Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

ASIA-DEVELOPMENT: AsDB, Indigenous Folk Size Each Other Up

Johanna Son

MANILA, Jan 18 1996 (IPS) - Edtami Mansayagan, from an indigenous community in southern Philippines, admitted being uneasy about attending a meeting that the Asian Development Bank (AsDB) organised with Asia’s native peoples recently.

“I fear that my name could be hurt because of future Bank policies and my attendance at this meeting,” Mansayagan said.

“Development is something that comes from outside. Thus it is viewed as something that destroys,” added an Indonesian participant at the November seminar.

These remarks reflected the discomfort, even suspicion, that representatives of various Asian indigenous groups felt as they met Bank representatives in what the AsDB said was the “first direct, official encounter” between the two sides.

To help break the ice, the three-day consultation was not the usual formal Bank meeting its Manila headquarters but was held in a beach resort in Batangas province south of the Philippine capital.

Like other multilateral financial institutions, the AsDB and development activists and indigenous groups are often on opposite sides of the fence.

Big projects often displace indigenous people living in upland areas targeted for development projects, activists say.

“The hill-forest regions are the sites of major dams and hydro- electric projects, which have led to the displacement of large numbers of indigenous peoples, for the benefit of the plains,” Dev Nathan and Govind Kelkar of the Bangkok-based Asian Institute of Technology said in a paper.

These are now “being seen as profitable areas for investment other than the former simple extraction of forest produce and minerals”, they said. Upland areas are also being tapped in the wake of limits of fossil fuel and in the search for biological materials useful in agriculture or medicine.

Activists have been seeking a stop to all large dam projects planned for the Mekong River, including a 210-megawatt dawn upstream of the Mekong in Laos.

They say the resettlement of displaced native peoples has not worked, citing the case of the Batang Ai dam resettlement scheme in eastern Malaysia. The AsDB cites this as a model of culturally compatible resettlement, but an Asian network of NGOs says promises of free homes, water, electricity and jobs were broken.

The AsDB organised the November meeting to discuss its proposed policy paper on indigenous peoples, designed to help Bank staff and projects carry out more development-friendly projects that affect their communities and habitats.

There are more than 1.8 million indigenous people in Asia — 92 million in East Asia, 31 million in South-east Asia and 63 million in South Asia. Indonesia and India have 200 and 300 ethnic groups respectively.

Some indigenous groups are divided by national boundaries, like the Naga people split between India and Burma, and Papuans found in both Indonesia’s Irian Jaya and Papua New Guinea.

In the latest ‘AsDB Review’, Bank official Thomas Colvin described as “difficult” the early stages of the consultation with indigenous people.

The indigenous peoples’ representatives were not keen on formal presentations, were often quiet and chose to discuss issues among themselves, he said. But they were curious about how the Bank’s policies affect their communities, he observed.

For its part the AsDB and the World Bank, which also attended the meeting, were eager to discuss the meaning of “informed participation” of indigenous folk in development projects.

The AsDB’s draft paper says: “As population pressure increases and the search for new resources cotninues, many development projects will be located in more remote hills, forests and border areas.”

These are often the homelands of indigenous peoples, who may be adversely impacted by such projects. While they have a right to share in the “benefits of development”, the paper says, “they also have a right to reject and protect themselves from changes that are harmful to their sustenance and way of life”.

The Bank proposes to “ensure that the development process facilitates their informed participation and fosters full respect for their dignity, human rights and cultural uniqueness”.

But talk of ‘development’ led to its varied definitions, as indigenous groups said they did not simply want to be integrated into market economies.

A Dayak representative from Indonesia, Stepanus Djuweng, defined development thus: “When mountains have tigers, when rivers have dragons and fish, when there is rice, when there is no war or conflict, then we have it”.

An International Labour Organisation official remarked that the time frame for projects as viewed by international organisations and native peoples were different. A Dutch official said that while indigenous folk were talking about ‘self-mobilisation’, aid experts were talking about ‘consultation’.

Nathan and Kelkar said all discussions about indigenous people’s rights should start with a recognition of their rights over land they have lived on for generations. This, they said, is the “starting point of a development strategy for the indigenous people”.

“So long as the indigenous people do not have tenure they are at best interlopers on their own lands, at worst they are criminals,” they point out.

The two experts say there have been improvements in the legal status of native peoples, especially in the Philippines and Nepal. But in some countries the ‘joint management’ of forests is little more than using cheap labour in return for a meagre share of forest income.

As one representative of an indigenous community said: “Before consultations can take place, institutions must recognise that indigenous peoples are people and have rights.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags