Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

ASIA-HABITAT: New Weapons Needed to Reverse Urban Decay

Johanna Son

MANILA, Apr 23 1996 (IPS) - For many governments, running Asia’s congested cities has become a daily battle against urban ills that range from clogged roads, poor water supply and sewerage, to huge shortages of decent housing.

On top of all that, regional governments are having to dig deep into their treasuries to finance this bottleneck in infrastructure and services.

Some three trillion dollars will be needed to finance much- needed infrastructure in Asia over the next decade, and there is a shortfall of 20 billion dollars, the Asian Development Bank (AsDB) says.

Other estimates put at 6.9 trillion dollars the amount Asia needs for the next 25 years, a figure beyond the capacity even of fast-growing cities to generate.

“The paradox we have is that enormous wealth generated through urbanisation is not being utilised properly to finance urban infrastructure development and service delivery in order to further promote economic development and to improve the quality of life of urban dwellers,” said Kim Kyung Hwan, urban finance advisor of the U.N. Commission on Human Settlements (UNCHS).

At an AsDB conference on urban finance in Manila last week, Kim said Asian cities must seek “innovative financing mechanisms” and other novel ways to ensure sustainable growth.

Royston A.C. Brockman of EDU International, a consultancy on urban issues, says central governments have failed to anticipate and plan for massive urbanisation in Asia over the last decade.

Thus, he said: “Urbanisation has brought prosperity for many millions, but still more live in conditions which are similar to those of the Middle Ages instead of approaching the 21st century.”

Now, AsDB President Mitsuo Sato says past experience and projected future needs show “the public sector alone cannot meet all the requirements” of a region that will become mostly urban by 2020.

Asia, which has the world’s largest urban population, will be home to 17 of the world’s 27 megacities by 2015. Asian urbanites numbered 1.1 billion in 1995, but the figure is expected to increase to almost 2.5 billion by 2020.

Indeed, governments are no longer the only key actors in the life of Asia’s cities and cannot cure all urban woes. In short, experts say, the authorities do not have all the answers.

Urban experts at last week’s AsDB meeting suggested a mix of new approaches to city management, including decentralisation, financial reform, improved implementation of urban plans, privatisation, recognition of the roles played by communities and an overhaul of traditional government views.

Many Asian governments are unable to provide basic services such as water supply, waste disposal and decent shelter especially in informal settlements.

Also, they are hard-pressed looking for resources to fund such services, often relying on taxation that urban dwellers shy away from because of the poor services they get in return.

Decentralisation and devolution of power, planning and resources to local governments has gained momentum in recent decades.

The World Bank says that of 75 countries with developing and transitional economies and populations of more than five million, 63 had transferred additional powers to local governments.

While the decentralisation process is incomplete, Brockman says Asia has its own good examples. The Philippines has traditionally been highly centralised, but in 1991 passed a decentralisation law that is a hallmark in the developing world.

Asian cities like Seoul and Karachi are nearly self-financing while cities and municipalities in Indonesia rely heavily on transfers from national governments.

Privatisation of urban infrastructure and services is also rising. In India and the Philippines, the entry of the private sector in power generation has “almost overnight eliminated power cuts”, Brockman pointed out.

Experts say the private sector tends to be keen on ‘hard’ infrastructure projects like transport, power generation, water supply and telecommunications. But there is growing interest in social sectors such as waste collection, which is being privatised nationwide in Malaysia.

Non-government groups are active in education and health care facilities in Bangladesh, and informal communities in India and Pakistan are building their own sewage systems and houses.

But Brockman says there are limits to privatisation, which can make things worse if it allows a monopolistic set-up to thrive.

Urban experts suggest looking at ways to raise funds apart from foreign aid and taxation, which is often politically unpalatable and collected inefficiently. “You can’t increase water charges if the quality is bad or if there is no water,” argued Brockman.

More cities are turning to other ways of raising funds, including auto and advertising taxes. Others, like South Korean local governments, are trying bond financing. Commercial banks are starting to extend five to seven year loans to local authorities.

“Devolution of governance and increased private sector participation, are expected to dominate urban financing over the next few decades,” Sato said.

Added Brockman: “There is a need to increase access to finance from the private sector and reduce dependency on government.”

Central governments and aid agencies used to be main sources of funding, but “this is not changing with privatisation and beneficiary participation”, Brockman said.

As UNCHS’ Kim explained, public funds are becoming scarce as governments downsize due to fiscal pressures. Foreign aid is also falling in real terms, with donor countries giving aid reaching only 0.29 per cent of Gross National Product (GNP) instead of the U.N.’s 0.7 per cent target.

Private money has outstripped aid. East Asia alone got 59 per cent of total private funds in 1995, which means it is in a prime position to use private money to finance future needs for infrastructure and services.

To boost their credibility, local governments must clean up their records in management and regulation.

And because Asian cities’ needs are burgeoning, governments must realise they cannot provide all infrastructure and services and that they are better off “governing rather than operating”, as Brockman put it.

In effect, this means a return by governments to “the function they were originally tasked to do — that is to govern”, Brockman said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags