Africa, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

RWANDA-HUMAN RIGHTS: Jails Full At Home, Empty Abroad

Commentary Konrad Huber (*)

LONDON, Apr 9 1996 (IPS) - In February 1996, Justice Richard Goldstone, chief prosecutor for the international tribunals for both Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia, handed down indictments against two alleged mass killers held in Zambia.

An indictment against Alfred Musema, a former tea factory director held in custody in Switzerland and allegedly involved in a massacre in the Rwandan town of Kibuye, is expected soon.

The U.S.-based NGO Physicians for Human Rights has conducted forensic examinations of more than 500 corpses found near a church in Kibuye. More than half were children. It found evidence that refuting claims that they were accidental victims of conflict.

Another five cases are being prepared, also based on well-known events and likely-to-be-apprehended perpetrators. Yet despite this activity, much uncertainty surrounds the Tribunal’s long-term ability to go after the ‘big fish’, as it characterises its main task.

Though not exactly prime targets for the prosecution, the two likely to be the first Rwandans tried by the court, are now in Zambian custody on charges of ‘immigration irregularities’ and are expected to be ‘deferred’ to the tribunal in April.

They are Georges Rutaganda, second vice-president of the National Committee of the Hutu extremist Interahamwe and Jean-Paul Akayesu, former mayor of Taba in Gitarama district. Akayesu is accused of inciting and ordering murder; Rutaganda is principally accused of participating in massacres of Tutsi in Kigali and Nyanza.

Under Article 28 of the tribunal’s mandate countries holding or harbouring suspects must arrest and transfer them to Tribunal custody in Arusha, Tanzania, seat of the court in Africa.

National agendas still predominate, as seen in the case of Colonel Theoneste Bagasora, by far the most senior alleged war criminal, recently arrested in Cameroon. Rwanda, the Tribunal and Belgium — he is believed to have ordered the murder of ten Belgian U.N. peacekeepers — are all trying to extradite him.

The tribunal is also waiting for Belgium to finalise legislation allowing three more detainees, including one former minister and two former mayors accused of genocide, to be transferred for trial.

But aside from these trials and those to be held in connection with the Kibuye indictments, the tribunal’s current prospects appear somewhat bleak. Also Goldstone, regarded as a key driving force for both the Rwandan and ex-Yugoslav courts, leaves in October 1996.

The Rwandan tribunal has yet to have its budget approved for this year, and the imminent withdrawal of the U.N. Assistance Mission in Rwanda, upon which the deputy prosecutor’s office in Kigali relies for security and logistical support, could compromise investigators’ ability to carry out independent fieldwork.

This at a time when the work is building up. While the Tribunal for Rwanda has too few suspects in its custody, the Rwandan justice system has too many. Its prisons are holding roughly ten times as many inmates as they were intended to, and detention of suspected killers continues at a rate of 400-1,200 per month.

Most of the alleged killers who remain in Rwanda, though regarded as ‘small fish’ in comparison to those who fled, are in custody, either in prisons or, increasingly, in local detention centres.

In its November 1995 report, the United Nations Human Rights Field Operation in Rwanda (HRFOR) highlighted maltreatment of prisoners, in some cases resulting in deaths. Amnesty International’s February 1996 report described jails as “grossly overcrowded”. International monitors have nonetheless recognised efforts by Rwandan authorities to improve arrest procedures and ameliorate prison conditions.

The Rwandan government seems increasingly prepared to start at least some trials. On Feb. 17, Prime Minister Pierre-Celestin Rwigema announced the establishment of specialised chambers for genocide cases within the existing criminal justice system.

Rather than establishing new judicial institutions, the special chambers will use available judicial personnel and infrastructure in each of Rwanda’s 10 districts.

Rwanda’s current chief Supreme Court prosecutor, Simeon Rwagasore, has been selected to put together a strategy for prosecuting the so-called ‘genocidaires’. Investigations will continue, primarily at the district and town levels, and a three- person panel of judges will sit in each district for the trials.

These judges will be drawn from approximately 250 non-jurist magistrates who have received special four-month training.

The principle of plea-bargaining was also proposed, a potentially controversial innovation, as well as the participation of non- professional ‘assesseurs’, or local representatives, in hearing the cases.

Sentencing guidelines will be put forth, based on levels of complicity ranging from the genocide’s key perpetrators to more ‘menial’ participants. To formalise these arrangements, the Ministry of Justice is preparing a draft law for approval by the Council of Ministers and for passage by the National Assembly.

Though the first trials are officially hoped to coincide with the genocide’s second anniversary in April, the necessary preparations will probably take at least six months.

According to the U.N. Human Rights Field Operation, approximately 30 district prosecutors are now in place throughout the country after attending a specialised two-month training course. Only four were left by November 1994.

In addition, 320 inspecteurs de police judiciaire (IPJs) have also undergone intensive, three-month instruction and are now being deployed under the supervision of the prosecutors, to compile dossiers on the detained genocide suspects, numbering in the hundreds in many towns.

One notable development has been the creation of so-called commissions de triage (screening committees) to review the detention of suspected genocidaires for sufficient evidence.

First set up in Kigali in November 1994 to relieve overcrowding in the capital’s jails, they have since been established throughout the country. But they have released less than 100 detainees during 1995, according to the U.N. Human Rights Field Operation.

This bring the efficacy of the commissions into doubt, especially since Rwanda’s current political climate supports the imprisoning of the genocidaires, even at the risk of detaining innocent people. In fact, accusing a rival of participation in genocide, even falsely, has become a means for settling old scores or to obtain homes or other property vacated during the 1994 violence.

Since the latter part of 1995, there have been improvements in arrest procedures — including more frequent prosecutorial reviews of dossiers prior to detention, greater use of warrants, and proper arresting procedure. Changes are also slated for the commissions de triage, including the establishment of more town- level commissions.

Fundamentally, however, Rwanda’s government has extremely limited resources to handle an overwhelming number of highly sensitive criminal cases.

Genocide survivors and relatives of the victims, many in positions of power, are likely to reject any outcome that appears lenient.

The families of the accused and those suspected of genocide could become further alienated from the current regime, thus accentuating Rwanda’s Hutu-Tutsi divide. The judgement must come fairly, and soon.

(*) Konrad Huber, formerly with the OSCE High Commission on National Minorities, is a field officer with the Human Rights Field Operation in Rwanda (HRFOR). This item comes to IPS via the Institute of War and Peace Reporting (IWPR), publishers of WarReport and Tribunal magazines.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags