Africa, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

U.S.-WOMEN: Togo Woman’s Asylum Case Will Set Precedent

Cindy Yoon

NEW YORK, May 3 1996 (IPS) - As the fate of 19-year-old Fauziya Kasinga of Togo hangs in the balance, so too does the future of many others who will seek asylum based on fears of female genital mutilation.

The U.S. Board of Immigration Appeals is to issue a ruling this summer on Kasinga’s request for asylum based on her argument that she would face the “deadly practice” of female genital mutilation (FGM) if she were to return home.

“The tragic truth is that most of the world’s refugees — 96 percent — languish in often hideous and life-threatening conditions,” says Deborah Anker, head of Women’s Refugee Project of Harvard Law School’s Immigration and Refugee Clinic.

“Eighty percent of these refugees are women and children, and they are regularly subject to rape, other violence, malnutrition, and even starvation,” she adds.

The Board of Immigration Appeals heard the case Thursday at an area just outside Washington. Its decision will be binding on immigration judges around the United States.

Victims of female genital mutilation and gender-based discrimination are not guaranteed asylum under U.S. law. A refugee seeking asylum must prove persecution based on race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group.

“It is not at all an out-on-a-limb legal argument that when we talk about persecution because of membership of a social group, that group can be defined by characteristics that include gender,” said Kasinga’s lawyer, Karen Musalo of American University’s International Human Rights Clinic.

Kasinga fled Togo at the age of 17 when her family ordered her to marry and undergo circumcision. However, when she arrived at Newark International Airport in New Jersey Dec. 17, 1994 seeking sanctuary, she was carrying forged papers and immigration officials immediately placed in detention.

Last year, Judge Donald V. Ferlise denied Kasinga’s application for asylum, concluding that her record did not reveal any past or present persecution. As a result, she was not characterised as being persecuted for membership in a particular social group which would have made her eligible for asylum.

“The social group that contains our client is that of women from her particular tribe where FGM is really pervasive,” Kasinga’s lawyer explains. “We know that they suffer this because of their membership in the group defined by gender and ethnicity. That is not a big stretch in terms of the law.”

On May 26, 1995, after 36 organisations pushed for gender-based guidelines for asylum cases, the head of the U.S. Immigration and Naturalisation Service (INS) wrote a memo suggesting ways in which special gender cases, including rape, domestic violence, and female genital mutilation could be handled.

The guidelines were designed to assist asylum officers in interviewing women refugees and in making asylum decisions based on international human rights and refugee law principles.

Last year, the U.S. Board of Immigration Appeals issued a finding that the gang-rape of a Haitian woman by military attaches because of her pro-democracy activity was a “grievous harm” that amounted to persecution.

Many hope that Kasinga’s case will get a similar ruling.

An estimated 85-115 million girls and women throughout the world have undergone female circumcision, according to a report published by the Netherlands Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

The procedure could involve the partial or total removal of the clitoris (clitoridectomy), or the removal of the entire clitoris and the cutting of the labia minora (excision), or the removal of all external genitals and the stitching together of the two sides of the vulva (infibulation).

In addition to about 20 countries in Africa, female circumcision is practiced in several nations around the Red Sea, along the Indian Ocean and the eastern Mediterranean area, among Muslim communities in Indonesia and Malaysia, among the Bohra Muslims in India and Pakistan, and among certain groups in Australia.

Three years ago Canada set up binding qualifications for women seeking asylum, but the United States has left decisions to the discretion of individual immigration judges. As a result, recent decisions on female genital mutilation have been contradictory.

On March 23, 1994, Judge Kendall Warren in Portland, Oregon ordered the suspension of a pending deportation order against a Nigerian woman, Lydia Oluloro, on the grounds that her two daughters would be at risk of female genital mutilation.

But on April 28, 1995, Judge John F. Gossart in Baltimore, Maryland denied asylum for a woman from Sierra Leone saying that the operation is “an important ritual” which “binds the tribe.”

“We are using the case of Fauziya Kasinga as an example of where (asylum law) has gone awry, because clearly, when you are issuing gender guidelines to asylum offices and they are not binding it doesn’t make sense,” says Surita Sandosham, executive director of Equality Now.

Many fear that guaranteed asylum for cases like Kasinga’s may create a floodgate of new immigrants. However, since the change in Canadian law, only two women have been granted asylum for female genital mutilation.

“Women are not jumping up and down to make these claims,” says Stephanie Marx, of the Lawyers Committee for Human Rights.

“I run probably one of the largest pro-bono asylum programmes in the country,” Marx said. “Forty percent of our clients are from Africa, and we have only one case involving this issue. This is not something where we can expect any kind of flood of applicants, and anyone in the government who is concerned about that has very misplaced concerns.”

Anker says that Kasinga’s case sends a message that the legitimate claims of women for refugee protection should not be ignored or trivialised.

“There are so few refugees relative to the world that ever get to this country, and such a small proportion of them are women,” said Anker. “Women are the poorest and most immobilised because of their responsibility to children and the elderly” and should have the same chance as men to obtain protection.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags