Environment, Headlines, North America

U.S.-ENVIRONMENT: ‘Mechanised’ Tourism Irks Environment Activists

Malcolm Howard

COLORADO SPRINGS, COLORADO, Mar 27 1996 (IPS) - When politicians and naturalists created the United States Park Service in 1916, they sought to leave some of America’s most awe-inspiring natural wonders “unimpaired for future generations.”

Still, they could never have foreseen the battle now brewing over the national park system. The U.S. Park Service is now engaged in a nation-wide fight over “flight-seeing:” an increasingly popular tourism trade that allows people to view protected areas via the cockpits of helicopters and small airplanes.

Aviation buffs and tourism groups say flight-seeing is the quickest, cheapest, and most environmentally friendly way to view the grandeur of places such as the Hawaiian volcanoes, or the Grand Canyon.

But a growing chorus of opponents say the deafening whomp of helicopter rotors and the whine of small aircraft are hurting park wildlife and destroying the park experience for millions of other visitors.

“Most people don’t come to parks to hear the thumping of helicopter blades,” says Don Barger, an activists for the National Parks and Conservation Association, which is trying to limit tour flights over national parks. “So, this is definitely a case of a few people making money at the expense of the many.”

A key problem, Barger says, is that there is no national policy governing how, when, and where tour flights can roam over protected havens. After all, he notes, the park system was created only 13 years after the first powered air plane flights.

“The visionaries who created the park system never could have anticipated that someone would invent a plastic bubble with rotors on top that was extremely loud and could buzz anywhere over the park system,” Barger adds.

But Barger says this loud, mechanised tourism is out of sync with the reason these pristine areas were set aside. Now, a cadre of environmentalists, park officials and politicians are pushing for new laws to manage, curtail, or in some cases, ban overflights over national parks.

Lawmakers in Tennessee, for example, have banned heliports within nine miles of Great Smoky National Park, the United States’ most popular park. But that ban (along with similar measures enacted by nearby towns) is being challenged by flight groups who say these local laws encroach on the federal government’s power to regulate air travel.

U.S. airways are controlled by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), which is mandated to manage and promote air travel. Because most tour flights take off outside park boundaries, the Park Service has no power to regulate them.

That is why some environmental groups are pushing for a nation- wide moratorium on new flight-seeing operations until the FAA deals with the issue. Elsewhere, tougher measures are advised.

In Colorado, local, state and Park Service officials are asking the FAA to ban flying tours over Rocky Mountain National Park. If adopted, the ban would be the first in the United States for a major national park.

The FAA, meanwhile, is preparing to release the first stage in the formation of a nation-wide policy regarding tour overflights of national parks. That first stage is a series of new rules designed to better manage air tour traffic over the Grand Canyon, by far the busiest flight-seeing destination.

This rule-making process was mandated by Congress in the late 1980s, after 25 people were killed during a tour over the Canyon. The issue of safety has not gone away. In the last five years, there have been 17 crashes inside national park boundaries. The worst were in Hawaii, where 46 people were injured and 37 killed in tour flight crashes between 1991 and 1993.

Though the FAA is tight-lipped about what the new Grand Canyon regulations will include, many in the tour flight industry are already calling them redundant. They say voluntary safety and noise abatement efforts have dramatically reduced the number of accidents and noise complaints.

“We’ve already given up flying over 85-percent of the Grand Canyon through voluntary agreements,” says Elling Halverson, a long-time Grand Canyon tour operator based in Tusayan, Arizona.

But Park officials counter that since that agreement was enacted in the early 1980s, air traffic has increased dramatically. In a report released last fall, the Park Service recommends a 15-year phase-in of quieter engines and the expansion of several “flight-free zones” throughout the park.

Though Halverson argues that quiet engine technology is a solution, many in the tour industry see such regulation as overkill.

“Helicopters are in fact the least intrusive way to see the park,” says Frank Jensen, president of Helicopter Association International, based in Virginia. “They don’t litter, leave footprints, or bring in non-native seeds via boot treads.”

But numerous studies say otherwise. Noisy planes can startle wild animals and interrupt critical feeding, nesting and calving periods. Migratory birds flushed during feeding stops, for example, might not store up enough energy to survive their round trip voyages, notes Doug Gladwin, a wildlife biologist and pilot who has studied overflights for two decades.

“Overflights just add stress to already stressful environments for wildlife,” adds Gladwin, one of the authors of the Park Service report. But Gladwin says park officials and tour operators can find ways to alleviate that stress.

In Banff National Park in Canada, for example, a private tour operator hired Parks Canada to map out habitat for grizzly bear, mountain goat and mountain sheep. Then the company hired Gladwin to route helicopters around and over important wildlife habitats at critical feeding and nesting times.

In the absence of federal regulation in the United States, that voluntary approach has been the norm, though peacemaking pacts between environmentalists and tour operators have often come after considerable public outcry.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags