Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Global Warming Best Fought with Pollution Credits, Report Says

Stephen Dale

OTTAWA, Jul 4 1996 (IPS) - Controlling global warming would be cheaper and more effective if companies from industrialised countries were given credit at home for their anti-pollution efforts in the developing world, according to Canadian and Indian researchers.

In a report produced jointly by the North-South Institute in Ottawa and the Indira Gandhi Institute for Development Research (IGIDR) in Bombay, researchers concentrated mostly on the “economic instruments” that could be used to control worldwide emissions of carbon dioxide, a leading contributor to global warming.

The report advocates a two-fold plan where industrialised countries would impose domestic restrictions on greenhouse gas emissions and then introduce a system of “tradable emissions permits,” allowing companies to use overseas work to control carbon dioxide (CO2) as a credit against their domestic obligations.

“We presume that at some point, in order to make companies reduce their production of CO2, the Canadian government is going to be forced to either impose regulations or impose some kind of a carbon tax,” explained Andrew Clark, senior researcher at the North-South Institute.

“Now a company in Canada faced with this scenario would have two options: One would be to do the work in Canada; the other would be to go abroad and do the work at a very much lower cost,” Clark told IPS.

According to the study, the benefits of concentrating CO2- reduction work in the developing world extend far beyond cost considerations. This form of “joint implementation” between countries, researchers said, would “reduce global emissions by a greater amount and at a lower cost than carbon tax alone.”

Additionally, they argued, it would benefit developing countries “in terms of resource inflow”

Emphasis on lowering CO2 emissions in the South is based on the belief that rapid industrialisation in Asia and Latin America will intensify the strain on the earth’s atmosphere.

“You have to see global warming as a long-term problem,” stressed Clark. “The North currently puts a lot more greenhouse gasses into the atmosphere than the south, but after the next 10 years the reverse will be true.”

According to the joint India-Canada report, the increase in greenhouse gas production in the South will come largely as a result of “plans to expand energy capacity via thermal electric generators, and because of ongoing construction projects requiring substantial quantities of cement — both of which are significant sources of CO2.”

Clark said that the intent of the report is to recognise that developing countries have the right to embark on this process of industrialisation, and that such growth is necessary for the alleviation of poverty.

“This is a real North-South dilemma,” said Clark. “The South needs to consume more energy in order to grow and to reduce poverty. The trick is to get them onto low-emitting technologies so as to reduce the impact on the atmosphere.”

And that’s the function that the transferable credits are designed to serve.

Clark argued that it is unjust to expect developing nations to pay the higher price for the more ecologically-friendly means of energy generation, particularly since most of the accumulated greenhouse gasses in the atmosphere were put their by northern countries.

In effect, having corporations transfer technology to reduce emissions in exchange for a domestic credit, he explains, is a way of making the North, rather than the developing nations themselves, pick up the tab.

Canada and India already have been engaged in joint projects aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

According to Brian Moore, acting director of the environment division of energy policy at Natural Resources Canada, his ministry is supporting two initiatives by the Canadian energy resource company Transalta to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in India.

One initiative is a “line loss project” that seeks to better insulate electrical transmission cables so that less energy is lost, and thus less needs to be generated. The other project provides enhanced feed for cattle so that they produce less methane gas.

There are no current plans to impose taxes on carbon-based fuels or to devise a system of transferable credits, said Moore, since it was decided at the 1995 Climate Change conference in Berlin that such initiatives should be deferred until after the year 2000.

Conferees did agreed that there should be a voluntary “pilot phase” for implementation of joint initiatives on climate change, “which is designed to test on the ground the whole concept of joint initiatives, and many of the practicalities, particularly the ways of measuring changes in the emissions of greenhouse gasses,” says Moore.

However, when the second Conference of Parties on the Climate Change Convention meets next week (July 8) in Geneva, the idea of transferable credits and carbon taxes are sure to be a topic of renewed discussion.

The North South-IGIDR report drew a mixed response from Canadian environmentalists.

Louise Comeau, climate change coordinator for the Sierra Club in Ottawa, and a member of the Climate Action Network, said the strongest aspect of the study is that it firmly supports carbon taxes and government regulation of industries that produce greenhouse gasses, measures that Canada’s powerful energy industry has bitterly opposed.

But Comeau criticised the proposal to allow companies transferable pollution-control credits as a means for them to escape commitments to lower greenhouse gasses within Canada. “Our position is that the first thing that should happen is a 20- per cent reduction at home,” she said.

Comeau also rejected the underlying logic that poverty alleviation and enhanced quality of life are dependent on the production of more greenhouse gasses. “Everyone has the right to a good quality of life,” she said. “But there’s no reason why our new heating, lighting, cooling, and transportation needs can’t be met by alternative sources.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Global Warming Best Fought with Pollution Credits, Report Says

Stephen Dale

OTTAWA, Jul 4 1996 (IPS) - Controlling global warming would be cheaper and more effective if companies from industrialised countries were given credit at home for their anti-pollution efforts in the developing world, according to Canadian and Indian researchers.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags