Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

CANADA-AID: Foreign Aid Cuts Call for Fresh Focus

Stephen Dale

OTTAWA, Mar 13 1996 (IPS) - Fresh cuts to Canada’s development assistance budget have prompted suggestions that the country’s foreign aid programme will soon have to be redesigned.

“One has to worry that when you’re getting down to an aid budget that’s only two-thirds of what it was five years ago, there has to be a re-thinking of what the foreign aid budget is for,” said Andrew Clark, senior researcher at the independent North-South Institute in Ottawa.

During his presentation of the federal budget in early March, finance minister Paul Martin announced new cuts of roughly 110 million U.S. dollars to Canada’s development assistance spending, to take effect during the fiscal year 1998-99.

Taken together with previously announced budget cuts, the new reductions mean that during the final years of this century Canada’s aid budget will be at its lowest point in 30 years, according to analysis by the Canadian Council for International Co-operation (CCIC), an umbrella group for 100 Canadian non-governmental organisations (NGOs).

The North-South’s figures show that a Canadian aid budget which stood at roughly 2.3 billion U.S. dollars in 1991-92, will have been reduced to 1.6 billion dollars by 1998-99.

“Foreign aid has been the number one whipping boy” in the government’s quest to reduce its deficit, says the North-South’s Clark.

Although recent budgets have also brought large cuts to domestic social programmes and unemployment insurance, “the cuts to the aid budget started well before cuts to other programmes, and they have been sustained,” he said. “Development assistance has taken on a disproportionate burden.”

While Canada has repeatedly restated its international commitment to increase aid to 0.7 percent of its own gross national product (GNP), the ongoing cuts are moving Canada quickly in the opposite direction. While the ratio stood at 0.49 in 1991-92, that will fall to 0.26 by 1998-99.

The figure is actually lower — 0.24 percent — when the costs of relocating refugees in Canada is removed from the aid budget, according to Clark.

“That will make us one of the least generous of the donor countries, whereas Canada has been above average in the past,” he said, but added that other nations were also reducing their aid spending.

Although finance minister Martin stated that Canada still intends to aim for the 0.7 percent figure when the country’s domestic debt situation improves, Clark said “this doesn’t ring true to me.”

“The development assistance budget would have to be increased by double-digit figures over a number of years in order to reach that target, and I don’t see that happening,” he said.

There have been no indications from the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA), the government ministry that administers official development assistance (ODA), on how the most recent cuts will be distributed.

CIDA’s media relations officer Marina Moraitis told IPS that over the next 12 months, the agency will consult on the matter with Canadians involved in development initiatives. She added that at this point, “any talk about the distribution of cuts is just speculation.”

NGOs find some consolation in the fact that, since the reductions will not actually be made for several years, distribution of the cuts can be planned, eliminating the need to wind down projects before they are completed.

Although Moraitis told IPS that “we still have the same parameters” for CIDA’s development assistance programme, outsiders believe the reduction of funds will require the agency to possibly to redesign its whole programme.

“Given that the foreign aid programme is being hobbled by these cuts, two things have to happen,” said Erika Rosenfeld, public affairs officer with the CCIC.

“The first is that the government has to play a leading role in bringing debt relief to poorer countries,” Rosenfeld said. “The second is that Canada’s aid programme must be more focused on poverty reduction.”

Regarding debt relief, the CCIC is pushing Canada to play a “significant role” in lobbying the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank to write off debts of poor countries, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, so that more significant sums can be invested in social programmes.

The continued cuts to foreign aid are helping to change the role of NGOs in several northern countries including Canada, Rosenfeld added.

“The NGO sector in Canada is in the process of transformation from programme implementation and design to an advocacy role, and the cuts we are seeing are going to accelerate this transformation,” she said.

“Southern NGOs are growing at an extraordinary rate, and increasing their capacity to raise funds and to implement programmes,” she said. “What they are telling us is that they need northern NGOs to address the macro-questions and lobby our own governments” on matters like trade practises and debt, the NGO spokesperson told IPS.

As for Canada’s bilateral aid, the North-South’s Clark says the government may have no choice but to do as Britain did and direct its development assistance towards a fewer number of recipient countries. He also predicted that Canada will attempt to cut its contributions to the multilateral development banks, once its long-term commitments elapse.

Along with the development assistance cuts, the most recent budget signals a 30 percent decrease in military spending in Canada over six years. The NGO community had been lobbying the government to cut military spending and reinvest the savings in international peace- building efforts.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags