many aspects to raising human potential, including education, health, poverty and participation measures, but perhaps the key is raising the mandatory education of our children to the nine-year level.”

The government is focusing on getting children to complete nine years’ schooling, under a 10 to 15-year programme. It also has a programme to provide supplementary food for primary school students in villages with sizable poor populations.

The government also launched a poverty alleviation scheme targeted at very poor villages. Each village is allocated 25,000 dollars over three years, to be used as seed money by self-help groups of 30 households each for small enterprises.

“We think of these as a ‘pro-poor’ programmes that will ensure that the poor have adequate access to basic social services,” Ramelan explained.

He also singled out the need for increased efforts to raise the women’s participation in higher education, after getting more girls in primary education. In 1993 to 1994, the ratio of girls to boys in elementary school was 93 per cent. At junior high school it was 87 per cent and at senior high school, 84 per cent.

The success of these initiatives will not be evident for years. But if investments in health and education are crucial to human development, Indonesia has to brush up its performance in these areas.

South Korea spends 4.2 per cent of its Gross National Product (GNP) on education and 2.7 per cent of GDP on health; Malaysia 5.5 per cent and 1.3 per cent respectively.

Comparative Indonesian figures, which are even lower than several South Asian countries, say a lot: it spends 2.2 per cent of GNP on education and only 0.7 per cent on health. These levels of spending rank it lower than many developing countries.

But Indonesia faces constraints in devoting more resources to social development, Ramelan said. “We face a situation where our ability to officially tap funds from the international community is increasingly limited, and currently we are paying more back, in amortisation alone than we receive as inflows.”

Indonesia uses 32 per cent of its exports of goods and services to service its 104 billion dollar external debt.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags