Saturday, November 21, 2026
John Roberts and Shada Islam
- Two very different tracks towards a end to the ‘cycle of violence’ in Lebanon and Israel, divided nations Wednesday, as political leaders from the involved states exchanged sometimes quick-tempered views on ways to end the current conflict.
In Cairo Lebanese foreign minister Fares Bweiz said Beirut could accept a U.S. proposal for a ceasefire between Israel and Hizbollah guerrillas after “modifications” but preferred the alternative French initiative.
In London Lebanese Prime Minister Rafiq Hariri tested British premier John Major’s view of the two options, but he showed little sign of sharing the Lebanese premier’s support for the plan tabled Wednesday by French Foreign Minister Herve de Charette.
“There are elements more appealing in the French proposal,” Hariri said, making it clear that Beirut preferred the French proposals to the six point plan unveiled by Washington on Tuesday evening.
In particular, he asserted that details of the U.S. plan conveyed to his Government did not provide for a withdrawal of Israeli forces from Southern Lebanon. “They don’t talk of withdrawal from our country,” Hariri said after meeting Major.
Israel’s Operation Grapes of Wrath, launched last Thursday ostensibly to halt Hizbollah attacks on northern Israel, has killed at least 38 people and injured some 170, mostly civilians, and driven some 400,000 Lebanese to flee their homes.
According to the U.S. State Department, the core of the plan drawn up by U.S. Secretary of State Warren Christopher is for guerrillas of the Hizbollah resistance in South Lebanon to stop their attacks on Israeli towns in Northern Israel and Israeli soldiers in Lebanon.
In return Israel would issue a declaration that it has no territorial demands in Lebanon and that it is willing to discuss withdrawal of its forces if the Lebanese army can first provide security in South Lebanon for nine months.
The seven-point U.S. plan looks to Syria not only to guarantee the agreement, but also to take a lead in its implementation. The U.S. believes that Syria, which has 35,000 troops in Lebanon, possesses the power to bring Hizbollah to heel.
Israel Wednesday insisted that Syria provide written guarantees that its forces will work to halt Hizbollah’s military actions.
The U.S. plan reiterates Israeli demands for the disarming of Hizbollah — and the right to resume attacks on Hizbollah in the event of Hizbollah attacks on Israelis. It also calls for Lebanon to guarantee the security of Israeli settlements and for Syria to guarantee the agreement as a whole.
In Cairo for an emergency meeting of the Arab League on the conflict, Bweiz told reporters that Beirut’s approval of the U.S. plan “still depends on essential modifications which must be made.” But the French plan, he added, “is beginning to firm up and contains reasonable and acceptable points”.
De Charette’s proposals “do not try to create a mechanism contrary to international resolutions, especially U.N. resolution 425, calling for an unconditional withdrawal of Israeli forces from Lebanon,” he told reporters.
Both Hariri and de Charette clearly feel a loose Israeli commitment to discussing withdrawal is not enough to end what Lebanon, France and Britain all term a “cycle of violence.
For the last ten years, the cycle has taken the form of Hizbollah attacks on Israel, usually directed at Israeli troops in Lebanon, but sometimes on such towns as Kiryat Shomoneh in Northern Israel — and Israeli attacks on both Hizbollah and the Lebanese people as a whole.
Hizbollah says it is fighting to end Israel’s occupation of parts of Southern Lebanon; Israel says it does not occupy Southern Lebanon, and has no designs on seizing any part of Lebanon, but that in order to safeguard its security its troops routinely patrol a substantial ‘Israeli Security Zone’ along the length of the border and extending in places twenty miles into Lebanon.
Hizbollah’s role in Lebanese affairs has become a major issue in the campaign. Israel views Hizbollah as a surrogate for Iran. The Lebanese government and many Lebanese think otherwise. A senior Israeli Foreign Ministry official said today that Hizbollah was “under orders from Iran, not just to kill innocent people, but to kill the peace process.”
Yet following the last massive series of Israeli raids on Lebanon in 1993, Hizbollah and the Israeli military concluded an informal agreement under which Hizbollah would not attack Northern Israel so long as Israeli forces did not kill Lebanese civilians.
This agreement effectively confined their war to combat between militia and military units in the security zone. There was no escalation in the conflict when Iran was most bitterly condemning the Israeli-Palestinian peace accords last year.
As for the latest flare-up, its origins seem internal. Hizbollah considers it was triggered when a Lebanese boy in the village of Braachit was killed in a bomb blast which Hizbollah considers was detonated by Israel. Isreal denies involvement and says the cause was Hezbollah’s subsequent Katyusha rocket attack on the northern Israeli settlement of Kiryat Shomoneh.
The European Union is not involved directly; its energies were focused Wednesday on a meeting of the ‘Euro-Med’ Mediterranean littoral countries, called to review progress since the first Euro- Med summit in Barcelona last November towards the creation of a free trade area covering the Mediterranean basin.
Israel, Syria and Lebanon attended the talks. “The situation in the Middle East is certainly not helpful,” said an EU spokesman, “but we have been able to safeguard the principles of the Barcelona meeting. This proves that Euro-Med relations are distinct from the Middle East peace process.”
“It’s a happy event that while 6,000 miles away they are fighting, Israel, Syria and Lebanon are able to sit at the same table in Brussels in a business-like manner and to talk about the future,” an EU expert on the Middle East said. “It shows that two different types of thinking are going on in the region.”
In making its own proposal in Lebanon, France has focussed attention on the key demand of the Lebanese Government for the last eighteen years: an unequivocal Israeli commitment permanently to withdraw all its forces from Lebanon.
French premier Alain Juppe has described the Israeli bombing of civilian targets, including two electrical power stations in Beirut, as “inadmissable”.
Isreal does not welcome the French initiative. On Wednesday de Charette held what a Paris official called “difficult” talks with his Israeli counterpart Ehud Barak, prior to moving on to Egypt. De Charette intends to hold a string of talks with Lebanese, Syrian and Israeli officials during which he is expected to put more flesh on the French proposals.
France backed up its support for Beirut by flying in a team of engineers on a military transport airport to repair two power stations bombed by Israel, causing, as Hariri said, Beirut “almost to be plunged into darkness.”
In contrast, Britain was widely seen as supporting the Israeli assault in the wake of a strong statement by Defence Secretary Michael Portillo during a visit to Israel last weekend.
Today Major placed a little distance between himself and Portillo when he acknowledged that the scale of the Israeli assaults, which have so far led to the creation of 400,000 refugees , was “disturbing”.
But Hariri noted that Britain had backed U.N. Security Council Resolution 425 on withdrawal of Israeli forces from Lebanon, but which has not been implemented since it was passed in 1978.