Sunday, November 22, 2026
Kalinga Seneviratne
- Asian immigrants in Australia, weighing the implications of Canberra’s planned new immigration laws, say they would be hardest hit by a scheme that has the trappings of what was once derisively labeled the ‘White Australia’ policy.
The proposed curbs, announced this month by Immigration Minister Philip Ruddock, aim to cut annual immigration by 10,000. Last year, 85,000 new immigrants were admitted to Australia.
The policy seeks to redirect prospective immigrants from the big cities by imposing huge bonds on sponsors who will forfeit the right to reclaim their money should the new arrival(s) fail to spend at least 12 months in a regional area before attempting to settle in the immigrant hubs like Sydney or Melbourne.
According to the proposed policy, sponsors must put up a 30,000 Australian dollar (25,000 dollar) for a spouse or relative that they intend to bring to Australia. Besides having to first settle in rural Australia, the migrants will not be allowed to claim any social security benefits for two years after arrival.
And those are not the only requirements. Indeed, one of the biggest potential barriers to prospective immigrants may be the passing of an English language test — a policy that some say harks back to the so-called ‘White Australia’ policy days.
Chairwoman of the Ethnic Communities Council of New South Wales, Angela Chan says that if the bond policy is adopted in its current form, it would contravene the United Nations Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act of 1986.
Schedule 2 of the Act says: “Everyone lawfully within the territory of a State shall within that territory, have the right to liberty of movement and freedom to choose his residence.”
Chan says that even if sponsors accept the terms of the bond, the policy would still contravene the human rights convention to which Australia is a signatory. “The question is whether it does impinge on the right to freedom of movement.”
Newly elected Greens senator Dr Bob Brown has also attacked the proposed policy. In a television interview on the weekend, he said that the shuffling of people to rural areas where there were not going to be job opportunities or where migrants will be separated from family members who have sponsored them, reflected a “streak of inhumanity” on the part of the authorities.
And as far as the English language test is concerned, both the Tasmanian senator and Chan said it smacked of previous policies that set out to deny “certain” groups of people from being allowed to settle in Australia.
That reference was to what came to be known as ‘White Australia’ policy which was abolished in 1972. Until then, prospective immigrants were required to pass English language tests which were said to be designed in such a way that non-Anglo-Saxons would fail even if just because of their accents.
“We are looking back at the ‘White Australia’ policy and unless we’re very careful about this, this government could see us going right away from the principles of social justice which have underwritten the immigration policy in recent decades,” said Brown.
In the late 1980s and the 1990s, Australia’s immigration programme has undergone a significant change of face. In the last five years or so, for the first time since White colonisation of the continent in the 18th century, there were more Asian migrants coming to settle in Australia than Europeans.
Of last year’s 85,000 new immigrants in Australia, more than half were Asians who make up an estimated two per cent of the country’s 18 million people.
Indeed, Asian migration became an election issue in 1989 when then Opposition leader John Howard campaigned for tighter legislation to stem the flow of Asian migrants which he said posed a threat to social cohesion in Australia.
After he lost the elections and later his party’s leadership, Howard softened his stance on the issue. Now, having won the March elections, his National-Liberal coalition seems bent on keeping good old campaign promises.
The planned changes to the immigration laws would inevitably affect the Asian community more than any other group, observes Chan. “They (Asians) are the latest group of immigrants and so they are the group that will be looking to bring out their families. Families are also very important to them.” she said.
“Although it (the policy) does not say he (Howard) is favouring those with white skin, saying you have to have a good command of English amounts to the same thing,” says Dr Kit Sun Lau, an immigrant from China.
And he adds: “If I’m a citizen and I want to bring my parents out, I think it is my right to do so. That is what a democracy is all about, not having the government dictate to me.”
But Dr Bob Birrell, director of the Centre for Population and Urban Research at Monash University who has consistently argued for immigration curbs, says the proposed measures are necessary, particularly as they relate to the settlement policy.
“In the absence of intervention, further expansion would have been inevitable because of the high propensity of many of our recently arrived migrant communities to sponsor their relatives,” he said.
That view seems to be shared by the majority of Australians.
An opinion poll done by the ‘Sydney Morning Herald’ last month found that nearly two-thirds of those surveyed supported cuts to the immigration programme as well as the rural resettlement policy that prevents family reunions and thereby serves as deterrent to would be sponsors and immigrants.
“The assault on family reunion will be hardest on Asians, who are the biggest users of that part of the programme,” observed political analyst Michael Millett.
And in spite of the expected protests from the immigrant community, he expects the prime minister to push through with the legislation “assured in the knowledge that this is one policy in which he can be guaranteed majority public support”.
Kalinga Seneviratne
- Asian immigrants in Australia, weighing the implications of Canberra’s planned new immigration laws, say they would be hardest hit by a scheme that has the trappings of what was once derisively labeled the ‘White Australia’ policy.
(more…)