Economy & Trade, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Labour

LABOUR: ‘Core Labour Standards’ In Trade With South Backed By G-7

Angeline Oyog

PARIS, Apr 2 1996 (IPS) - The Group of Seven (G-7) rich nations Tuesday defied the warnings of Japan and lined themselves up for a battle with the rest of Asia by singling out the need for improving core labour standards worldwide.

Japan, backed by Britain, had warned against overstressing the need for core labour standards on issues like child and forced labour, trade union rights and discrimination.

But the final statement issued in Lille, France after a G-7 ministerial meeting on tackling unemployment, calls on trade ministers to take the issue to the World Trade Organisation at a key WTO ministerial meeting in Singapore in December.

This ignored the warnings of Japan and Britain that linking trade with labour standards would amount to disguised protectionism. Repeated calls from the United States and international labour groups for the inclusion of a so-called “social clause” in the WTO have run into fierce opposition from developing countries.

Asian trade officials say any such link would be used by protectionist forces in the West to keep out competing goods from the developing world.

The United States and France faced stiff opposition when they tried to link trade and efforts to end forced and child labour in the GATT world trade agreement signed in Marrakesh, Morocco in 1994.

“Progress has been step by step,” EU Economy Commissioner Yves- Thibault de Silguy told reporters in Lille, “but there has been progress when you think that in Marrakesh, even putting such words into a statement was difficult.”

The G-7 comprises Canada, Britain, France, Italy, Germany, Japan and the United States. Their final document concluded that G-7 ministers “noted the importance of enhancing core labour standards around the world and examining the links between international trade and working conditions in the appropriate fora.”

G-7 ministers also agreed to wait for the results of a study being made by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and the International Labour Organisation (ILO) on the social consequences of changes in world trade.

But OECD Secretary-General Jean-Claude Paye said Monday that the study, which is still unfinished, had not found any significant unfair competitive advantage arising from failure to respect minimum labour standards, at least not enough to justify sanctions.

The EU, which ran into heavy fire on this issue at a Euro-Asia summit hosted by the Association of South East Asian States in Bangkok last month, was determined to avoid charges of covert protectionism in its comments at Lille.

Social Affairs Commissioner Padraig Flynn said the EU should seek “incentives rather than sanctions” to encourage develoiping nations to respect labour standards. “We don’t want protectionism of any kind and we don’t want any imposition of western or European standards across the board,” he told the Lille meeting.

The EU has struggled to add a so-called social clause to its own core Maastricht Treaty of union, an addition which is opposed by Britain. The EU, hoping to defuse the debate, has said that it has “no agenda for depriving low-wage countries of their legitimate economic advantage.”

“In those international forums where the subject is currently under discussion, the view is gaining ground that this is not a protectionist gambit,” EU officials said in Brussels.

On the other hand, Commission trade officials argue that some practices such as preventing freedom of association and using forced labour cannot be justified in terms of level of economic development in developing nations.

The International Confederation of Free Trade Unions (ICFTU) says the WTO should link trade to five basic social standards: the freedom of association, the prohibition on the use of child labour and forced labour, the right to organise and bargain collectively and non-discrimination.

Asian trade experts insist that the subject is best handled by the ILO, the U.N. body set up to improve workers’ standards. They also argue that the best way to better working conditions is through development aid rather than trade sanctions.

European Trade Commissioner Sir Leon Brittan has denied claims that the EU is trying to impose minimum social standards on the South. “Europe has no intention of trying to enforce a social diktat on the rest of the world,” Brittan insisted.

Brittan said that instead of trying to impose Western codes of behaviour on the WTO agenda, all trading nations should agree to look into the question at the meeting in Singapore.

“We hope that through discussion and cooperation, we can play a constructive role in improving social standards in such countries,” Brittan said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags