Europe, Headlines, Human Rights

HUMAN RIGHTS/EUROPE: U.S. Style Youth Detention Centres Condemned

Angeline Oyog and Darsha Damayanthi

PARIS, Jan 11 1996 (IPS) - Juvenile court magistrates and policemen are resisting efforts by British and French governments to get tough with teenage lawbreakers, to put the worst offenders into severe new detention centres and scare them out of a life of crime.

Conservative governments across Europe are responding to reports of rises in juvenile crime by advocating the introduction of tough youth detention centres where the daily regime is modelled on U.S. military-style prison camps — nicknamed ‘Boot Camps’.

Such centres, say the critics, will be little more than training centres for crime that will turn youthful petty offenders into full fledged adult criminals — fitter, leaner and more aggressive.

The first camp opens in Britain this summer, for 60 18 to 21 year old young offenders, at Thorn Cross in Cheshire, northern England. But in Britain, as in France, the concept of such camps has been attacked not only by liberal social groups, but also by the police and the judiciary.

On both sides of the channel the scheme is derided as a thoughtless attempt by right-wing governments under pressure from factions even further on the right to be seen to be “getting tough” with juvenile crime.

“An imprisoned minor may come out of jail an animal,” Pierre Laurent, adviser to the Autonomous Federation of Police Unions told IPS. “We ought to know, because we are on the frontlines.” The proposed systems may also breach international conventions on the rights of the child.

“Boot camps will not work,” said Harry Fletcher, assistant general secretary of the British National Association of Probation Officers. He said the British government tried them in 1981 — dubbing the regimes ‘short, sharp shocks’ — and abandoned them four years later as a failure.

” The new regimes are a political gimmick based on hard labour, running at the double and endless drill, ” he told reporters when the British camp was named last year. “What was required to reduce crime,” he added, “is support, education and training for work’.

A British Prison Service delegation which visited a Maryland boot camp in the United States two years ago was shocked to discover inmates being routinely referred to as “maggots, dummies and trash”. Some boys at these camps are as young as six.

Their report concluded that the detainees were “utterly dominated and controlled,” and there was “there was precious little room for self-discipline, or the development of initiative and personal growth”.

Under pressure the original plan to duplicate the U.S. style camps in Britain has been softened in favour of a regime described as “a high-impact regime designed to provide a challenging and energetic approach to deal with young offenders”.

Details of the French plan are proving hard to come by. “For sure, the government wants to get more repressive. But the problem is to find out if the measures it is concocting are pertinent and respond to real needs,” said Jean-Pierre Rosenczveig, a children’s court judge and secretary general of the French Council of Associations for the Rights of the Child (COFRADE).

While the methods of dealing with the problem are in dispute, the problem appears to be real enough and growing. Seventy percent of young offenders jailed by the present British system return to crime.

The French Union of Chiefs of Police and High Officials of the National Police (SCHFPN) say that while general crime figures remain relatively stable the number of juvenile crimes climbed by 15 percent in 1994.

“The total number of offences could even be underestimated, as silence reigns on this issue,” it claimed. In the first quarter of 1995, French youth under 18 years were allegedly responsible for 45 percent of thefts with violence and 30 percent of petty crimes like burglary and car theft.

Painting a graphic picture of “gangsters in shorts” the SCHFPN claimed juvenile crime, especially in the poorer inner cities, is “expanding” and likely to become a “major risk”.

Rosenczveig said he was ready to listen to the arguments of others and conceded that the general public felt that there was a problem. “Nevertheless,” he warned, “the global tenor of government plans is to become more repressive with youngsters, and that is worrisome.”

He said the French Justice Ministry has given assurances to go slow on the detention centres. “But the proposed law will still be debated by the National Assembly and some want to get even tougher.

“The problem is, such measures would violate the principles and the spirit of the Convention on the Protection of the Rights of Children.”

The French Interior and Justice Ministries are targeting the entire concept of juvenile law, established in 1945, which advocated educational methods over strong-arm tactics, says COFRADE. The planned changes also propose speeding up the process of trying and sentencing young offenders found guilty.

If the objective is to speed up legal procedures, the courts can render verdicts very quickly, said Rosenczveig. But the 1945 law allows more deliberation of the appropriate penalties to impose.

“There must be time to understand why the teenager did what he did and to make him understand what he did. The government proposals seems to want to catch the young offender red-handed and that is easily translated into imprisonment,” he said.

Another concern voiced on both sides of the Channel is that ethnic minorities will be unfairly treated by the new system.

“There seems to be some invisible hand drawing unhealthy parallels between juvenile delinquency and the inner cities, some of which are heavily populated by immigrants,” said Jean-Claude Bouvier, secretary-general of the French Union of Magistrates.

“Even if such parallels are not in black and white, they are in people’s heads,” he added.

COFRADE argues that the new proposals could end up simply locking up a entire problem and forgetting about it, as appeared to be happening in the United States. “We know full well that these youths concerned are of North or Central African origin, just as the youths concerned in the U.S. are Afro-Americans.”

Poor areas in economic decline produce poor people desperate enough to turn to crime and young people growing up in such environments soon lose track of conventional concepts of right and wrong, say most groups.

Others reject the importation of U.S. penal systems when they are clearly failing to reduce crime. The United States has about 1.4 million criminals in various types of jails, as a proportion of its population, almost five times as many as Britain. Yet 24,526 murders were recorded in the U.S. in 1993.

“Paris is not Chicago. But there seems to be this feeling of increasing insecurity being whipped up and we know that political campaigns are propelled by feelings of insecurity,” said Laurent.

“We believe that the young people are not the ones who should be blamed, but the kind of society we have created for them,” he added.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags