Friday, November 20, 2026
Marcela Valente
- Argentina’s President Carlos Menem shares a common dream with Chilean President Eduardo Frei — achieving in their two countries the Asian success in economic development with high rates of growth, investment and domestic savings.
With a seven percent growth rate and savings equivalent to 27 percent of gross domestic product (GDP), Chile is closer to making the dream a reality than Argentina, where the model left the country vulnerable to Mexico’s financial crisis of December 1994.
These dreams of Pacific prosperity, however, are far removed from the nightmare of African-style poverty confronting large numbers of people in Argentina and Chile. Many people are now slipping from being poor to being absolutely destitute.
A recent survey shows that 33 percent of the families in the northeast La Puna region of Argentina bordering Chile reported a child dying before the age of one. The regional infant mortality is triple the national rate and is similar to those of Ghana and the Sudan!
In La Puna, 75 out of every 1,000 children die before they are 12 months old, 64 percent of the survivors are malnourished, and 67 percent leave or never attend school, according to a survey conducted by a group of local teachers, priests and social workers.
Meanwhile, the latest Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC) released in Costa Rica notes that among the group of countries that successfully overcame the crisis of the 1980’s and restored sustained growth in recent years, only Colombia and Uruguay have succeeded in reducing inequality.
The report pointed out that Chile – which multilateral lending organizations hail as a paragon of Latin American development – “emerged from the crisis (of the 1980’s) with a similar or worse level of inequality and was only able to reduce it marginally during the recent growth period.” And former Chilean economy minister Carlos Aminami recently acknowledged in Buenos Aires that his country had succeeded in reducing the number of poor Chileans from five to four million in recent years but that the social structure “continues to be very unequal.”
“Chile has Asian rates of growth but its income distribution is more like Africa’s,” said Aminami, who served in the cabinet of former President Patricio Aylwin.
Hernando Kliksberg, the Argentine coordinator of the Institute of Social Development of the Inter-American Bank of Development, confirmed this assessment, adding that Latin America is the region with the “greatest social inequality.”
Kliksberg notes that the benefits of economic growth regionally are not shared equally among all sectors of society and that there is no automatic relationship between high rates of growth and social development.
He said statistics showed, there are at least 270 million Latin Americans at the poverty level, 60 million more than in 1980. Additionally, poor people were poorer and now include former members of the middle class that have slipped down the social ladder.
In Argentina, it appeared that poverty had stopped its spread until the Mexican crisis of 1994. Still, the number of families that weren’t able to cover their basic needs grew 24 percent between 1994 and 1995 (from 14.2 to 17.6 percent).
official data, gathered by the Secretariat of Social Development, also indicated that the number of indigent families increased 30 percent, from 3.4 to 4.4 percent. And there is yet another reality that has escaped national statistics; namely the unequal distribution of wealth throughout the country.
The level of poverty, of unemployment, of infant mortality and of illiteracy is twice as high in some Argentine provinces as in the nation overall, owing to the unequal division of wealth.
The increase in poverty in the last two years is mainly the result of unemployment which reached 18.6 percent in May 1995 and fell barely two points in October, according to the Subsecretary of Economic Planning.
The unemployment rate, expected to decrease, unstead saw an upturn instead as a result of the recession that followed the Mexican crisis. Argentina’s unemployment grew at a rate of seven percent annually until 1995, the year in which the economy shrank 5.5 percent.
The Roman Catholic Church in Argentina, meanwhile, has become the outspoken voice for the poor and unemployed victims of the Argentine economic model, to the point of engaging in public confrontations with President Menem and Economy Minister Domingo Cavallo.
“I don’t know how the government can say that unemployment has fallen because we see more factories closing every day and more and more unemployed,” protested bishop Rafael Rey. The bishop is president of Caritas Argentina, a charity that assists 700,000 needy people in 62 cities in the country.
Analysts have noted that Argentina, traumatized by the hyperinflation of the late 1980’s, appears to have given greater priority to economic stability than to improving the unequal distribution of wealth and undertaking other social reforms.
Menem was re-elected to office by 50 percent of the electorate in 1995 and there have been reports of amending the electoral law to allow him to run for a third term. Analyst Rosendo Fraga cites some relevant numbers to explain this sustained popular support for Menem’s stabilization and market-oriented policies.
“Under hyperinflation, a worker needed 10 monthly salaries to buy a television set and had to pay cash. Now she only needs one salary and can pay in installments if she likes,” Fraga remarked.
But the problem today, he acknowledged, is that there are now many more unemployed workers without any means of buying that television set than there were during the unpopular period of hyperinflation.