Environment, Headlines, North America

CANADA: Extreme Weather Events Fire Global Warming Debate

Stephen Dale

OTTAWA, Feb 7 1996 (IPS) - Deep snow and temperatures that freeze exposed flesh in a few seconds are facts of life at this time of year across much of Canada’s sprawling land mass.

But to many Canadians, this is no ordinary winter. Scientists and citizens alike wonder if this brutal season is part of a larger pattern of unpredictable weather, caused by global warminû)H¿HñRR¡ûRWñ,YY:ogether all the extreme weather events, then the head-scratching begins,” said Henry Hengeveld, science advisor on climate change at the Toronto office of the federal agency Environment Canada.

But Hengeveld is not completely sold on the notion that global warming is responsible for a run of spectacular weather in Canada. He argues that if scientists had centuries’ worth of data on weather conditions, they might see that the current changes are part of larger, natural process of “variability,”.

Still, Hengeveld says, it is likely that the changes are human- made, since recent abnormal conditions “are consistent with what we expect from global warming.”

Scientists agree that carbon dioxide and other gases in the atmosphere trap heat that would otherwise be radiated back to space. Computer models have predicted that the warming of the atmosphere will lead to quicker evaporation of water and in turn to more intense rain and snowfalls and to an increase in hailstorms, tornadoes and other hazards.

“It’s not that extreme weather isn’t supposed to happen,” the climate scientist told IPS. “Weather is highly variable from one year to the next, and it’s natural for extreme events to arise without warning. What’s making climatologists nervous is the clustering of extreme events, the frequency of these events. That isn’t normal.”

“Extreme” and “unpredictable” seem to be the precise words to describe the weather this past year in Canada, a country that spans several thousand miles of highly varied conditions including temperate rain-forest, Rocky Mountains, Arctic tundra, open prairie, and a cold, wet North Atlantic region.

Last summer saw a large increase in forest fires, a phenomenon Canada’s environment minister attributed to the drying effect of global warming. Now, the winter has brought severe and often confusing weather. People in many areas have had to cope with conditions associated with other parts of the country.

In the Pacific province of British Columbia, normally warm winter temperatures have been interrupted by a sudden cold snap that has covered flowers in a layer of ice and caused a rash of ruptured water-pipes.

Since homeless people from other urban areas often migrate to the province in the winter to escape from extreme cold, the British Columbia has had to construct emergency homeless shelters. In other cities like Toronto, many homeless people have frozen to death this winter in streets and in parks.

In the Atlantic province of Nova Scotia, an unusual warm spell prompted the premature hatching of tadpoles, which were then wiped out when temperatures dropped back down to minus 14 degrees Celsius. A similar thaw in Quebec caused flash floods and the destruction of homes. November’s snowfall in Ottawa was three times the normal average.

Scientists link many of these events to global warming since they are part of the “hydrological cycle”: evaporation, snow- and rainfall, and the occurrence of severe storms.

The issue that has captivated most attention, however, is the fierce cold that has gripped much of the western prairies and parts of central Canada this winter. Some cities have plunged below minus 40 degrees Celsius and stayed there for record periods. At those low temperatures, fluids in cars solidify, and skin freezes after only a few seconds of exposure.

It is on this question of temperature that scientists and environmentalists are much more reluctant to acknowledge a connection with climate change.

“You have to be really careful about this,” said Louise Comeau, global warming campaigner at the Sierra Club of Canada in Ottawa. “Climate change is about very long-term trends. It would be wrong to react to a seasonal thing.”

Comeau says that the current low temperatures are probably within the range of normal temperature fluctuations, and could be expected to occur once every few years in Canada.

Hengeveld agrees: “We haven’t had a lot of cold winters in the past 10 years and that given us a false sense of what is normal.”

Comeau told IPS that Canada’s recent history of warmer winters is likely the product of El Nino, the air current from the Pacific ocean. Although El Nino has visited Canada only once every several years, it now appears to have been blowing its balmy breezes northward every year since 1990.

Hengeveld suggests that this type of alteration in air currents are a predicted result of climate change.

The temperature difference between the earth’s poles and the equator “are the driving force that makes the winds blow,” he said. But as the poles heat up and the temperature difference decreases, the theory is that “the winds will get slower, causing meandering wind patterns. It’s possible that this will bring more extreme temperature changes to different parts of the world.”

Hengeveld cautions that scientific certainty should not be a condition for taking preventive action.

“The scientific community says we need 99 percent certainty before we know something is true,” he argued. “But the real world doesn’t work that way. The insurance industry would say, ‘if its 95 percent certain, that’s good enough. We know how much risk is too much.”

There is general agreement that countries can take a number of steps to curb emissions of carbon dioxide and other earth-warming gases, including conserving energy and halting deforestation.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags