Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour

INDONESIA-LABOUR: Minimum Wage Hike is Hardly Reason to Celebrate

Yuli Ismartono

JAKARTA, Jan 16 1996 (IPS) - April 1 should be a day of celebration for Indonesia’s lowest paid employees who are then due for wage hikes. But workers say there is little to toast since inflation means the increase will hardly enhance their spending power.

“We rarely win. Our pay raise always come a bit too late to catch up with prices,” said Wati, a factory worker explaining her lukewarm reaction to the 10.6 per cent wage increase, announced by the government last week.

Labour union representatives had been negotiating for a 15 per cent increase, so that some of the workers’ basic minimum needs would have been covered considering a running inflation rate of 8.6 per cent.

“Our target was to improve the welfare of the workers as well as their families,” said Andi Hisbuldin Patunur, secretary-general of the government-sanctioned All-Indonesia Workers Union (SPSI).

Economists say the raise will increase the workers’ purchasing power by only about two per cent so that Indonesian wages will still rank among the lowest in the ASEAN grouping of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam.

In Jakarta, workers that will earn the new daily wage of 5,200 rupiah (2.30 dollars) will have to fork out half of that just to pay rent for their very basic accommodation that comes to around 75,000 rupiah (33.30 dollars).

“This smacks of political expedience rather realistic need,” said one analyst, who thinks the announcement was made in anticipation of the coming year’s general elections campaign.

But the labour department defended its decision by saying the rise was the most feasible, given the present economic prospects. If the rise were any higher, government officials contend, small and medium-sized companies could be adversely affected.

This may be true, but it brings to light another issue. For the past 28 years, since President Suharto came to power, Indonesia’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) has averaged 6.9 per cent. The World Bank says this performance is the fourth best among countries with populations of more than 30 million.

But despite last year’s upbeat economic report — citing a continuing seven per cent annual growth rate — the World Bank warned of the widening income disparities caused by inequitable distribution of wealth and its implications for the efficiency and equity of private sector growth.

So that while statistics show that only 18 per cent of the population now lives below the poverty line, compared with 60 per cent in 1979, this still means that millions of poor languish in squalid city villages in the shadow of Jakarta’s multitude of skyscrapers.

Hidden poverty also exists in the rural areas.

Of the minimum daily wages among Indonesia’s 27 provinces, depending on costs of living indexes and levels of economic development, the highest is 7,350 rupiahs (3.20 dollars) in the industrial estate island of Batam just off Singapore. The lowest is 3,200 rupiah (1.40 dollars) in Yogyakarta, central Java and central Sulawesi province.

The problem is compounded by unscrupulous employers in the private sector who interpret present labour regulations for the company’s benefit and to the detriment of the worker.

The current regulation stipulates the minimum wage set by government must amount to at least 75 per cent of the employee’s basic income, with the remaining 25 per cent as allowances. What some companies do is to charge various extra expenses to the employees, thereby legally avoiding the basic minimum level.

To counter this, the government is considering a proposal to redefine the minimum wage regulations by specifically referring it only as basic wages and excluding allowances.

“We hope that the number of labour disputes will be reduced if this revision is made into a ministerial ruling,” said Andi Hisbuldin of the SPSI, which along with the Indonesian Association of Employers (APINDO) is reviewing the proposal.

Workers strikes in Indonesia have steadily declined over the past few years, from 1,700 in 1993, to 500 in 1994 and 200 in 1995. With elections constitutionally due in 1997, the government more than ever wants to avoid labour unrest.

As such, the government has announced plans to revamp and improve vocational training centres, and to establish industrial apprenticeship programmes.

Labour Minister Abdul Latief has also stressed that his ministry will strictly monitor and sanction companies which fail to adhere to the new minimum wage law which he reminded is aimed at helping those at “the lowest pay level”.

Companies violating the rule are no longer be given warnings, but taken directly to court. Forty-eight companies were fined last year.

But labour activists say that the government still has a long way to go to empower workers and ensure their rights.

For example, companies employing more than 25 workers are required by law to allow them SPSI representation, and also to sign a collective labour agreement detailing workers rights and obligations.

But SPSI data records only 11 per cent of the 67,000 companies registered with having 25 or more workers, have signed the collective labour agreement, meaning that the majority of workers lack legal protection.

Activists are also pressing for the right to form their own unions — independent of the only one allowed by the government.

The political situation as it is, the government is presently unlikely to give in to this demand. It has instead allowed the SPSI to revert to being a federation of trade unions, currently covering 13 sectors.

The unions are reported to be considering drawing up a proposal to have minimum wage levels determined not by region, as it currently stands, but by profession or sectors, such as banking, trade and textile, in order to ensure more equitable distribution.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags