Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Health, Population

HEALTH: Vaccines – Challenges Remain After 200 Years

Jaya Dayal

UNITED NATIONS, Jan 28 1996 (IPS) - Health officials and children’s advocates have come together to mark the 200th anniversary of one of the world’s greatest medical discoveries – the creation of vaccine to combat disease.

In the two centries since the discovery of smallpox vaccine by British doctor Edward Jenner, vaccination has controlled nine major diseases including smallpox, yellow fever, mumps and rubella.

“Because of vaccines, eight out of every ten children in the world are now protected from six deadly childhood diseases – measles, tuberculosis, tetanus, diptheria, whooping cough and polio,” said Carol Bellamy, Executive Director of the U.N. Children’s Fund (UNICEF). “This achievement saves three million young lives every year.”

Bellamy and members of Task Force for Child Survival and Development have begun a year-long campaign to promote the use and need for new and safe vaccines. The task force is sponsored by the Rockefeller Foundation and the United Nations.

“Vaccines are one of the most powerful disease-prevention tools available,” said Dr. David Satcher, Director of the Atlanta- based U.S. Centres for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

The resistance to antibiotics of micro-organism and their ability to mutate into deadlier diseases, however, are challenging efforts by researchers to repeat the 1979 success of eradicating smallpox from the face of the earth, Satcher added.

Smallpox was the first disease wiped out by vaccination. Guinea worm and polio – which still exacts a toll on millions of children – are expected to be eradicated by the end of the year. Researchers also forsee the eradication of measles.

“New vaccines are all the more urgent because antibiotic resistance is developing more rapidly,” said Dr. Stanley Plotkin, Medical and Scientific Director at Pasteur Merieux-Connaught, a major manufacturer of vaccines.

He said that “new weapons” in vaccine manufacturing, like the genetic manipulation of microbes, gene recombination and DNA reading, are helping scientists evolve more effective drugs. But repeating the smallpox success with other diseases would be difficult.

“I think eradication of measles is possible, but it’s going to take more work than smallpox,” Plotkin said. The highly infectious nature of the virus was one reason.

William Foege, Fellow for Health Policy for the Carter Presidential Centre noted that, “Although we’ve made tremendous strides in infectious disease control, future success requires using our current tools wisely, while improving our interventions based on the best science and the best social mobilisation.”

By the end of 1990, according to UNICEF, immunisation of the world’s children rose from a 20-percent to a 80-percent rate over a six-year period. But badly administered vaccines, inadequate health services and lax follow up have spurred the resurgence of

preventable diseases like polio and diptheria in some innoculated populations.

Deadly diseases like malaria, tuberculosis, pertussis — and, more recently, the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) — continue to elude the best medical and scientific efforts to prevent them.

The Task Force estimates that close to 10 million deaths occur each year as a result of bacterial and viral diseases like measles, neonatal tetanus, dengue, bacterial diarrhea, meningococcal meningitis and hepatitis A,C, and E.

It says the improvement and development of existing and new vaccines could prevent 900 million severe illnesses among children each year. A single-dose tetanus toxoid vaccine could alone prevent some 600,000 deaths per year.

The Task Force also notes that vaccines make good economic sense. For every dollar invested in vaccination, between seven to 27 dollars are saved as a result of the prevention of disability, death and medical costs associated with the disease.

While scientists and medical researchers insist on the safety of vaccines, some critics say some campaigns to promote vaccines may be endangering children’s health.

They point to “significant numbers” of adverse reactions and deaths from vaccines. For example, according to health advocate Gary Null, the CDC investigated claims in the mid-1970s of more than 2,000 serious reactions to the swine-flu vaccine, 181 of which resulted in death.

“Of these, 142 deaths occurred within 48 hours of immunisation,” Null says in an article, ‘Vaccine Victims.’

Critics also note that vaccines sometimes give rise to new diseases. In the late 1970s, a disease called the Guillain-Barre Syndrome, which produces polio-like symptoms, was linked to the swine flu vaccine. Researchers agreed that the “relative risk” of developing Guillain-Barre Syndrome was 12 times greater in vaccinees than in non-vaccinees.

While no one doubts that some vaccines have caused injuries — and even deaths — health and government officials argue that bad reactions to vaccines are rare and the long-term benefits of vaccines proven. “Without question, the benefits of vaccines so far outweigh the risks,” said Satcher.

He noted that while polio has all but disappeared in the United States, the remaining roughly eight cases per year that do occur are a direct result of the vaccine.

Other critics contend that the “hero” in the fight against infectious diseases is not vaccination, but improved nutrition and environmental sanitation.

The Task Force agrees that, with the exception of safe water, nothing has had as much impact on deaths from infectious diseases as vaccinations – not even antibiotics.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags