Saturday, November 21, 2026
Barbara Borst
- Fearful that competition for international trade often overrides human rights concerns, Canadians are weighing a range of options.
Business executives and human rights activists met this week to debate a central question: Who should bear responsibility for encouraging or imposing human rights standards — businesses or international organisations?
They were reacting, in part, to Prime Minister Jean Chretien’s January trade mission to Indonesia, Pakistan, India, and Malaysia, which secured 6.5 billion U.S. dollars in new contracts. ‘Team Canada’, as the government and business members called themselves, had also visited China, Hong Kong, Indonesia and Vietnam in a previous mission.
Critics lambasted the January team for failing to address human rights abuses as it sought business for Canadian companies in Asia. In fact, Chretien was upstaged by 13-year-old Craig Kielburger, a Toronto boy who was touring the region to draw attention to child labour.
“There are over 200 million children working in child servitude around the world,” Kielburger said in New Delhi before the high-profile team had publicly addressed the issue of human rights.
Observers here say that Kielburger, who has launched a crusade against child exploitation in such industries as carpet weaving, as well as toy, glass and brick factories, has directed national attention to an issue that may have been lost in the zeal for CaNadian jobs and business.
This week’s forum — ‘Globalisation, Trade and Human Rights: The Canadian Business Perspective’ — brought business leaders and human rights activists together to wrestle with a range of options. These included simply encouraging more trade and investment, adopting voluntary codes of conduct, and a suggestion that the World Trade Organisation (WTO) should develop a so-called ‘social clause’.
Proponents of the social clause argue that the WTO could use such a mechanism to end discrimination, abolish forced labour and child exploitation, and guarantee workers’ freedom to organise and bargain collectively.
Tom Axworthy of Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Public Policy says such a clause would be “a tremendous lever” to enforce rights. He cited China’s bid for membership of the WTO, suggesting that the country’s human rights record should be considered with its application.
“China is desperate to get in,” he told the forum that was organised by the International Centre for Human Rights and Democratic Development and the Business Council on National Issues. “They want certification that they are alright. If they’re not alright, they shouldn’t get it.”
Ever since Beijing’s 1989 repression of the pro-democracy movement, human rights activists have identified China as one of the world’s worst abusers.
But WTO officials say the trade organisation is not the appropriate organ to oversee human rights.
Richard Eglin, director of the WTO’s trade and environment division, argues that the WTO is “ill-suited” to enforcing human rights standards since it was designed to promote free market policies.
Others warned that a social clause could easily be misused.
The Business Council for National Issues, whose members include some of the largest companies in Canada, is against such a measure. Its president Thomas d’Aquino cautions that protectionists in the industrialised could use a WTO social clause against developing nations. He contended that business leaders investing abroad do raise questions — “even about human rights”.
“The moral justification for doing business with non- democratic regimes is that trade and, in particular, investment are powerful catalysts for economic liberalisation, democratisation and the improvement of domestic economic conditions,” he said.
Edward Broadbent, president of the International Centre for Human Rights and Democratic Development pointed out that there was no “inevitable connection” between market economics and democracy.
“The gulf between the promise and reality of free trade is both wide and deep,” he charged, because many companies have not made human rights integral to their business strategy.
Roger Clark of Amnesty International in Canada charged that when business executives went overseas, they were “nervous about upsetting local authorities” over human rights. He, however, noted that these companies were not as shy about their own interests.