Sunday, November 22, 2026
Andrew Nette
- The murder this month of six members of a Vietnamese mafia in Berlin, has put added strain on ties between Bonn and Hanoi, the two also not seeing eye to eye on the repatriation of Vietnamese living illegally in Germany.
The victims, were found shot to death in a seedy apartment building in East Berlin’s Marzahn district and among the latest casualties of a brutal gang war which police claim is being waged for control of the city’s illegal cigarette trade.
The violence has brought to a head, criticisms that Hanoi is delaying implementing an agreement signed last year to take back more than 40,000 illegal Vietnamese immigrants from Germany.
Hundreds of thousands of Vietnamese were sent to Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union as guest workers during the communist era.
Approximately 60,000 went to the former German Democratic Republic alone.
When the state owned factories in which they worked closed after the fall of the Berlin Wall in November 1989, many stayed on, and have since been joined by thousands more who have come as illegal immigrants and asylum seekers.
In the post-Cold War period, elements of this community have turned their attention to criminal activities, say international law enforcement authorities.
In particular, there is a massive trade into Germany of smuggled cigarettes from Poland and Hungary where top brands such as Marlboro are produced under licence.
An estimated ten billion cigarettes were brought to Berlin illegally last year, depriving the authorities of hundreds of millions if not billions of dollars in tax revenue.
Clashes between rival gangs involved in the trade have resulted in the deaths of dozens of Vietnamese since Germany was reunified, according to police reports.
Last March, five Vietnamese were killed by suspected members of the cigarette mafia in a hostel for foreigners in East Berlin, and by some accounts as many as 35 have died so far this year.
Vietnamese gangs are also reported to be branching out into extortion, prostitution, gambling and possibly narcotics, establishing legitimate businesses with the proceeds.
“Most Vietnamese in these countries respect the law,” says Vu Xuan Ninh, deputy director of the Eastern Europe and Middle Asia Department at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Hanoi. “There are a few who do not, and in these cases it is up to the country in which they are staying to deal with them.”
A senior diplomat in the German embassy in Hanoi agrees that the “criminal element is a very small minority of the Vietnamese community, perhaps as few as a couple of hundred”. But, he adds: “They are very violent and very visible.”
Under pressure from Bonn, Hanoi signed an agreement last July to assist in the repatriation of 2,500 Vietnamese living illegally in Germany by the end of 1995 and 40,000 by the year 2000, in exchange for 140,000 million dollars in financial assistance to help reintegrate them back into the community.
Vietnam has accepted only 65 so far — all of them criminals.
In April, five Vietnamese expelled by Bonn with Hanoi’s consent were barred entry upon arrival on the grounds that they had no re- entry papers.
Bonn says that no Vietnamese citizen with a clean record has been able to return, despite official statistics showing that 8,100 Vietnamese have registered with the government to go home.
“The failure to respect the spirit of the contract does not augur well for German-Vietnamese relations,” German junior interior minister Kurt Schelter was quoted as saying recently.
Although Bonn has so far refused to comment on if it might consider suspending aid to Vietnam over the dispute, Foreign Minister Klaus Kinkel told the German media last week that government was mulling appropriate action should Hanoi continue to delay taking back citizens living illegally in Germany.
Vietnam’s foreign ministry has responded by saying that while it remains committed to the agreement, the numbers repatriated so far had “fallen short of expectations because of some difficulties attributable to both the German and Vietnamese side”.
At the same time Hanoi said it would be “anachronistic” should Bonn try to force the pace of the agreement by withholding aid, instead of trying to bring gang warfare under wraps.
Meanwhile, governments in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union fear they will experience an upsurge of illegal Vietnamese immigration as Bonn cracks down.
“If Germany gets tougher on their Vietnamese we can expect many more people to escape to Poland and other countries, rather than go back home,” claims Miroslaw Gajewski, first secretary of the Polish embassy in Hanoi.
Hungary is concerned at possible links between Chinese mafia groups and sections of its 7,000 strong Vietnamese population, more than 3,000 of which are suspected to be illegal.
The Czech and Slovak Republics (formerly Czechoslovakia) — the only ex-East Bloc nations to continue taking guest workers — has emerged as a likely transit route for smuggled merchandise to Russia.
“There is the possibility of illegal Vietnamese coming from Germany,” says Josef Pis, a counselor for Bratislava in Hanoi. “So far we do not have any evidence of mafia activities, but that doesn’t mean it’s not happening.
Vietnamese criminal operations are a growing problem in the former Soviet Union, home to between 100,000 and 150,000 Vietnamese — many of them without proper papers.
Eastern European diplomats say that porous borders and lack of resources limit what their countries can do to contain the influx. Criminal gangs are also difficult to infiltrate and crack due to the secretive nature of the overseas Vietnamese communities.
“The networks are extremely tight-knit and getting information out of them is extremely difficult for outside agencies,” the German diplomat in Hanoi explained to IPS.
Meanwhile, Ninh stresses the Vietnamese authorities are cooperating with INTERPOL to tackle the problem.
In early 1995, the Vietnamese Press reported that Hanoi had dispatched a special police unit to Moscow to assist their Russian counterparts in combating gang-related activities.
And in February, Germany and Vietnam signed a protocol to coordinate efforts against organised crime. But this month’s deaths in Berlin and the subsequent finger-pointing suggests the criminal network is proving difficult to crack.