Saturday, November 21, 2026
Stephen Dale
- Canadian Prime Minister Jean Chretien has added his voice to the growing chorus of discontent over the negative social impact of economic globalisation.
Speaking at a recent Vancouver meeting of former world leaders, Chretien remarked that pressures from the global market have left created a feeling among Canadians of “not being able to control our economic destiny.”
The Prime Minister, however, attempted to put a positive spin on the situation, saying, “Globalisation is imposing a healthy discipline that will result in healthier economies in the long run.” He also insisted that Canada will be able to adapt.
“We cannot stop globalisation, we need to adjust to it,” he said.
Despite the surface optimism, Chretien acknowledges the growing perception that his government’s economic policy – particularly cuts to social spending – are being driven by external forces.
Some analysts, meanwhile, believe that social spending cuts are radically changing the character of Canada. It is moving away from “the just society” envisioned by former Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau in the 1970s, to a more polarised, less generous social climate similar to that in the United States, Canada’s largest trading partner.
“We seem to be headed in that direction, especially with the most recent cuts to social spending,” says Andrew Sharpe, director of the Centre for the Study of Living Standards, an independent economic think-tank in Ottawa.
“But I don’t think Canada will go as far as the U.S.,” Sharpe says. “We have fundamentally different values in this country, so I don’t think its inevitable that we have to follow the U.S. model. Very few people want to trade away our health system and our society safety net for the ones that exist in the United States.”
In an attempt to calm the fears of international bond rating agencies, the Chretien government has cut its budget deficit by slashing funding for the unemployment insurance programme. This reduction will be followed by a one-third cut in transfer payments to the provinces for health, welfare, and social programmes.
In fact, public policy at the provincial level already looks more like the U.S. version.
The new Conservative government in Ontario — the nation’s industrial heartland — has introduced a sweeping economic package modelled on blueprints from the U.S. states of New Jersey and Michigan, which lowered taxes on the wealthy, cut welfare and education spending and gutted environmental and consumer protection programmes.
Toronto Star columnist Dalton Camp, a former Conservative strategist, warns that cutting government support for the poor will lead to U.S.-style crime and other social problems.
By chopping services to pay for the upper-income tax cut announced in early May, the Ontario government is “weakening, if not destroying the peaceful and orderly society it has built over the years and which has made Ontario the role model for all provinces,” he says.
The Ontario government officials argue that their economic package is needed to make the province competitive in the global competition for investment. Their allies in the business community say higher taxes on upper income earners drove executives and other well-paid professionals to the United States, and the tax break will lure them back.
Other community leaders believe Canada need not succumb to the pressure of global competition.
Andrew Jackson, senior economist with the Canadian Labour Congress, Canada’s largest federation of trade unions, contends that Canada already is competitive in world markets and does not need to push down wages and labour standards.
The country’s competitive edge, he says, is largely a result of its devalued dollar and recent technological investments. He added that labour costs are no longer an impediment because most labour- intensive industries in Canada have already died under the North American Free Trade Agreement.
“There’s a segment of the corporate community which advocates taking the low road of lower wages and longer hours of work, to close the gap with ‘right-to-work’ states in the U.S. So these measures are being sold with this message,” says Jackson.
“But most people realize that this is not the basis for making Canada competitive with its trade partners,” he continues. “If we want to compete with Mexico on the basis of having lower wages, we’re never going to win that contest.”
With the percentage of the Canadian gross domestic product linked to export production rising to 37 percent last year — up from 24 percent in 1991 — critics believe the country is increasingly vulnerable to the whims of the international market.
“That’s an undesirable direction to move in. It’s a much more unbalanced economy, less amenable to political regulation,” Jackson warns.
The dependence on exports may also make Canada more vulnerable to U.S. trade retaliation. In one celebrated case concluded in April, Canada agreed to place a tax on softwood exports to the United States, not because Canada was found to have violated the NAFTA pact, but in response to continual U.S. threats to impose tariffs on Canadian products.